Cause or coincidence?
The bigger spender wins about nine House races in ten. Political scientists have spent fifty years asking whether the money did it, or whether money simply flows to the candidate who was going to win anyway.
The problem with the scoreboard
Winners attract money. Donors, parties and interest groups give to candidates they expect to win: incumbents, and nominees in districts that lean their way. A safe incumbent may raise ten times what a token challenger does and would have won with none of it. So a count of races won by the bigger spender mixes two things: what money does, and where money goes.
Vulnerable incumbents spend more. An incumbent in trouble raises and spends heavily, then often does worse than a safe colleague who spent little. Read naively, that makes incumbent spending look useless or even harmful. Much of the literature is an argument about how to correct for this.
So researchers look for comparisons that hold the candidates fixed: the same two candidates meeting twice, changes in the cost of advertising across media markets, field experiments that randomly assign who gets contacted. Those studies agree less with the scoreboard than you might expect. See the scoreboard itself →
And a dollar is not always a dollar. In the weeks before an election, broadcasters must sell candidates airtime at their lowest rate (47 U.S.C. 315(b)). Super PACs and other outside groups get no such discount, so a campaign’s dollar buys more advertising than an outside group’s.
The studies
49 studies, grouped by what they found. Each links to the paper. The grouping is ours; the findings are stated as the authors report them.
Spending buys less than it looks (13)
Studies finding small or no effects once you account for who gets the money.
Steven D. Levitt (1994), “Using Repeat Challengers to Estimate the Effect of Campaign Spending on Election Outcomes in the U.S. House”
Comparing House races in which the same two candidates face each other more than once, Levitt finds the effect of challenger spending is about ten times smaller than earlier studies estimated. He concludes campaign spending has a very small effect on outcomes no matter which candidate spends it. He reads this as favoring spending limits but not public financing.
How: First-differenced regressions on repeat match-ups between the same House candidates, which removes fixed candidate and district traits. Journal of Political Economy 102(4): 777-798. Read the paper
Jeffrey Milyo; Timothy Groseclose (1999), “The Electoral Effects of Incumbent Wealth”
Using data on House incumbents seeking reelection in 1992, the authors find wealthy incumbents do not raise or spend more campaign money and do not win larger vote shares. Incumbent wealth does, however, deter high-quality challengers.
How: Regression analysis of personal wealth, fundraising, spending and vote share for 1992 House incumbents. Journal of Law and Economics 42(2): 699-722. Read the paper
Jeffrey Milyo; David Primo; Timothy Groseclose (2000), “Corporate PAC Campaign Contributions in Perspective”
The authors argue scholarly attention to corporate PAC money is out of proportion to its size: corporate PAC contributions are only about 10% of congressional campaign spending. Large corporations put considerably more money into lobbying or philanthropy than their PACs give to candidates.
How: Descriptive comparison of corporate PAC contributions with total campaign spending, lobbying outlays and corporate charitable giving. Business and Politics 2(1): 75-88. Read the paper
Stephen Ansolabehere; John M. de Figueiredo; James M. Snyder Jr. (2003), “Why Is There So Little Money in U.S. Politics?”
Candidates and parties raised about $3 billion in the 1999-2000 cycle, against roughly $2 trillion in federal spending; about $2.4 billion came from individuals, whose average contribution was about $115. Only about one in four earlier studies supports the idea that contributions buy legislators' roll-call votes, and the authors' own estimates find changes in donations do not change a legislator's voting. They argue giving is mainly a form of consumption or participation, not investment, and note interest groups spent about ten times more on lobbying ($3 billion in 1997-98) than on PAC contributions.
How: Descriptive accounting of FEC contribution data, a survey of prior roll-call studies, and OLS/instrumental-variable regressions of Chamber of Commerce voting scores on contributions. Journal of Economic Perspectives 17(1): 105-130. Read the paper
Jennifer A. Steen (2006), “Self-Financed Candidates in Congressional Elections”Partly confirmed
Steen's empirical study of wealthy self-funded congressional candidates concludes they cannot simply buy seats: according to the publisher's description, the large majority of self-financers lose. The book also examines their effects on competition and campaign rhetoric.
How: Empirical analysis of self-financed House and Senate candidacies and their outcomes. University of Michigan Press (book). Read the paper
Adam R. Brown (2013), “Does Money Buy Votes? The Case of Self-Financed Gubernatorial Candidates, 1998–2008”
Brown argues the apparent power of money is greatly overstated because strategic donors give to candidates who would win anyway. His evidence: money that gubernatorial candidates give themselves, which is not steered by strategic donors, has no statistically detectable effect on results, while money raised from others is associated with winning.
How: Regression analysis separating self-financed from externally raised spending in governor's races, 1998-2008. Political Behavior 35(1): 21-41. Read the paper
Omar S. Bashir (2015), “Testing Inferences about American Politics: A Review of the "Oligarchy" Result”
Bashir argues the Gilens-Page statistical model is prone to underestimating the influence of median-income citizens by a wide margin. In their own data, average Americans got their preferred policy outcome about as often as elites did when the two groups disagreed. He concludes the evidence that average citizens are ignored is weaker than claimed.
How: Re-examination of the Gilens-Page dataset with simulation-style tests of the original model and descriptive win-rate comparisons. Research & Politics 2(4). Read the paper
Peter K. Enns (2015), “Relative Policy Support and Coincidental Representation”
Enns shows that even on issues where the wealthy and the middle disagree, policy ends up about where it would if lawmakers represented the middle class and ignored the affluent. The reason is that the policies most (or least) popular with the middle are usually also most (or least) popular with the rich. He finds more room for unequal representation of strong partisan preferences than of income groups.
How: Reanalysis of the Gilens policy-preference data comparing relative support across income groups. Perspectives on Politics 13(4): 1053-1064. Read the paper
Seth E. Masket; Michael G. Miller (2015), “Does Public Election Funding Create More Extreme Legislators? Evidence from Arizona and Maine”
Comparing publicly funded ('clean elections') and traditionally funded state legislators in Arizona and Maine, the authors find essentially no meaningful difference in voting behavior. Privately financed legislators were not consistently more or less ideologically extreme than publicly financed ones.
How: Comparison of roll-call-based ideology of clean-funded versus privately funded legislators in two states. State Politics & Policy Quarterly 15(1): 24-40. Read the paper
J. Alexander Branham; Stuart N. Soroka; Christopher Wlezien (2017), “When Do the Rich Win?”Partly confirmed
The article re-examines claims that U.S. policy responds mainly or only to the richest Americans, asking how often the rich and the middle class actually disagree and who prevails when they do. The paper's specific results could not be read from an accessible source today.
How: Reanalysis of the Gilens policy-preference dataset (per the article's framing). Political Science Quarterly 132(1): 43-62. Read the paper
Joshua L. Kalla; David E. Broockman (2018), “The Minimal Persuasive Effects of Campaign Contact in General Elections: Evidence from 49 Field Experiments”
The authors' best estimate of the persuasive effect of campaign contact and advertising on candidate choice in U.S. general elections is zero. A meta-analysis of 40 field experiments averages zero, and nine new experiments (a roughly tenfold increase in evidence on personal contact) also average zero. Persuasion appears only when a candidate holds an unusually unpopular position and the campaign invests heavily in finding persuadable voters, or when contact happens long before Election Day, and that early effect decays.
How: Meta-analysis of 40 prior field experiments plus nine original field experiments. American Political Science Review 112(1): 148-166. Read the paper
David M. Primo; Jeffrey D. Milyo (2020), “Campaign Finance and American Democracy: What the Public Really Thinks and Why It Matters”
Using original survey data, the authors challenge the claim that stricter campaign finance laws would restore trust in government. Many Americans back reform in principle but doubt it would curb corruption, which they see as pervasive; support for restrictions splits along party lines. The authors conclude public attitudes about money in politics reflect broader fears about democracy that campaign finance reform will not relieve.
How: Original surveys of public (and expert) opinion on money in politics and campaign finance reform. University of Chicago Press (book). Read the paper
Alexander Coppock; Seth J. Hill; Lynn Vavreck (2020), “The small effects of political advertising are small regardless of context, message, sender, or receiver: Evidence from 59 real-time randomized experiments”
Testing 49 political ads in 59 experiments on 34,000 people during the 2016 presidential campaign, the authors find small average effects on candidate favorability and vote choice. The effects stayed small across senders, viewers' partisanship, attack versus promotional content, battleground status and timing, so small averages are not hiding large offsetting effects.
How: Weekly randomized survey experiments exposing respondents to real campaign ads during the 2016 campaign. Science Advances 6(36). Read the paper
It depends (18)
Studies finding that effects vary by who spends, on what, and in which races.
Gary C. Jacobson (1978), “The Effects of Campaign Spending in Congressional Elections”
Reanalyzing 1972 and 1974 House and Senate spending data, Jacobson finds that what challengers spend affects the outcome far more than what incumbents spend. Survey evidence suggests spending buys non-incumbents the voter recognition that incumbents already have. The abstract gives no single effect-size number.
How: OLS and two-stage least squares regressions on 1972 and 1974 congressional races, plus 1972/1974 SRC survey data on candidate recall. American Political Science Review 72(2): 469-491. Read the paper
Gary C. Jacobson (1990), “The Effects of Campaign Spending in House Elections: New Evidence for Old Arguments”
Jacobson argues that Green and Krasno (1988) did not solve the simultaneity problem. Using a panel survey that tracks changes in voters' intentions over the last six weeks of the 1986 campaign, he again finds challenger spending moves voters far more than incumbent spending.
How: Analysis of individual-level change in vote intention in the 1986 ABC News/Washington Post Congressional District Poll panel. American Journal of Political Science 34(2), starting p. 334. Read the paper
Robert S. Erikson; Thomas R. Palfrey (2000), “Equilibria in Campaign Spending Games: Theory and Data”
A game-theoretic model predicts that the bias from spending and expected vote determining each other should be absent in races expected to be close and get steadily worse in safer races. The authors report that comparing simple OLS estimates for expected-close versus other House incumbent races over two decades confirms this pattern. The abstract gives no effect-size number.
How: Formal model of candidate spending plus OLS regressions on two decades of House incumbent races split by expected closeness. American Political Science Review 94(3): 595-609. Read the paper
Alan S. Gerber (2004), “Does Campaign Spending Work? Field Experiments Provide Evidence and Suggest New Theory”
Field experiments in partisan contests found incumbent campaign efforts failed to raise the incumbent's vote share while challenger campaigns were effective. Gerber offers a theory: incumbents who maximize their chance of winning rather than vote share may rationally spend in ways that barely move vote share, so small measured effects of incumbent spending need not mean the money is wasted.
How: Several randomized field experiments on campaign communications, plus a formal analysis of optimal incumbent spending. American Behavioral Scientist 47(5): 541-574. Read the paper
Thomas Stratmann (2005), “Some talk: Money in politics. A (partial) review of the literature”Partly confirmed
A literature review covering methodological problems in studying campaign spending and contributions, what is known about the effects of spending and advertising in candidate and ballot-measure elections, whether contributions benefit contributors, studies exploiting changes in state campaign finance laws, and what interest-group giving patterns reveal about donor motives. The abstract does not state a bottom-line effect size.
How: Narrative review of empirical and theoretical campaign-finance research. Public Choice 124(1-2): 135-156. Read the paper
Alan S. Gerber; James G. Gimpel; Donald P. Green; Daron R. Shaw (2011), “How Large and Long-lasting Are the Persuasive Effects of Televised Campaign Ads? Results from a Randomized Field Experiment”
In what the authors call the first large-scale experiment with paid political ads, about $2 million of TV and radio advertising for an incumbent in the early months of a 2006 governor's race was deployed with randomly assigned start dates and volumes across media markets. Tracking polls of about 1,000 registered voters a day showed the TV ads had strong effects on vote preference that faded quickly.
How: Randomized field experiment assigning ad timing and volume by media market, measured with daily tracking polls. American Political Science Review 105(1): 135-150. Read the paper
Matilde Bombardini; Francesco Trebbi (2011), “Votes or money? Theory and evidence from the US Congress”
Interest groups' contributions to a legislator follow a hump shape in the group's share of district voters: mid-sized groups give the most, because large groups can deliver votes directly instead of money. The authors' structural model also yields an estimate of spending effectiveness: an additional vote costs a politician about $145 on average.
How: Bargaining model estimated structurally with district-level PAC and individual donations and sectoral employment. Journal of Public Economics 95(7-8): 587-611. Read the paper
Alexander Fouirnaies; Andrew B. Hall (2014), “The Financial Incumbency Advantage: Causes and Consequences”
Winning office causes the incumbent party's share of campaign donations to rise by roughly 20-25 percentage points, in both the U.S. House and state legislatures. The gain comes mainly from access-seeking interest groups, especially those in heavily regulated industries, rather than from the perks of office. The authors conclude such groups are an important source of incumbents' electoral security.
How: Regression discontinuity design on close elections for the U.S. House and state legislatures. Journal of Politics 76(3): 711-724. Read the paper
Adam Bonica (2014), “Mapping the Ideological Marketplace”
Bonica builds ideology scores for candidates and donors from more than 100 million contribution records in state and federal elections. Because donors give across offices and levels of government, the method puts members of Congress, presidents, state officials, interest groups and individual donors on one common scale, including non-incumbents. This is a measurement paper; the abstract reports no estimate of money's effect on election results.
How: Scaling model (the basis of the DIME/CFscore data) applied to contribution records, validated against other ideology measures. American Journal of Political Science 58(2): 367-386. Read the paper
Raymond J. La Raja; Brian F. Schaffner (2015), “Campaign Finance and Political Polarization: When Purists Prevail”
Drawing on more than 20 years of data from the 50 states and Congress, the authors argue that reforms meant to restrict money in politics have unintentionally favored ideologically extreme candidates, because the rules let ideological donors and groups dominate campaign funding. They propose routing more money through party organizations, which they find are less driven by activists and more pragmatic.
How: Comparative analysis of state campaign finance laws, contribution patterns and legislative polarization across the 50 states and Congress. University of Michigan Press (book, open access). Read the paper
Gary C. Jacobson (2015), “How Do Campaigns Matter?”
A review concluding that election campaigns do matter in several important ways, and that the useful questions are when, where, how and for whom. It surveys research on events and advertising in presidential races, campaign spending in down-ballot races, mobilization and turnout, vote choice and negative campaigning, and who is persuadable.
How: Narrative review of recent high-quality campaign-effects studies. Annual Review of Political Science 18: 31-47. Read the paper
Adam Bonica (2016), “Avenues of influence: on the political expenditures of corporations and their directors and executives”
Using a new database of contributions from Fortune 500 directors and executives, Bonica finds political giving is nearly universal among corporate elites. Compared with corporate PACs, these individuals give more ideologically, are more willing to back non-incumbents and are less focused on powerful legislators. Preferences vary widely across and within firms, and bipartisan boardrooms are common.
How: Descriptive analysis of individual contribution records matched to Fortune 500 directors and executives, compared with corporate PAC giving. Business and Politics 18(4): 367-394. Read the paper
Alex Keena; Misty Knight-Finley (2019), “Are Small Donors Polarizing? A Longitudinal Study of the Senate”
Tracking senators over time, the authors find that small-donor money received in past elections does not change a senator's later voting behavior. Causation instead runs the other way: how a senator votes in the run-up to reelection significantly affects how much small-donor money they raise. They conclude polarization is not an inevitable result of reforms that expand small-donor participation.
How: Longitudinal analysis of U.S. senators' small-donor receipts and roll-call ideology across six-year terms. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy 18(2): 132-144. Read the paper
Tyler Culberson; Michael P. McDonald; Suzanne M. Robbins (2019), “Small Donors in Congressional Elections”
Using internal FEC data on small donations in U.S. House races from 2006 to 2010, the authors find small-donor supply is unrelated to district income, that incumbents, challengers and open-seat candidates attract small donors about equally, and that candidates in the most competitive races raise the most. They also find ideologically extreme incumbents tend to raise more from small donors, which they say should temper reformers' enthusiasm.
How: Regression analysis of FEC records of sub-threshold (small) contributions to House candidates, 2006-2010. American Politics Research 47(5): 970-999. Read the paper
Richard H. Pildes (2019), “Small-Donor-Based Campaign-Finance Reform and Political Polarization”
A law-review essay arguing that building public financing around small-donor matching (as in H.R. 1's six-to-one match) could worsen polarization. Pildes cites research that individual donors are more ideologically extreme than the public and that the limited evidence does not show small donors are less extreme than large ones, while acknowledging scholars such as Malbin who dispute that small donors favor extremes. He prefers traditional public financing from general revenues.
How: Legal and policy essay synthesizing existing political-science evidence; no original data analysis. Yale Law Journal Forum, vol. 129 (18 November 2019). Read the paper
Laurent Bouton; Julia Cagé; Edgard Dewitte; Vincent Pons (2022), “Small Campaign Donors”
Building a comprehensive dataset of small U.S. donors for 2005-2020 from fundraising-platform filings, the authors find the number of small donors has surged but their total giving has not grown faster than large donors'. Small donors look more like the general population than large donors do, yet remain disproportionately white and affluent, and they support similar candidates to large donors. The authors conclude small donors are unlikely to transform U.S. elections.
How: Analysis of a new dataset of small contributions reported by fundraising platforms, 2005-2020. NBER Working Paper 30050 (issued May 2022; later revised). Read the paper
David E. Broockman; Joshua L. Kalla (2023), “When and Why Are Campaigns' Persuasive Effects Small? Evidence from the 2020 U.S. Presidential Election”
In four survey experiments during the 2020 presidential election (113,742 respondents, 291 messages), voters were more persuadable about candidates they knew less about, and messages with more information were more persuasive. Persuasive messages did shift evaluations and vote choice, including partisan defection. The authors conclude small campaign effects partly reflect voters already being well informed, not just blind party loyalty.
How: Four large randomized survey experiments testing 291 campaign messages. American Journal of Political Science 67(4): 833-849. Read the paper
Danielle M. Thomsen (2023), “Competition in Congressional Elections: Money versus Votes”
Measuring competition in U.S. House primaries from 1980 to 2020 by pre-election fundraising instead of vote totals, Thomsen finds competition looks markedly worse on the money measure. The gap is largest in open-seat primaries and is driven largely by candidates with little chance of winning.
How: Descriptive comparison of receipt-based and vote-share-based competition measures using a dataset of pre-election campaign receipts, 1980-2020. American Political Science Review 117(2): 675-691. Read the paper
Money matters (18)
Studies finding real effects of spending on votes, or of donations on access and policy.
Donald Philip Green; Jonathan S. Krasno (1988), “Salvation for the Spendthrift Incumbent: Reestimating the Effects of Campaign Spending in House Elections”
Using the 1978 House elections, the authors argue Jacobson understated the effect of incumbent spending because of three specification problems: no control for challenger quality, ignored interaction effects, and poor handling of reverse causation. After correcting these, the marginal effect of incumbent spending is substantial and in some circumstances on par with challenger spending. Challenger spending still matters, especially at high levels.
How: Re-estimation of House vote models for 1978 with a challenger-quality control, interaction terms and a simultaneous-equations treatment of spending. American Journal of Political Science 32(4), starting p. 884. Read the paper
Alan I. Abramowitz (1988), “Explaining Senate Election Outcomes”
Analyzing Senate contests from 1974 to 1986, Abramowitz finds candidate characteristics affected outcomes more than state political traits or national conditions. He concludes money was probably more important than ever, especially for challengers and open-seat candidates.
How: Aggregate regression analysis with the individual Senate contest as the unit, 1974-1986. American Political Science Review 82(2): 385-403. Read the paper
Alan Gerber (1998), “Estimating the Effect of Campaign Spending on Senate Election Outcomes Using Instrumental Variables”
Once spending is instrumented with factors that affect fundraising ability (such as candidate wealth), the marginal effects of incumbent and challenger spending in Senate races are roughly equal. In an average Senate election the incumbent's spending advantage is estimated to add about 6% to the incumbent's vote share. Gerber concludes that equalizing spending would noticeably improve challengers' chances.
How: Instrumental-variables regressions of Senate vote share on incumbent and challenger spending. American Political Science Review 92(2): 401-411. Read the paper
Gregory A. Huber; Kevin Arceneaux (2007), “Identifying the Persuasive Effects of Presidential Advertising”
Exploiting the fact that some residents of non-battleground states saw heavy 2000 presidential advertising only because their media market spilled over from a competitive state, the authors find little evidence that ads mobilize or inform citizens but strong evidence that they persuade.
How: Natural experiment matching local ad-broadcast records to National Annenberg Election Survey respondents in uncontested states. American Journal of Political Science 51(4): 957-977. Read the paper
Neil Malhotra (2008), “The Impact of Public Financing on Electoral Competition: Evidence from Arizona and Maine”
After Arizona and Maine adopted full public financing ('clean elections') in 2000, competition increased significantly in districts where challengers accepted public money, on two measures of competitiveness. Malhotra concludes access to campaign funds is an important determinant of competitiveness, though public financing is not a cure-all.
How: Comparison of competitiveness in Arizona and Maine state races by whether challengers accepted public funds, using two competitiveness measures. State Politics & Policy Quarterly 8(3): 263-281. Read the paper
Kenneth Benoit; Michael Marsh (2008), “The Campaign Value of Incumbency: A New Solution to the Puzzle of Less Effective Incumbent Spending”
Using the 2002 Irish general election, the authors argue incumbent spending looks ineffective because incumbents also campaign with unmeasured, publicly funded perks of office. Once the value of those office resources is measured, that hidden 'spending' is very effective at winning votes and seats, apparently more so than ordinary campaign spending.
How: Regression analysis of candidate-level declared spending and assigned office allowances in Ireland's 2002 election. American Journal of Political Science 52(4): 874-890. Read the paper
Martin Gilens; Benjamin I. Page (2014), “Testing Theories of American Politics: Elites, Interest Groups, and Average Citizens”
Analyzing 1,779 policy issues in a single multivariate model, the authors report that economic elites and organized groups representing business have substantial independent effects on U.S. policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence. They read this as support for 'economic-elite domination' and 'biased pluralism' theories over majoritarian ones. The study concerns policy outcomes, not election results or campaign spending directly.
How: Multivariate regression of policy adoption on the measured preferences of median-income citizens, affluent citizens and interest groups across 1,779 proposed policy changes. Perspectives on Politics 12(3): 564-581. Read the paper
Andrew B. Hall (2014), “How the Public Funding of Elections Increases Candidate Polarization”Partly confirmed
Studying five states that adopted public funding at different times (Minnesota, Wisconsin, Arizona, Maine, Connecticut), Hall reports that public funding increases legislative polarization. His explanation is that it removes contributions from access-seeking interest groups, which give more moderately than individual donors; it also erases incumbents' financial and electoral advantages. He cautions that effects depend on opt-in rates, which were falling in Arizona.
How: Difference-in-differences style comparison of treated and control states using Shor-McCarty state legislator ideology scores. Working paper (Harvard University), 2014; unpublished. Read the paper
Michael J. Barber (2016), “Ideological Donors, Contribution Limits, and the Polarization of American Legislatures”
Using variation in state contribution limits across states and over about 20 years, Barber finds higher limits on individual contributions lead to more polarized legislators, while higher limits on PAC contributions lead to more moderate ones. The explanation offered is that individual donors favor ideologically extreme candidates and access-seeking PACs favor moderates.
How: Panel analysis of an original dataset of state contribution limits and state legislator ideology. Journal of Politics 78(1): 296-310. Read the paper
Joshua L. Kalla; David E. Broockman (2016), “Campaign Contributions Facilitate Access to Congressional Officials: A Randomized Field Experiment”
A political organization sought meetings with 191 congressional offices for local members who were campaign donors, randomly varying whether the office was told the attendees were donors. Senior policymakers made themselves available three to four times more often when told the attendees were donors. The experiment measures access, not votes or election results.
How: Randomized field experiment across 191 congressional offices. American Journal of Political Science 60(3): 545-558. Read the paper
Tilman Klumpp; Hugo M. Mialon; Michael A. Williams (2016), “The Business of American Democracy: Citizens United, Independent Spending, and Elections”
Comparing states whose bans on corporate and union independent spending were struck down by Citizens United with states that had no such bans, the authors find the ruling is associated with about a 4 percentage point increase in Republicans' probability of winning state house races overall, and 10 or more points in several states. They also examine effects on incumbent reelection, candidate entry and direct contributions.
How: Difference-in-differences across states with and without pre-2010 bans on corporate/union independent expenditures. Journal of Law and Economics 59(1): 1-43. Read the paper
Andrew B. Hall (2016), “Systemic Effects of Campaign Spending: Evidence from Corporate Contribution Bans in US State Legislatures”
Looking at whole legislatures rather than individual seats, Hall finds state bans on corporate contributions substantially change election outcomes. He estimates a 1 percentage point increase in a party's share of all contributions in a cycle raises its share of legislative seats by roughly half a percentage point.
How: Difference-in-differences using state-level corporate contribution bans. Political Science Research and Methods 4(2): 343-359. Read the paper
Jörg L. Spenkuch; David Toniatti (2018), “Political Advertising and Election Results”
Using 2004-2012 presidential campaigns, the authors find total political advertising has almost no effect on overall turnout but a positive, economically meaningful effect on vote shares. A one-standard-deviation increase in the partisan difference in advertising raises the partisan difference in vote shares by about 0.5 percentage points. Advertising appears to work by changing the partisan makeup of who votes.
How: Border-discontinuity design comparing neighboring counties in different media markets, exploiting FCC rules that create differences in ad exposure. Quarterly Journal of Economics 133(4): 1981-2036. Read the paper
Nour Abdul-Razzak; Carlo Prato; Stephane Wolton (2020), “After Citizens United: How Outside Spending Shapes American Democracy”
Lifting state restrictions on funding outside spending after Citizens United and SpeechNow increased Republican candidates' electoral success in state legislatures and made legislatures more conservative, but had no detectable effect on polarization. The effect is larger where unions are weak and business is aligned with Republicans; in those states the manuscript reports an effect of almost 8 percentage points, more than twice the baseline.
How: Difference-in-differences exploiting the court-mandated removal of state restrictions, paired with a formal model of outside spending. Electoral Studies 67, article 102190. Read the paper
Jordan Kujala (2020), “Donors, Primary Elections, and Polarization in the United States”
Placing 2002-2010 U.S. House primary winners on the same ideological scale as their primary voters, general-election voters and partisan donors, Kujala finds nominees are more responsive to their donors than to either electorate. He concludes donor influence in nominating contests is a source of polarization that outweighs any moderating forces.
How: Joint ideological scaling of candidates, electorates and donor constituencies for U.S. House primaries, 2002-2010. American Journal of Political Science 64(3): 587-602. Read the paper
Steven Sprick Schuster (2020), “Does Campaign Spending Affect Election Outcomes? New Evidence from Transaction-Level Disbursement Data”
Isolating the part of candidate budgets actually spent on messages to voters, Schuster finds that spending has a statistically significant effect on voter support, working mainly by changing who turns out rather than by converting voters. Low-information partisans and economically dissatisfied voters respond most. He argues the usual total-spending measure overstates what candidates spend on their own campaigns and so tends to miss the effect.
How: Transaction-level FEC disbursement data combined with panel survey data to control for unobserved candidate traits. Journal of Politics 82(4): 1502-1515. Read the paper
John Sides; Lynn Vavreck; Christopher Warshaw (2022), “The Effect of Television Advertising in United States Elections”
Across 2000-2018 elections, TV advertising moves votes at every level but far more down-ballot. A 100-airing advantage raises two-party vote share by about 0.02 points in presidential races, versus 0.04-0.06 in Senate, 0.06-0.09 in gubernatorial, 0.08-0.09 in House, 0.19-0.26 in attorney general and 0.34-0.35 in state treasurer races, i.e., 2.5 to 19 times larger down-ballot. The main mechanism is persuasion, not mobilizing partisans.
How: Difference-in-differences with county fixed effects and a border-county-pair design across media-market boundaries, using Wesleyan Media Project ad-airing data. American Political Science Review 116(2): 702-718. Read the paper
Eric Avis; Claudio Ferraz; Frederico Finan; Carlos Varjão (2022), “Money and Politics: The Effects of Campaign Spending Limits on Political Entry and Competition”
A Brazilian reform capped spending in mayoral elections with a sharp cutoff. Stricter limits lowered incumbent reelection rates and increased competition by drawing in more candidates, who were less wealthy and relied less on self-financing. The limits did not produce significant short-run improvements in policy outcomes such as education and health.
How: Regression discontinuity around the rule that set municipal spending caps in Brazil. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 14(4): 167-199. Read the paper
Checking our numbers against others’
Share of general elections won by the campaign that spent more, computed here from FEC files, beside the figures the Center for Responsive Politics (now OpenSecrets) published after each election.
| Year | House, here | Senate, here | House within 10 pts | Published at the time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | 95.4% | 82.4% | 68% | House 94%; Senate 85%. Five winning Senate candidates spent less than their opponents; 28 House winners raised less than their opponents. source |
| 2002 | 94.2% | 88.2% | 68% | No published figure found |
| 2004 | 97.2% | 85.3% | 77% | Center for Responsive Politics (as restated in its Nov 2010 release): House 98%, Senate 88%. Associated Press election-week review: at least 96% of top House spenders and about 94% of top Senate spenders won. source |
| 2006 | 92.9% | 72.7% | 55% | Center for Responsive Politics preliminary (decided races, spending through Oct 18): House 93% (398 of 428), Senate 67% (22 of 33). CRP later figure (in its 2010 release): House 94%, Senate 73%. source |
| 2008 | 92.2% | 91.4% | 63% | Center for Responsive Politics preliminary (races decided by midday Nov 5, spending through Oct 15): House 93%, Senate 94%. CRP later figure (in its 2010 release): House 93%, Senate 86%. source |
| 2010 | 86.2% | 81.1% | 55% | Center for Responsive Politics preliminary: House about 85%; Senate 83% (29 of 35 called races). source |
| 2012 | 93.8% | 75.8% | 67% | Senate 76% (PBS NewsHour citing CRP). A search-result excerpt of the archived OpenSecrets Nov 2014 article gives House 93.8% and Senate 75.8% for 2012. sourcePartly confirmed |
| 2014 | 93.6% | 77.8% | 66% | House 94%, Senate 82% (PBS NewsHour citing CRP post-election analysis). Search-result excerpt of the OpenSecrets article gives the unrounded 94.2% and 81.8%. source |
| 2016 | 95.9% | 82.4% | 58% | No published figure found |
| 2018 | 88.5% | 82.9% | 60% | House 89% (election-week figure). Senate figure not found. sourcePartly confirmed |
| 2020 | 87.8% | 71.4% | 55% | Center for Responsive Politics, Nov 24, 2020: 88% of congressional races overall; House 89.2%; Senate 71.9%. Counting candidate plus outside money: House over 90%, Senate almost 69%. Candidate with more outside support won over 70% of House races and about 44% of Senate races. Earlier snapshot (Mother Jones, Nov 6, 2020, citing OpenSecrets): House 90.4%, Senate 73%. source |
| 2022 | 93.3% | 80.6% | 73% | Over 94% of winning House candidates and 88% of winning Senate candidates outspent their opponents (OpenSecrets, as shown in search-result excerpts of a mirror of its post-election article). sourcePartly confirmed |
| 2024 | 94.7% | 82.9% | 72% | No published figure found |
Small differences are expected: sources differ on whether they count money raised or spent, whether Senate figures cover two years or six, how they treat candidates who filed no report, and whether they ran the numbers before all races were called.
Outside spending totals
This site adds up independent expenditures from the FEC’s raw filings after removing amended and hoax reports. The FEC publishes its own total for each cycle.
| Cycle | This site | FEC published | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | $1.31B | $1.25B | +4.6% |
| 2014 | $781.32M | $787.80M | −0.8% |
| 2016 | $1.72B | $1.63B | +5.2% |
| 2018 | $1.32B | $1.30B | +1.2% |
| 2020 | $3.37B | $3.14B | +7.1% |
| 2022 | $2.27B | $2.25B | +0.8% |
| 2024 | $4.46B | $4.43B | +0.7% |
Source: FEC 24-month statistical summary press releases (seven cycles, URLs in the A1 entries above).
More published benchmarks (24): re-election rates, total cost of each election, FEC summaries
| Published figure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Incumbent re-election rates, U.S. House and Senate, by cycle (OpenSecrets) | House: 2000 97.8%, 2002 96%, 2004 97.8%, 2006 94.1%, 2008 94.3%, 2010 85.4%, 2012 89.8%, 2014 95.4%, 2016 96.7%, 2018 91%, 2020 94.7%, 2022 93.2%, 2024 96.6%. Senate: 2000 79.3%, 2002 85.7%, 2004 96.2%, 2006 79.3%, 2008 83.3%, 2010 84%, 2012 91.3%, 2014 82.1%, 2016 93.1%, 2018 84.4%, 2020 83.9%, 2022 100%, 2024 88%. | OpenSecrets, Reelection Rates in Congress, 1964-2024 (page states it is based on FEC data released Feb 6, 2025) |
| Total cost of federal elections by cycle, dollars as reported (OpenSecrets) | 1998 $1.62B; 2000 $3.08B; 2002 $2.18B; 2004 $4.15B; 2006 $2.85B; 2008 $5.29B; 2010 $3.63B; 2012 $6.29B; 2014 $3.85B; 2016 $6.51B; 2018 $5.73B; 2020 $15.14B; 2022 $8.94B; 2024 $14.8B; 2026 $11.93B (projected). | OpenSecrets, Total Cost of Federal Elections, 1998-2026 |
| Total cost of federal elections by cycle, inflation-adjusted (OpenSecrets' published restatement) | 1998 $3.33B; 2000 $5.98B; 2002 $4.06B; 2004 $7.36B; 2006 $4.74B; 2008 $8.14B; 2010 $5.6B; 2012 $9.15B; 2014 $5.44B; 2016 $9.09B; 2018 $7.64B; 2020 $19.6B; 2022 $10.15B; 2024 $15.82B. (2026 projection of $11.93B is not restated.) | OpenSecrets, Total Cost of Federal Elections (inflation-adjusted view) |
| Average spending by winners and losers, 2022 House and Senate races (OpenSecrets) | House: average winner spent $2,789,859, average loser $803,773; Senate: average winner $26,525,065, average loser $13,518,978. Most expensive campaigns: Katie Porter (House) $28,483,083; Raphael Warnock (Senate) $180,666,083. House incumbents: 384 sought re-election, 359 won (93.49%); Senate: 28 of 28 (100%). Close races (margin under 10 points): 73 House, 8 Senate. | OpenSecrets, Election Trends in House and Senate Races, 2022 |
| House incumbents' financial advantage and spending in races where incumbents lost, 2024 (OpenSecrets) | Average raised: incumbents $3,040,923 (387 candidates), challengers $467,323 (888), open-seat candidates $744,042 (510) - incumbents raised 6.5 times as much as challengers (3.5 times in 1998). By race result: incumbent re-elected (369 races) - winner spent $2,497,726 on average vs loser $648,434; incumbent defeated (12 races) - winning challenger spent $5,071,263 vs losing incumbent $6,659,513; open seats (49) - winner $2,626,061 vs loser $1,128,077. | OpenSecrets, Incumbent Advantage in Congressional Elections, 2024 (FEC data released Sept 16, 2025) |
| Candidate fundraising totals by chamber and party, 2023-2024 cycle (OpenSecrets) | House candidates raised $1.99B and spent $1.84B (Democrats raised $1.03B, Republicans $941.39M). Senate candidates raised $1.61B and spent $1.64B (Democrats $974.28M, Republicans $602.28M). Presidential candidates raised $1.87B and spent $1.85B (Democrats $1.16B, Republicans $637.86M). | OpenSecrets, Federal Elections: Stats at a Glance, 2024 (FEC data released Sept 16, 2025) |
| OpenSecrets' 'Winning vs. Spending' (top spender wins) page | Not available. The former URL (opensecrets.org/elections-overview/winning-vs-spending) now redirects to the redesigned elections hub, which has no top-spender-wins table. The percentages in this file therefore come from news reports quoting OpenSecrets / Center for Responsive Politics (entries A3-*). | OpenSecrets elections hub (checked 2026-11-19) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2011-2012 cycle: receipts/disbursements by filer type and independent expenditures | All filers: receipts $7,127.1M, disbursements $6,982.2M. Presidential candidates $1,379.8M / $1,359.8M; congressional candidates $1,878.8M / $1,847.2M; party committees $1,609.4M / $1,576.8M; PACs $2,259.1M / $2,198.4M. Independent expenditures $1,250.5M (IE-only committees $606.8M; committees with non-contribution accounts $12.9M; other PACs $78M; persons other than political committees $300.4M; party committees $252.4M). Electioneering communications $15.1M. | FEC press release, 'FEC Summarizes Campaign Activity of the 2011-2012 Election Cycle' (Apr 19, 2013) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2013-2014 cycle | Congressional candidates: receipts $1,669.4M, disbursements $1,615.0M (Senate, 233 candidates: $635.4M / $654.2M; House, 1,445 candidates: about $1 billion / $960.8M). Party committees $1,227.7M / $1,192.3M. PACs $2,368.6M / $2,304.8M. Independent expenditures $787.8M (IE-only committees $339.4M; non-contribution-account committees $2.6M; other PACs $48.8M; persons other than political committees $168.0M; party committees $229.0M). | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2013-2014 Election Cycle' (Apr 3, 2015) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2015-2016 cycle | Presidential candidates: receipts $1,539.1M, disbursements $1,527.1M. Congressional candidates $1,644.3M / $1,597.0M (Senate, 217 candidates: $594.5M / $625.3M; House, 1,400 candidates: about $1 billion / $971.7M). Party committees $1,629.4M / $1,556.1M. PACs $4,046.3M / $3,973.3M. Independent expenditures $1,631.0M (IE-only committees about $1.1 billion; non-contribution-account committees $46.7M; other PACs $76.2M; persons other than political committees $197.2M; party committees $254.5M). | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2015-2016 Election Cycle' (Mar 23, 2017) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2017-2018 cycle | Congressional candidates: receipts $2,774.0M, disbursements $2,718.3M (Senate, 257 candidates: about $1.0B / $1.0B; House, 2,234 candidates: about $1.7B / $1.7B). Party committees $1,555.2M / $1,501.8M. PACs $4,674.2M / $4,554.1M. (2020 presidential candidates to date: $75.3M / $63.1M.) Independent expenditures $1,301.0M (IE-only committees $820.5M; non-contribution-account committees $72.9M; other PACs $59.6M; persons other than political committees $115.5M; party committees $232.7M). | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2017-2018 Election Cycle' (Mar 15, 2019) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2019-2020 cycle | Presidential candidates: receipts $4,073.9M, disbursements $4,071.9M (149 filers). Congressional candidates $4,005.3M / $3,765.2M (House, 2,082 candidates: about $2.0B / $1.8B; Senate, 289 candidates: about $2B). Party committees $3,196.8M / $3,010.5M. PACs $13,227.9M / $12,947.1M. Independent expenditures $3,143.7M (IE-only committees about $2 billion; non-contribution-account committees $552.2M; other PACs $86.5M; party committees $393.5M; persons other than political committees $92M). Electioneering communications $32.8M; communication costs $22.7M. | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2019-2020 Election Cycle' (Apr 2, 2021) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2021-2022 cycle | Congressional candidates: receipts $3,756.1M, disbursements $3,726.7M (Senate, 342 candidates: about $1.7B; House, 2,314 candidates: about $2.1B). Party committees $2,119.8M / $2,150.5M. PACs $9,307.7M / $9,049.1M. (2024 presidential candidates to date: $4.3M / $1.1M.) Independent expenditures $2,255.0M (IE-only committees about $1.3 billion; non-contribution-account committees $555M; party committees $271.2M; other PACs $52.2M; persons other than political committees $30.4M). Electioneering communications $4.8M. | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2021-2022 Election Cycle' (Apr 3, 2023) |
| FEC 24-month summary, 2023-2024 cycle | Presidential candidates: receipts $2,012.0M, disbursements $1,796.7M. Congressional candidates $3,801.5M / $3,704.2M (Senate, 266 candidates: about $1.5B / $1.5B; House, 1,886 candidates: about $2.3B / $2.2B). Party committees $2,746.1M / $2,646.3M. PACs $15,744.1M / $15,520.3M. Independent expenditures $4,426.5M (IE-only committees about $2.7 billion; non-contribution-account committees about $1.4 billion; other PACs $66.9M; persons other than political committees $86M; party committees $177.5M). Electioneering communications $11.3M. | FEC press release, 'Statistical Summary of 24-Month Campaign Activity of the 2023-2024 Election Cycle' (Apr 23, 2025) |
| 2016 presidential: Clinton's campaign committee raised and spent far more than Trump's; Trump won | Clinton: receipts $585,669,599, disbursements $585,346,281. Trump: receipts $350,668,436 (including $66,141,714 in contributions/loans from the candidate), disbursements $343,056,733. Outside spending as of Oct 31, 2016 per Center for Responsive Politics: more than $189M supporting Clinton vs just over $59M supporting Trump (campaigns then at $497.8M vs $247.5M). | FEC Presidential Tables 1 and 2, activity through Dec 31, 2016 (published Apr 7, 2017); outside-spending snapshot from Center for Responsive Politics as reported by the Record Herald (Nov 16, 2016) |
| 2020 presidential: Biden's campaign committee raised and spent more than Trump's; Biden won | Biden: receipts $1,074,179,976, disbursements $1,073,919,501. Trump: receipts $744,350,229, disbursements $752,889,329. | FEC Presidential Tables 1 and 2, activity through Dec 31, 2020 (generated Mar 21, 2021) |
| 2024 presidential: the Harris (formerly Biden) campaign committee raised about 2.5 times what Trump's committee did; Trump won. Outside-group spending was roughly even.Partly confirmed | Harris for President (includes Biden for President activity before the Jul 21, 2024 renaming): receipts $1,175,189,103, disbursements $1,175,284,284. Trump: receipts $474,871,587; FEC Table 2 prints disbursements of $255,214,045 and cash on hand $119,676,444, which does not reconcile with receipts. Outside groups through Election Day per OpenSecrets: about $1.05 billion backing Harris/attacking Trump vs about $1 billion backing Trump/attacking his opponents. | FEC Presidential Tables 1 and 2, activity through Dec 31, 2024 (generated Mar 24, 2025); outside spending from OpenSecrets staff article republished by InDepthNH (Nov 7, 2024) |
| Total outside spending by cycle as reported by OpenSecrets (via news articles quoting it)Partly confirmed | 2018: about $1.32 billion (then a midterm record). 2022: about $1.34 billion as of Oct 14, 2022 (already past 2018); about $2.3 billion final per search excerpt. 2020: about $3.3 billion full cycle per search excerpt. 2024: about $2.6 billion by early October with a projection above $5 billion; about $4.5 billion reported before Election Day (a record). | Truthout (Sharon Zhang, Oct 17, 2022) citing OpenSecrets; CNN via KRDO (Fredreka Schouten, Oct 8, 2024) citing OpenSecrets; OpenSecrets staff article republished by InDepthNH (Nov 7, 2024) |
| Total cost of elections per OpenSecrets / Center for Responsive Politics (context figures) | 2006: about $2.8B (estimate). 2010: roughly $4B (projection). 2018: $7.1B inflation-adjusted. 2022: over $9.3B federal projected in Sept 2022; $16.7B federal plus state. 2024: at least $15.9B federal projected (Oct 2024); about $16B federal plus $4.6B raised at state level, over $20B combined (Nov 7, 2024). | Insurance Journal citing CRP (2006); CRP release via SCPRONet (2010); The Fulcrum/OpenSecrets, Taylor Giorno (Sept 26, 2022); Brennan Center citing OpenSecrets (Nov 16, 2022); CNN via KRDO (Oct 8, 2024); OpenSecrets via InDepthNH (Nov 7, 2024) |
| Ohio Senate 2024: Brown's campaign outraised Moreno's by more than 3 to 1 and lostPartly confirmed | Brown (D, incumbent): receipts $96,530,241, disbursements $99,564,642. Moreno (R): receipts $26,920,694 (including $4,500,838 from the candidate), disbursements $26,388,505. Result: Moreno 50.09% (2,857,383), Brown 46.47% (2,650,949). Total spending in the race reported as a record $483.4 million. Crypto super PAC network Fairshake spent about $40 million backing Moreno. | FEC Congressional Candidate Table 5, Senate campaigns through Dec 31, 2024 (generated Mar 17, 2025); result and race total from Wikipedia race page; Fairshake figure from Wikipedia Fairshake page |
| Pennsylvania Senate 2024: Casey's campaign outraised McCormick's and lost by about 15,000 votesPartly confirmed | Casey (D, incumbent): receipts $58,147,601, disbursements $60,234,444. McCormick (R): receipts $35,970,837 (including $7,691,847 from the candidate), disbursements $35,373,179. Result: McCormick 48.78% (3,399,295), Casey 48.56% (3,384,180), margin 15,115 votes. | FEC Congressional Candidate Table 5, Senate campaigns through Dec 31, 2024; result from Wikipedia race page |
| Montana Senate 2024: Tester's campaign outraised Sheehy's by more than 3 to 1 and lostPartly confirmed | Tester (D, incumbent): receipts $93,570,123, disbursements $95,689,258. Sheehy (R): receipts $30,004,860 (including $2,602,762 from the candidate), disbursements $28,624,278. Result: Sheehy 52.64% (319,682), Tester 45.50% (276,305). Wikipedia race page: total spending by both sides on track to exceed $315 million as of October 2024, Democrats outspending Republicans by about $50 million, roughly $487 per registered voter. | FEC Congressional Candidate Table 5, Senate campaigns through Dec 31, 2024; result and race totals from Wikipedia race page |
| House incumbents re-elected as a share of those seeking re-election (Brookings Vital Statistics on Congress, Table 2-7) | 2000 97.8%; 2002 96.2%; 2004 97.8%; 2006 94.0%; 2008 94.3%; 2010 85.4%; 2012 89.8%; 2014 95.4%; 2016 96.9%; 2018 91.0%; 2020 94.7%; 2022 94.0%; 2024 95.9% | Brookings Institution, Vital Statistics on Congress, Table 2-7 (April 2026 update; Molly Reynolds, Abby Ward) |
| Senate incumbents re-elected as a share of those seeking re-election (Brookings Vital Statistics on Congress, Table 2-8) | 2000 79.3%; 2002 88.9%; 2004 96.2%; 2006 78.6%; 2008 83.3%; 2010 84.0%; 2012 91.3%; 2014 79.3%; 2016 93.1%; 2018 84.4%; 2020 83.9%; 2022 100%; 2024 88.0% | Brookings Institution, Vital Statistics on Congress, Table 2-8 (April 2026 update) |
Famous big money, and how it did
Cases beyond House and Senate general elections: presidential primaries, governors’ races, self-funders, super PAC campaigns. Most lost, which is why they are famous; the ones that won are marked. They show a limit: money buys attention, not agreement.
| Who | Race | Money | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Bloomberg | 2020 Democratic presidential primary | Campaign receipts $1,124,592,945, of which $1,089,225,532 came from the candidate; disbursements $1,121,170,037 | LOST. Won only American Samoa and 61 delegates; in the race from Nov 2019 to Mar 4, 2020. source |
| Tom Steyer | 2020 Democratic presidential primary | Campaign receipts $353,041,936, of which $341,776,336 came from the candidate; disbursements $352,955,049 | LOST. No pledged delegates; best finish third in South Carolina with about 11%; withdrew Feb 29, 2020. source |
| Hillary Clinton | 2016 President (general) | Campaign receipts $585,669,599 vs Trump $350,668,436; outside support as of Oct 31, 2016 more than $189M vs just over $59M | LOST (better-funded on both campaign and outside money). source |
| Kamala Harris (committee formerly Biden for President) | 2024 President (general) | Campaign receipts $1,175,189,103 vs Trump $474,871,587; outside groups about $1.05 billion vs about $1 billion | LOST (far better-funded campaign committee; outside money near parity). source |
| Jeb Bush / Right to Rise super PACPartly confirmed | 2016 Republican presidential primary | Right to Rise raised over $100 million by August 2015; Bush's own campaign committee: receipts $35,491,191, disbursements $35,435,885 | LOST. Suspended campaign Feb 20, 2016, after the South Carolina primary. source |
| Meg Whitman | 2010 California governor | About $140-144 million of her own money; total campaign spending reported as over $160 million (Marketplace/CRP, Nov 2010) and $178.5 million (Salon/AP via Wikipedia) | LOST to Jerry Brown, about 41% to 54%. source |
| Linda McMahon | 2010 Connecticut U.S. Senate | About $46 million self-funded (Marketplace/CRP); Wikipedia lists campaign receipts of $46.6 million and a pledge of up to $50 million | LOST to Richard Blumenthal, 43.2% to 55.2%. source |
| Linda McMahonNot confirmed | 2012 Connecticut U.S. Senate | Wikipedia text says $15.7 million of her own money (appears to be a mid-campaign figure; full-cycle total not confirmed) | LOST to Chris Murphy, 43.1% to 54.8%. source |
| Carly Fiorina | 2010 California U.S. Senate | About $5.5 million self-funded | LOST (to incumbent Barbara Boxer). source |
| Rick ScottPartly confirmed | 2010 Florida governor | About $60 million of his own money by Oct 25, 2010; final totals reported at roughly $75-78 million; more than $23 million of it in the primary | WON narrowly over Alex Sink, 48.87% to 47.72%. source |
| Rick Scott | 2018 Florida U.S. Senate | Campaign receipts $85,226,716, of which $63,569,754 were contributions/loans from the candidate; disbursements $83,771,112. Incumbent Bill Nelson: receipts $32,397,358. | WON by 10,033 votes after a recount (50.05% to 49.93%). source |
| Rick Scott | 2024 Florida U.S. Senate | 2023-2024 receipts $36,696,093, of which $21,393,850 from the candidate (plus $4,214,331 from the candidate in 2021-2022); disbursements $39,942,180. Challenger Debbie Mucarsel-Powell: receipts $36,616,416. | WON by more than 12 points. source |
| David TronePartly confirmed | 2016 Maryland 8th District Democratic primary | More than $13 million of his own money (described as a record for a self-funded House campaign) | LOST to Jamie Raskin, 27.2% to 33.6%. source |
| David TronePartly confirmed | 2018 Maryland 6th District | Campaign spent more than $15 million; his Republican opponent spent under $1 million | WON. source |
| David Trone | 2024 Maryland U.S. Senate Democratic primary | Contributions/loans from the candidate $62,877,800 of $63,833,137 in receipts; disbursements $64,032,402. Winner Angela Alsobrooks: receipts $31,077,189 for the whole cycle including the general election. | LOST the May 14, 2024 primary to Angela Alsobrooks, 42.80% to 53.37%. source |
| Jaime Harrison | 2020 South Carolina U.S. Senate | Receipts $132,685,670, disbursements $132,350,243. Incumbent Lindsey Graham: receipts $107,747,534, disbursements $98,460,665 (2019-2020). | LOST by about 10 points. source |
More cases (31), including 2025–26
| Who | Race | Money | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amy McGrath | 2020 Kentucky U.S. Senate | Receipts $96,325,352, disbursements $92,980,540. Incumbent Mitch McConnell: receipts $68,094,903, disbursements $64,878,658 (2019-2020). | LOST by nearly 20 points. source |
| Sara GideonPartly confirmed | 2020 Maine U.S. Senate | Receipts $75,629,137, disbursements $64,069,683 (ended the year with $11,559,504 unspent). Incumbent Susan Collins: receipts $27,867,541, disbursements $29,200,074 (2019-2020). | LOST to Susan Collins. source |
| Other 2020 Democratic Senate challengers who outraised Republican incumbents/nomineesPartly confirmed | 2020 U.S. Senate (Montana, Iowa, North Carolina, Kansas) | Bullock $49,522,120 vs Daines $31,883,905; Greenfield $56,358,312 vs Ernst $27,693,029; Cunningham $52,569,134 vs Tillis $23,280,647; Bollier $29,004,665 vs Marshall $6,772,872 (receipts, 2019-2020 period) | All four LOST. Counter-examples the same year: Mark Kelly ($101,106,584 vs McSally $73,553,299) and Jon Ossoff ($156,145,527 vs Perdue $99,202,974) outraised their opponents and WON. source |
| Beto O'RourkePartly confirmed | 2018 Texas U.S. Senate | Receipts $80,338,144, disbursements $80,450,313. Incumbent Ted Cruz: receipts $35,409,077, disbursements $39,458,810 (2017-2018). | LOST to Ted Cruz. source |
| Colin AllredPartly confirmed | 2024 Texas U.S. Senate | Receipts $94,674,183 vs incumbent Ted Cruz $74,050,031 (2023-2024) | LOST to Ted Cruz (outcome not separately fetched today). source |
| Jon OssoffPartly confirmed | 2017 Georgia 6th District special election | Raised more than $23 million vs about $4.3 million for Karen Handel (FEC, through May 31, 2017); combined campaign and outside spending exceeded $55 million, then the most expensive House race ever | LOST the June 20, 2017 runoff, 48.22% to 51.78%. source |
| Sherrod Brown | 2024 Ohio U.S. Senate | Receipts $96,530,241 vs Bernie Moreno $26,920,694 | LOST, 46.47% to 50.09%. source |
| Jon Tester | 2024 Montana U.S. Senate | Receipts $93,570,123 vs Tim Sheehy $30,004,860 | LOST, 45.50% to 52.64%. source |
| Bob Casey Jr. | 2024 Pennsylvania U.S. Senate | Receipts $58,147,601 vs Dave McCormick $35,970,837 | LOST by 15,115 votes (48.56% to 48.78%). source |
| Ross PerotPartly confirmed | 1992 President (independent) | About $60 million of his own money | LOST. About 18.9% of the popular vote and zero electoral votes. source |
| Steve ForbesPartly confirmed | 2000 Republican presidential primary | $37 million of his own money out of $86 million raised (2000 campaign). 1996 self-funding amount not confirmed. | LOST both times. In 1996 he won the Arizona and Delaware primaries before dropping out; in 2000 he dropped out early. source |
| Michael HuffingtonPartly confirmed | 1994 California U.S. Senate | Spent $28 million (then the most expensive non-presidential campaign); share from his own pocket not stated in the fetched source | LOST to Dianne Feinstein, 44.83% to 46.74% (margin 162,127 votes). source |
| Jon CorzinePartly confirmed | 2000 New Jersey U.S. Senate | More than $62 million of his own money (over $35 million in the primary alone); described as the most expensive Senate campaign to that date | WON, 50.11% to 47.10% over Bob Franks. (Also won governor in 2005 after spending $38 million on the general election; lost re-election in 2009.) source |
| J.B. PritzkerPartly confirmed | 2018 Illinois governor | $171.5 million of his own money (2018). 2022 self-funding amount not found. | WON in 2018, 54.53% to 38.83% over incumbent Bruce Rauner; WON re-election in 2022, 54.91% to 42.37%. source |
| Self-funders overall (statistics)Partly confirmed | 2010 Federal and gubernatorial, 2010 and 2004 | 2010: of the ten biggest self-funders listed by Marketplace from Center for Responsive Politics data, two won and eight lost (winners included Ron Johnson, $8.2M, and Scott Rigell, $2.4M; losers included Whitman, McMahon, Jeff Greene at $23.7M, Fiorina). CRP's own 2010 post-election release said most self-financing candidates faltered again. 2004: AP found that none of the candidates whose personal spending triggered the 'millionaire's amendment' won. | Mostly LOSSES. source |
| AIPAC / United Democracy Project vs Jamaal BowmanPartly confirmed | 2024 New York 16th District Democratic primary | About $15 million in AIPAC-linked outside spending benefiting George Latimer; described as the most expensive House primary in U.S. history | BIG MONEY WON. Latimer defeated the incumbent 58.59% to 41.41% on June 25, 2024. source |
| AIPAC / United Democracy Project vs Cori BushPartly confirmed | 2024 Missouri 1st District Democratic primary | About $9 million (Politico, CNN) or $8.5 million (AP headline); second most expensive House primary | BIG MONEY WON. Wesley Bell defeated the incumbent 51.12% to 45.65% on Aug 6, 2024. source |
| Fairshake (crypto industry super PAC network)Partly confirmed | 2024 House and Senate primaries and general elections | Raised about $260 million (Mar 2023 - Dec 2024, FEC) and spent over $133 million on candidates; about $40 million backing Bernie Moreno in Ohio; over $10 million against Katie Porter in the California Senate primary. Top donors: Coinbase $93.5M, Ripple $45M, Andreessen and Horowitz $33.5M each, Jump Trading $25M. | BIG MONEY MOSTLY WON. CNBC count: backed the winner in 33 of 35 primaries by June 2024; Moreno won; Porter lost her primary. source |
| Haley Stevens and allied groups (incl. AIPAC's United Democracy Project) | 2026 Michigan U.S. Senate Democratic primary | About $54M-$62M in outside spending for Stevens or against El-Sayed (about $30.6M from United Democracy Project) versus $3M-$5M on El-Sayed's side; the two campaigns themselves were close ($9.1M spent by Stevens vs $12.0M by El-Sayed as of July 15) | LOST 47.55% to 48.45% source |
| John Cornyn and allied groups | 2026 Texas U.S. Senate Republican runoff | Roughly $109M in advertising by his campaign and allies across primary and runoff (AP) versus single-digit millions for Ken Paxton | LOST the May 26 runoff 36.2% to 63.8% after Trump endorsed Paxton source |
| Elon Musk | 2026 2026 midterms (Republican committees; chiefly the Texas Senate race) | About $474M in disclosed giving since Jan 1, 2025 (New York Times analysis), about $212M of it effectively behind Ken Paxton | Paxton LOST 43.0% to 55.1%; Republicans lost both chambers source |
| Pro-Husted outside groups (incl. crypto PACs) | 2026 Ohio U.S. Senate special election | $264M in outside spending for Husted vs $159M for Sherrod Brown (Brennan Center); Brown's campaign spent $64M to Husted's $16M | Husted LOST 45.15% to 50.01% (side with more total money lost; candidate with more campaign money won) source |
| Tom Steyer | 2026 California governor (top-two primary) | At least $213M-$216M of his own money | LOST - finished third and did not advance source |
| David Trone | 2026 Maryland 6th District Democratic primary | $25.0M in self-loans (FEC summary file) against incumbent April McClain Delaney, who lent herself about $7.4M before the primary | LOST by about 6-7 points source |
| Raja Krishnamoorthi | 2026 Illinois U.S. Senate Democratic primary | Campaign spent about $28M vs about $4M for Juliana Stratton (who had roughly $16M in outside support, much of it from a Pritzker-funded PAC) | LOST 32.7% to 40.4% source |
| Angie Craig and allied groups | 2026 Minnesota U.S. Senate DFL primary | Raised $12.6M to Peggy Flanagan's $6.4M before the primary; about $17M of outside money on her side vs about $3.6M on Flanagan's | LOST by about 20 points source |
| Rick Jackson | 2026 Georgia governor | More than $100M of his own money; outspent Keisha Lance Bottoms about 5 to 1 | Won the Republican runoff, then LOST the general source |
| Vivek Ramaswamy and allied V-PAC | 2026 Ohio governor | At least $36M of his own money; more than $120M in ads with allies, over triple Amy Acton's side | LOST source |
| Pro-Cuomo super PACs (incl. Fix the City; Michael Bloomberg $13.3M) | 2025 New York City mayor | $28.4M in super PAC support for Andrew Cuomo in the general vs $4.5M for Zohran Mamdani; more than $30M on losing super PAC efforts in the primary | LOST both the primary and the general (Mamdani won the general 50.78% to 41.32%) source |
| Anti-Massie coalition (MAGA KY, United Democracy Project, RJC Victory Fund) - big money WON | 2026 Kentucky 4th District Republican primary | About $19M of the roughly $32M-$35M in ads favored Trump-endorsed Ed Gallrein, though Massie's own campaign out-raised Gallrein's about 2 to 1 ($8.9M vs $4.1M) | The side with more total money WON: Massie lost 45.1% to 54.9% in the costliest House primary on record source |
| Opponents of California Prop 40 (billionaire tax) - big money WON | 2026 California Proposition 40 | $378.4M against vs $33.5M in support | The bigger spender WON: the measure failed with about 52-53% No source |
2026: what was reported
News and watchdog reporting on the 2026 midterms and primaries, race by race. Two things were true at once: Democratic candidates out-raised Republican candidates, and Republican-aligned outside groups outspent Democratic ones. In most Senate races the nominee whose own campaign raised more won, while several sides with more combined money lost.
- Projected total cost of the 2026 federal midterms (OpenSecrets): $11.93 billion (projected), the most expensive midterm on record: up from $8.94B in 2022 ($10.15B inflation-adjusted). Spending by and for Democrats $5.52B (46.2%), Republicans $5.12B (42.9%). OpenSecrets, Total Cost of Federal Elections, 1998-2026 (read 2026-11-19; 2026 row flagged as projected)
- Projected outside spending, 2026 (OpenSecrets, via news reports): About $3.9 billion in outside spending, mostly super PACs, up about 85% from 2022; at least $1.47 billion in dark-money contributions to outside groups identified (above $1.35B for 2024), described as a floor. News summaries of OpenSecrets' October 2026 projection (IBTimes, Tampa Free Press, Common Dreams and others; seen in search-result summaries, not on OpenSecrets' own page)
- Independent expenditures reported to the FEC for the 2026 cycle (computed): About $4.10 billion in filings received through Nov 18, 2026: about $2.41B aimed at Senate races and $1.66B at House races. Largest spenders: SLF PAC $351M, House Majority PAC $283M, WinSenate $282M, No Going Back PAC $274M, Congressional Leadership Fund $223M, Texas PAC $182M, Defend American Jobs (crypto) $105M, Americans for Prosperity Action $105M, America PAC (Musk) $87M, United Democracy Project (AIPAC) $54M. Computed for this file from the FEC independent-expenditure bulk file (pipeline's local copy; superseded amendments dropped, bogus filings removed). Not an official FEC total; compare the FEC's own 24-month totals of $2.26B (2022) and $4.43B (2024, including the presidential race).
- Advertising spending, 2026 cycle (AdImpact): AdImpact projected a record $11.6 billion in political ad spending for the 2025-26 cycle (June 2026); nearly $2.8 billion had been spent on Senate-race ads as of Oct 13. AP after the election: Republicans and allies out-advertised Democrats about $5.45B to about $5.0B. AdImpact projection as reported by TV Technology / Advanced Television / Bloomberg Government (search summaries); AP via KATV (Nov 4, 2026)
- Party split of 2026 spending and the 13 costliest Senate races (Brennan Center): Per OpenSecrets' tally of disclosures so far, Democrats $5.5B vs Republicans $5.1B overall. In the 13 most expensive Senate contests Democrats (plus Nebraska's independent) had 49% of the spending; they outspent Republicans in 5 of 13, were within 10 points in 9, and their campaign committees outspent the Republicans' in 10 of 13. Democrats won all of these races except Florida and Nebraska (Alaska uncalled at publication). Brennan Center for Justice, Ian Vandewalker, 'In Top Senate Races, Parties Spend to a Tie' (Nov 13, 2026)
- Candidate fundraising by party, 2026 congressional races: Through September 2026 Democratic congressional candidates had raised about $2.36 billion to Republicans' $1.58 billion. AP (FEC data) via KATV (Nov 4, 2026), as collected by the primaries/themes research pass
- Senate general-election scorecard, 2026 (computed): Across the 18 Senate general elections profiled here with both nominees' figures (MI, TX, OH, IA, ME, AK, KS, SC, NC, NE, NH, GA, FL, LA, MS, MT, KY, IL): the nominee whose campaign committee raised more won 16 of 18. Adding outside independent expenditures (approximate, FEC IE file), the side with more combined money won 12 of the 17 races where the gap exceeded 5% (1 within 5%). Losing sides with more combined money: ME, MI, MT, OH, TX. Computed for this file from the FEC summary file (weball26), the FEC independent-expenditure bulk file and the repository's results file; see meta.ie_method
Michigan Senate (Democratic primary, Aug 4, 2026)
Abdul El-Sayed (D): Won: 744,952 votes, 48.45% Campaign: Raised $14,514,335, spent $11,961,573 as of July 15, 2026 (FEC pre-primary figures as tabulated on Wikipedia; Bridge Michigan, July 29: 'nearly $12 million' spent) Outside: About $3.3M from supportive groups as of late July (Bridge Michigan). FEC IE file, primary-coded: $4.0M supporting him and $1.1M opposing Stevens, about $5.1M on his side. Against him: $20.3M, of which $20.1M from AIPAC's United Democracy Project.
Haley Stevens (D): Lost: 731,160 votes, 47.55% Campaign: Raised $11,884,632, spent $9,091,338 as of July 15, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia; Bridge Michigan: 'about $9 million'); $13.3M raised cycle-to-date through 9/30/2026 (FEC summary file) Outside: More than $45M from supportive groups as of late July, projected above $60M with reserved airtime (Bridge Michigan, AdImpact). AP: groups backing her spent more than $50M, over $30M of it from AIPAC and affiliates. FEC IE file, primary-coded: $33.9M supporting her (A Stronger Michigan $17.2M; United Democracy Project $10.5M; Unite to Win $4.0M) plus $20.3M opposing El-Sayed, about $54.2M on her side.
Mallory McMorrow (D): Withdrew in July 2026 but stayed on the ballot: 61,516 votes, 4.00% Campaign: Raised $11,386,720, spent $9,519,089 as of July 15, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: Negligible (about $0.05M in the FEC IE file)
Split by type of money. El-Sayed's own campaign had somewhat MORE than Stevens's (raised $14.5M vs $11.9M; spent $12.0M vs $9.1M by July 15). Outside groups favored Stevens by roughly 10 to 1 (about $54M-$62M vs $3M-$5M). Counting everything, the Stevens side had roughly $63M-$71M against roughly $15M-$17M for El-Sayed, about 4 to 1 - and Stevens lost by 0.9 points. Ad trackers put the paid-advertising gap at about 9 to 1 (AdImpact via NBC) or 10 to 1 ($52M vs $5.2M, Kinetiq via Axios/Roll Call). source
Michigan Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)
Abdul El-Sayed (D): Won 52.5%-45.5% (repository results file; Wikipedia shows 52.56%-45.44%, 2,521,693 to 2,180,388) Campaign: Raised $53,830,872, spent $51,096,843 cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 (FEC summary file); $47.2M from individuals, $0.40M from PACs/other committees, no self-funding. Raised $30.66M in the July 16-Sept 30 quarter alone (Michigan Advance/Bridge Michigan), a state record per Bridge. Outside: About $42M as of mid-October (Bridge Michigan). FEC IE file through Nov 18 filings, general-coded: $40.6M supporting him plus $54.1M opposing Rogers, about $95.1M on his side (largest: WinSenate $46.5M, LCV Victory Fund $5.4M, Lower Costs Now $8.3M).
Mike Rogers (R): Lost 45.5%-52.5% Campaign: Raised $23,016,439, spent $19,369,637 cycle-to-date through 10/22/2026 (FEC summary file); $15.4M from individuals, $1.29M from PACs. Raised $9.66M in the July 16-Sept 30 quarter. Outside: About $95M as of mid-October (Bridge Michigan). FEC IE file through Nov 18 filings, general-coded: $37.4M supporting him plus $134.7M opposing El-Sayed, about $172.1M on his side (largest: SLF PAC $46.2M against El-Sayed; No Going Back PAC $35.6M; GLCF/Great Lakes Conservatives Fund $25.6M; Americans for Prosperity Action $22.3M; TFM $15.3M; America PAC $9.2M). A further $13.9M of pro-Rogers spending was coded to his uncontested primary.
Split by type of money, in the opposite pattern from the common assumption. El-Sayed's campaign committee had far MORE than Rogers's (raised $53.8M vs $23.0M, about 2.3 to 1). Outside groups favored Rogers by roughly 1.8 to 1 ($172M vs $95M in the FEC IE file; $95M vs $42M at Bridge Michigan's mid-October count). Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Rogers's side about $191M vs El-Sayed's side about $146M. So the candidate with more campaign money won, and the side with more total money lost by 7 points. source
Texas Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
James Talarico (D): 55.1% - won Campaign: Raised $146.3M, spent $136.4M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $109.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Ken Paxton (FEC IE file, approximate)
Ken Paxton (R): 43.0% - lost Campaign: Raised $22.3M, spent $17.5M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $316.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing James Talarico (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: James Talarico raised more ($146.3M vs $22.3M, about 6.6 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $109.5M on James Talarico's side vs $316.0M on Ken Paxton's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Ken Paxton's side had more ($333.5M vs $245.9M). Winner: James Talarico - the candidate with more campaign money won. The side with more combined money LOST. source
Ohio (special) Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Sherrod Brown (D): 50.01% - won Campaign: Raised $68.4M, spent $64.0M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $157.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Jon Husted (FEC IE file, approximate)
Jon Husted (R): 45.15% - lost Campaign: Raised $19.9M, spent $15.7M through 10/22/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $258.7M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Sherrod Brown (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Sherrod Brown raised more ($68.4M vs $19.9M, about 3.4 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $157.5M on Sherrod Brown's side vs $258.7M on Jon Husted's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Jon Husted's side had more ($274.4M vs $221.4M). Winner: Sherrod Brown - the candidate with more campaign money won. The side with more combined money LOST. source
Iowa Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Josh Turek (D): 50.5% - won Campaign: Raised $24.3M, spent $21.2M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $104.2M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Ashley Hinson (FEC IE file, approximate)
Ashley Hinson (R): 46.4% - lost Campaign: Raised $14.1M, spent $13.9M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $96.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Josh Turek (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Josh Turek raised more ($24.3M vs $14.1M, about 1.7 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $104.2M on Josh Turek's side vs $96.5M on Ashley Hinson's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Josh Turek's side had more ($125.5M vs $110.4M). Winner: Josh Turek - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Maine Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Troy Jackson (D): 53.2% - won Campaign: Raised $26.9M, spent $25.3M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $52.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Susan Collins (FEC IE file, approximate)
Susan Collins (R): 46.8% - lost Campaign: Raised $22.5M, spent $22.4M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $89.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Troy Jackson (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Troy Jackson raised more ($26.9M vs $22.5M, about 1.2 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $52.3M on Troy Jackson's side vs $89.3M on Susan Collins's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Susan Collins's side had more ($111.6M vs $77.6M). Winner: Troy Jackson - the candidate with more campaign money won. The side with more combined money LOST. source
Alaska Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Mary Peltola (D): 50.13% (Wikipedia, as read 2026-11-19) - won Campaign: Raised $36.9M, spent $32.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $47.9M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Dan Sullivan (FEC IE file, approximate)
Dan Sullivan (R): 45.79% - lost Campaign: Raised $11.5M, spent $10.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $47.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Mary Peltola (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Mary Peltola raised more ($36.9M vs $11.5M, about 3.2 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $47.9M on Mary Peltola's side vs $47.5M on Dan Sullivan's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Mary Peltola's side had more ($80.7M vs $58.3M). Winner: Mary Peltola - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Kansas Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Adam Hamilton (D): 50.99% - won Campaign: Raised $19.2M, spent $16.3M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $58.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Roger Marshall (FEC IE file, approximate)
Roger Marshall (R): 45.99% - lost Campaign: Raised $5.4M, spent $6.2M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $35.9M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Adam Hamilton (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Adam Hamilton raised more ($19.2M vs $5.4M, about 3.6 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $58.5M on Adam Hamilton's side vs $35.9M on Roger Marshall's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Adam Hamilton's side had more ($74.8M vs $42.1M). Winner: Adam Hamilton - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
More 2026 races (49): other Senate contests, primaries, House and governors
South Carolina Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Annie Andrews (D): 51.13% - won Campaign: Raised $24.2M, spent $22.5M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $23.6M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Darline Graham (FEC IE file, approximate)
Darline Graham (R): 46.65% - lost Campaign: Raised $1.9M, spent $1.3M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $25.4M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Annie Andrews (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Annie Andrews raised more ($24.2M vs $1.9M, about 12.6 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $23.6M on Annie Andrews's side vs $25.4M on Darline Graham's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Annie Andrews's side had more ($46.1M vs $26.7M). Winner: Annie Andrews - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
North Carolina Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Roy Cooper (D): 58.7% - won Campaign: Raised $49.6M, spent $40.5M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $29.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Michael Whatley (FEC IE file, approximate)
Michael Whatley (R): 39.1% - lost Campaign: Raised $13.7M, spent $12.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $46.4M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Roy Cooper (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Roy Cooper raised more ($49.6M vs $13.7M, about 3.6 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $29.3M on Roy Cooper's side vs $46.4M on Michael Whatley's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Roy Cooper's side had more ($69.8M vs $59.2M). Winner: Roy Cooper - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Nebraska Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Dan Osborn (I): 43.7% - lost Campaign: Raised $11.0M, spent $9.1M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $37.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Pete Ricketts (FEC IE file, approximate)
Pete Ricketts (R): 50.3% - won Campaign: Raised $14.5M, spent $13.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file); $7.3M of it the candidate's own contributions/loans Outside: $32.7M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Dan Osborn (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Pete Ricketts raised more ($14.5M vs $11.0M, about 1.3 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $37.3M on Dan Osborn's side vs $32.7M on Pete Ricketts's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): roughly even ($46.4M vs $46.6M). Winner: Pete Ricketts - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
New Hampshire Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Chris Pappas (D): 56.1% - won Campaign: Raised $23.7M, spent $22.1M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $24.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing John E. Sununu (FEC IE file, approximate)
John E. Sununu (R): 42.1% - lost Campaign: Raised $5.7M, spent $3.9M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $39.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Chris Pappas (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Chris Pappas raised more ($23.7M vs $5.7M, about 4.2 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $24.0M on Chris Pappas's side vs $39.3M on John E. Sununu's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Chris Pappas's side had more ($46.2M vs $43.2M). Winner: Chris Pappas - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Georgia Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Jon Ossoff (D): 59.0% - won Campaign: Raised $115.9M, spent $105.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $19.8M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Mike Collins (FEC IE file, approximate)
Mike Collins (R): 41.0% - lost Campaign: Raised $10.7M, spent $10.2M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $18.3M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Jon Ossoff (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Jon Ossoff raised more ($115.9M vs $10.7M, about 10.8 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $19.8M on Jon Ossoff's side vs $18.3M on Mike Collins's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Jon Ossoff's side had more ($125.6M vs $28.5M). Winner: Jon Ossoff - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Florida (special) Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Angie Nixon (D): 47.98% - lost Campaign: Raised $11.3M, spent $8.1M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $11.8M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Ashley Moody (FEC IE file, approximate)
Ashley Moody (R): 50.88% - won Campaign: Raised $14.5M, spent $13.7M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $14.1M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Angie Nixon (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Ashley Moody raised more ($14.5M vs $11.3M, about 1.3 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $11.8M on Angie Nixon's side vs $14.1M on Ashley Moody's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Ashley Moody's side had more ($27.8M vs $19.8M). Winner: Ashley Moody - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Louisiana Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Jamie Davis (D): 49.12% - lost Campaign: Raised $5.0M, spent $3.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $0.1M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Julia Letlow (FEC IE file, approximate)
Julia Letlow (R): 50.88% - won Campaign: Raised $7.1M, spent $6.6M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $2.7M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Jamie Davis (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Julia Letlow raised more ($7.1M vs $5.0M, about 1.4 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $0.1M on Jamie Davis's side vs $2.7M on Julia Letlow's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Julia Letlow's side had more ($9.4M vs $3.9M). Winner: Julia Letlow - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Mississippi Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Scott Colom (D): 49.34% - won Campaign: Raised $4.4M, spent $3.4M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $15.5M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Cindy Hyde-Smith (FEC IE file, approximate)
Cindy Hyde-Smith (R): 48.56% - lost Campaign: Raised $4.6M, spent $3.7M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $2.4M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Scott Colom (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Cindy Hyde-Smith raised more ($4.6M vs $4.4M, about 1.1 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $15.5M on Scott Colom's side vs $2.4M on Cindy Hyde-Smith's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Scott Colom's side had more ($18.9M vs $6.1M). Winner: Scott Colom - the candidate with LESS campaign money won. source
Montana Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Seth Bodnar (I): 37.5% - lost Campaign: Raised $4.9M, spent $4.3M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $12.4M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Kurt Alme (FEC IE file, approximate)
Kurt Alme (R): 48.6% - won Campaign: Raised $3.0M, spent $2.4M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $4.7M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Seth Bodnar (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Seth Bodnar raised more ($4.9M vs $3.0M, about 1.6 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $12.4M on Seth Bodnar's side vs $4.7M on Kurt Alme's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Seth Bodnar's side had more ($16.8M vs $7.1M). Winner: Kurt Alme - the candidate with LESS campaign money won. The side with more combined money LOST. source
Kentucky Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Charles Booker (D): 42.9% - lost Campaign: Raised $1.9M, spent $1.6M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $0.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Andy Barr (FEC IE file, approximate)
Andy Barr (R): 54.99% - won Campaign: Raised $12.5M, spent $14.7M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $2.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Charles Booker (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Andy Barr raised more ($12.5M vs $1.9M, about 6.5 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $0.0M on Charles Booker's side vs $2.0M on Andy Barr's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Andy Barr's side had more ($16.7M vs $1.6M). Winner: Andy Barr - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Illinois Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Juliana Stratton (D): 61.3% - won Campaign: Raised $7.2M, spent $5.7M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file) Outside: $0.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Don Tracy (FEC IE file, approximate)
Don Tracy (R): 37.1% - lost Campaign: Raised $4.9M, spent $4.4M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file); $4.2M of it the candidate's own contributions/loans Outside: $0.0M in independent expenditures supporting them or opposing Juliana Stratton (FEC IE file, approximate)
Candidate committees: Juliana Stratton raised more ($7.2M vs $4.9M, about 1.5 to 1). Outside groups (FEC IE file, approximate): $0.0M on Juliana Stratton's side vs $0.0M on Don Tracy's side. Combined (campaign spending plus outside): Juliana Stratton's side had more ($5.7M vs $4.4M). Winner: Juliana Stratton - the candidate with more campaign money won. source
Minnesota Senate (general, Nov 3, 2026)Not confirmed
Peggy Flanagan (D): 53.7% - won Campaign: Raised $11.6M, spent $10.6M through 10/14/2026 (FEC two-year summary file; includes her contested primary) Outside: $2.8M (FEC IE file, approximate)
Michele Tafoya (R): 43.6% - lost Campaign: UNVERIFIED: the FEC summary file shows only $46,626 in receipts under candidate ID S6MN00556, which is implausibly low for a major-party nominee and probably reflects a second committee or incomplete record Outside: $2.7M (FEC IE file, approximate)
Not established for the general election because Tafoya's campaign total could not be confirmed. Outside spending in the general was small and even. source
Texas Senate (R primary Mar 3 / runoff May 26, 2026)
Ken Paxton (R): Primary: 40.5% (2nd). Runoff: won 63.8%-36.2%. Lost general to James Talarico 42.99%-55.09%. Campaign: Spent $5.26M as of May 6, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia finance table); $17.5M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 incl. general (FEC weball26) Outside: Paxton campaign plus two allied super PACs spent about $5.9M on ads between Mar 3 and the runoff (AdImpact via AP). Ad spending by/for Paxton about $8.2M (Kinetiq via Axios, as relayed by Roll Call column). About $3.6M in pro-Paxton ads before the March primary (Barbed Wire citing AdImpact).
John Cornyn (incumbent) (R): Primary: 42.0% (1st, short of majority). Runoff: lost 36.2%-63.8%; first Texas GOP senator denied renomination (AP). Campaign: Spent $10.13M as of May 6, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); $12.2M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Cornyn campaign and allied groups spent roughly $109M on advertising across primary and runoff (AP). Post-Mar 3 pro-Cornyn groups: $16.5M (AdImpact via AP). Ad spending by/for Cornyn $58.8M (Kinetiq via Axios/Roll Call column). Named pro-Cornyn groups pre-primary: Lone Star Freedom Project ~$18M, Texans for a Conservative Majority ~$17M, Senate Leadership Fund (Barbed Wire).
Wesley Hunt (R): Primary: 13.5% (3rd, eliminated). Campaign: $4.64M cycle-to-date through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26); $4.12M spent as of Feb 11, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: About $11.4M in supportive ads and $5.4M in ads attacking him before the primary (Barbed Wire citing AdImpact/Texas Tribune).
Cornyn, by a very wide margin (roughly $109M in ads by campaign plus allies vs. single-digit millions for Paxton). The far better-funded incumbent LOST the runoff by about 28 points. source
Texas Senate (D primary, Mar 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
James Talarico (D): Won, about 52-53% to 46% (Wikipedia text gives 52.4%; a search-result summary of local coverage gave 52.8%-45.9%). Won general 55.09%-42.99%. Campaign: Raised $20.69M / spent $15.91M as of Feb 11, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia). Cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026: raised $146.3M ($139.8M from individuals), spent $136.4M (FEC weball26). Outside: About $24M in ad support pre-primary, more than four times Crockett's (Barbed Wire citing AdImpact). Lone Star Rising super PAC: $1.9M+ in ads, $6M+ raised, over half from a dark-money group (Barbed Wire).
Jasmine Crockett (D): Lost, about 46%. Campaign: Raised $8.58M / spent $5.09M as of Feb 11, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia). Senate committee $11.1M total through 8/13/2026 (FEC weball26). Outside: About $5M in ad support (Barbed Wire citing AdImpact).
Colin Allred (D): Left the Senate race Dec 8, 2025, before the primary (Wikipedia); FEC lists him as a TX-33 House candidate. Campaign: Senate committee $7.77M disbursed through 9/30/2026; separate House (TX-33) committee $7.84M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: n/a
Talarico (roughly 3-to-1 in campaign spending and 4-to-1+ in ad support). The better-funded candidate WON. source
Maine Senate (D primary June 9, 2026; replacement convention July 25, 2026)Partly confirmed
Graham Platner (D): Won primary with 72.1% (156,084 votes). Withdrew July 10, 2026 after a sexual-assault allegation he denies. Campaign: Raised $16.31M / spent $14.13M as of May 20, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: Not found
Janet Mills (governor) (D): Suspended campaign Apr 30, 2026 but stayed on ballot: 19.3%. Campaign: Raised $5.84M / spent $5.12M as of May 20, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); $6.04M total through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
David Costello (D): 8.1%. Campaign: $154K total (FEC weball26, through 8/26/2026) Outside: n/a
Troy Jackson (D): Not on the primary ballot (he had run for governor and lost that primary). Chosen as replacement nominee by party convention 566 of 571 delegate votes. Won general 53.07%-46.87% over Sen. Susan Collins. Campaign: Raised $26.87M ($23.98M from individuals) / spent $25.28M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) - all after late July Outside: Republican side held about 61% of Maine ad spending through September (AdImpact via Washington Monthly). AIPAC-linked spending of $4.8M+ backed Collins (Latin Times).
Jordan Wood (D): Withdrew from the Senate primary before June 9; listed among convention hopefuls in July; FEC lists him as an ME-02 House candidate (outcome not verified). Campaign: $6.37M disbursed through 9/30/2026 across Senate/ME-02 committees (FEC weball26); $3.10M raised as of May 20 (Wikipedia) Outside: n/a
Primary: Platner out-raised Mills nearly 3-to-1 and won (better-funded WON). General: Jackson and Collins raised similar sums (about $26.9M vs $22.5-25.2M), but GOP-side advertising was larger (61% share through September) and Collins LOST. source
Louisiana Senate (R closed primary May 16 / runoff June 27, 2026)
Julia Letlow (R): Primary 44.8% (1st); won runoff 56.9%; won general 50.88%-49.12% over Jamie Davis (D). Campaign: $6.62M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 incl. general (FEC weball26). About $1M on ads between primary and runoff (AP). Outside: A pro-Letlow super PAC led all runoff-period spending at $4.1M over six weeks (AdImpact via AP). Trump endorsed her.
John Fleming (state treasurer, self-funder) (R): Primary 28.3% (2nd); lost runoff with about 43%. Campaign: $12.35M through 10/14/2026, of which $11.58M was his own loans (FEC weball26). About $1M on ads in runoff period (AP). Outside: Not found
Bill Cassidy (incumbent) (R): Primary 24.8% (3rd) - incumbent eliminated before the runoff. Campaign: $12.60M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26); held $10.1M cash at end of 2025 (NBC News) Outside: Louisiana Freedom Fund ran ads for him (search-result summary; amount not found)
At the campaign level Cassidy ($12.6M) and Fleming ($12.35M, 94% self-funded) each spent roughly double Letlow. Both better-funded candidates LOST; the Trump-endorsed candidate with the smaller campaign account (but the biggest super PAC help in the runoff) won. source
Kentucky Senate (R primary, May 19, 2026; open McConnell seat)Partly confirmed
Andy Barr (R): Won 60.5% (283,833 votes). Won general 54.99%-42.90% over Charles Booker. Campaign: Raised $8.40M / spent $9.65M as of June 30, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); $14.68M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Fairshake crypto network about $8M in support (Fortune citing Tech Influence Watch). Pro-Barr super PAC Keep America Great active (amount not found). Trump endorsed May 1.
Daniel Cameron (R): Lost, 30.8%. Had led early polls. Campaign: Raised $2.15M / spent $2.07M as of June 30, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: Kentucky First Action super PAC (amount not found)
Nate Morris (self-funder) (R): Withdrew May 1, 2026, the day Trump endorsed Barr; endorsed Barr. Reports say Trump offered him an ambassadorship (Al Jazeera). Campaign: Raised $8.59M incl. $6.30M of his own money as of June 30 (Wikipedia/FEC); $6.75M in self-loans, $8.67M spent through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Elon Musk reportedly gave $10M to a pro-Morris effort in Jan 2026 (Wikipedia reference title only - not independently fetched)
Barr (about 4.5x Cameron's campaign spending, plus ~$8M of crypto super PAC help). Better-funded candidate WON; the self-funder quit before the vote. source
Illinois Senate (D primary, Mar 17, 2026; open Durbin seat)
Juliana Stratton (lt. governor) (D): Won 40.4% (507,689). Won general 62.07%-36.34%. Campaign: Raised $4.79M / spent $4.10M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); AP counted just under $2.8M in spending reported before the primary Outside: About $16M in independent expenditures supported her and about $11M opposed her (AP). Illinois Future PAC (about $12M raised, at least $5M from Gov. JB Pritzker) ran a ~$12M ad campaign for her; Democratic Lieutenant Governors Assn. ~$250K (Sun-Times/IPM; Capitol News Illinois). Fairshake/Protect Progress spent about $10M against her.
Raja Krishnamoorthi (D): Lost, 32.7% (411,150). Campaign: Raised $31.39M / spent $28.24M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); $31.53M total (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026). About $28M on paid media (Capitol News Illinois). Outside: More than $4M in independent expenditures opposed him (AP).
Robin Kelly (D): Lost, 18.3%. Campaign: Raised $3.47M / spent $3.28M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: Not found
Krishnamoorthi by about 7-to-1 at the campaign level ($28.2M vs $4.1M). Counting outside money, roughly $39M worked for him or against Stratton versus roughly $24M for Stratton or against him. The better-funded candidate LOST - but the winner was carried by the single largest outside effort (the Pritzker-funded PAC). source
Minnesota Senate (DFL primary, Aug 11, 2026; open Tina Smith seat)
Peggy Flanagan (lt. governor) (DFL): Won about 59%-39%. Won general 53.70%-43.56% over Michele Tafoya (R). Campaign: Raised $6.4M before the primary (OpenSecrets via Newsweek); $1.9M on ads (AdImpact via Newsweek); $10.57M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 incl. general (FEC weball26) Outside: Outside groups: $1.30M supporting her, $7.23M opposing her as of Aug 10 (Ballotpedia). Ad spending by/for her $3.3M (Roll Call column).
Angie Craig (U.S. Rep.) (DFL): Lost by about 20 points. Campaign: Raised $12.6M before the primary (OpenSecrets via Newsweek); $9.6M on ads (AdImpact via Newsweek); $13.23M total through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Outside groups: $9.77M supporting her, $2.31M opposing her as of Aug 10 (Ballotpedia). Ad spending by/for her $13.8M (Roll Call column).
Craig: about 2-to-1 in fundraising, about 5-to-1 in campaign ads, and roughly $17M of outside money on her side vs about $3.6M on Flanagan's. The better-funded candidate LOST decisively. source
Georgia Senate (R primary May 19 / runoff June 16, 2026)Partly confirmed
Mike Collins (R): Primary 40.5%; won runoff 55.5%-44.5%. Lost general to Sen. Jon Ossoff 40.97%-59.03%. Campaign: Raised $4.32M / spent $2.79M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); raised about $4.9M through end of May (AP); $10.18M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Trump endorsed two days before runoff. Outside totals not found.
Derek Dooley (R): Primary 30.2%; lost runoff. Campaign: Raised $3.67M / spent $1.45M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia) Outside: Backed by Gov. Brian Kemp; allied outside spending not found.
Buddy Carter (R): Primary 25.1% (3rd, eliminated). Campaign: Raised $6.71M / spent $6.00M as of Mar 31, 2026 (FEC via Wikipedia); $10.28M total through 9/30/2026 incl. $3.5M in self-loans (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Carter spent the most from his campaign (about $10.3M incl. $3.5M of his own) and finished THIRD. Between the runoff pair, Collins had somewhat more campaign money than Dooley and won. Outside-group totals were not found, so the full picture is incomplete. source
North Carolina Senate (primaries Mar 3, 2026; open Tillis seat)Partly confirmed
Roy Cooper (D): Democratic nominee; won general 58.75%-39.05%. Campaign: Raised $49.6M / spent $40.5M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not itemized
Michael Whatley (R): Republican nominee (Trump-backed); lost general. Campaign: Raised $13.7M / spent $12.8M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Senate GOP leadership-aligned group began pulling ad money out of North Carolina in early October (AP).
Cooper, more than 3-to-1 at the campaign level (Brennan Center lists NC among races where the Democratic campaign outspent the Republican by more than 3-to-1). Better-funded WON the general. source
Massachusetts Senate (D primary, Sep 1, 2026)Partly confirmed
Ed Markey (incumbent) (D): Won about 65%-35% (AP via Roll Call with 81% counted). Won general 63.40%-32.13% over John Deaton. Campaign: Two-year-cycle receipts $5.99M, disbursements $7.00M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not confirmed
Seth Moulton (U.S. Rep.) (D): Lost by about 30 points. Campaign: Receipts $6.67M, disbursements $8.41M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not confirmed
Roughly even. In the FEC two-year file Moulton's committee spent somewhat more ($8.4M vs $7.0M) and he out-raised Markey early (Q4 2025: $2.1M vs $874K, NBC News); a search-result summary of other coverage said the reverse (Markey $8M+ vs Moulton $6M+). Either way money was not decisive: the incumbent won easily. source
South Carolina Senate (R primary June 9; special R primary Aug 11 / runoff Aug 25, 2026)Partly confirmed
Lindsey Graham (incumbent; died July 11, 2026) (R): Won June 9 primary outright with 56.8%. Died July 11, 2026. Campaign: $22.2M disbursed through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26); $13.4M cash on hand at end of 2025 (NBC News) Outside: Trump endorsed early
Mark Lynch (self-funder) (R): June 9: lost, 28.9%. Ran again in Aug 11 special primary: 5.9% (5th). Campaign: $5.83M disbursed through 9/30/2026, incl. $5.05M of his own loans (FEC weball26); raised $5.73M as of Mar 31 (Wikipedia) Outside: Not found
Paul Dans (Project 2025 architect) (R): Withdrew before June 9 and endorsed Lynch (Wikipedia). Campaign: $1.01M disbursed incl. $692K self-loans (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: n/a
Darline Graham (appointed senator, sister of Lindsey Graham) (R): Appointed July 13-14. Special primary Aug 11: 32.8% (1st); runoff Aug 25: beat Rep. Ralph Norman 52.4%-47.6%. Lost general to Annie Andrews (D) 46.64%-51.14%. Campaign: Raised $1.92M / spent $1.28M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Trump endorsed. AI-industry super PAC American Mission spent about $2.7M for her in the general (Fortune).
Ralph Norman (R): Special primary 24.6%; lost runoff 47.6%. Campaign: $3.12M disbursed incl. $2.1M self-loans through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
June primary: incumbent Graham (about 4x self-funder Lynch) - better-funded WON. Special runoff: Norman's campaign (with $2.1M of his own money) out-spent the appointed senator's, and LOST. General: Annie Andrews raised $24.2M to Darline Graham's $1.9M and WON (FEC through 10/14/2026). source
Florida Senate special (D primary, Aug 2026)Partly confirmed
Angie Nixon (D): Won the primary by about 12 points. Lost the general (Brennan Center: Republicans held Florida). Campaign: About $60,000 on ads in the primary (NYT review of AdImpact data via Roll Call column); $8.05M cycle-to-date through 10/14/2026 incl. general (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Alexander Vindman (D): Lost the primary. Campaign: About $2.2M on ads in the primary (same source); $16.37M total disbursed through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Vindman, about 37-to-1 on ads and roughly 2-to-1 in total campaign money. Better-funded candidate LOST the primary. source
Kentucky 4th District (R primary, May 19, 2026)
Ed Gallrein (Trump-endorsed) (R): Won 54.9%-45.1%. Won general 54.22%-40.86%. Campaign: Raised $4.10M / spent $3.66M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: About $19M of ad spending benefited him, nearly $9.4M of it from AIPAC and other pro-Israel groups (Al Jazeera). United Democracy Project $4.1M+; RJC Victory Fund $3.9M; Trump-aligned MAGA KY super PAC $7M+, mostly anti-Massie ads (Anadolu citing elections data/reports). FactCheck.org: UDP $3M+ against Massie and nearly $500K for Gallrein.
Thomas Massie (incumbent) (R): Lost renomination. Campaign: Raised $8.89M ($8.70M from individuals) / spent $9.33M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Remainder of the roughly $32-35M total (pro-Massie groups; breakdown not found)
Mixed: Massie's own campaign out-raised Gallrein's by more than 2-to-1, but outside money favored Gallrein (about $19M of roughly $34M in ads). The side with more total money (Gallrein + Trump-aligned and pro-Israel groups) WON; the candidate with the bigger campaign account LOST. source
New York 10th District (D primary, June 23, 2026)Partly confirmed
Brad Lander (Mamdani-backed) (D): Won by nearly 30 points (unofficial count about 65%-34%). Campaign: Raised $2.79M / spent $2.71M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Dan Goldman (incumbent) (D): Lost renomination. Campaign: Spent $9.62M through 9/30/2026, incl. $2.45M of his own money ($325K contributions + $2.125M loans) (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Goldman, about 3.5-to-1. Better-funded incumbent LOST. source
New York 12th District (D primary, June 23, 2026; open Nadler seat)
Micah Lasher (D): Won, 39% (margin of about 4,300 votes). Campaign: $3.18M through 10/14/2026 incl. $500K loan (FEC weball26) Outside: Backed by party leaders; super PAC totals for him not itemized
Alex Bores (author of NY AI-safety law) (D): Lost, 35%. Campaign: $3.98M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: AGAINST: Think Big (Leading the Future / OpenAI-linked) at least $8M. FOR: Anthropic-linked super PACs plus a super PAC funded by crypto billionaire Chris Larsen, about $18M combined (Politico tally via City & State); Jobs and Democracy nearly $7M (search summary). The Intercept: the two AI networks together spent $21.3M for or against him.
Jack Schlossberg (D): 11%. Campaign: $4.06M incl. $1.03M loans (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: n/a
George Conway (D): 6% (5th). Campaign: $7.08M incl. $2.0M loans (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: n/a
Bores had the most money behind him (about $18M of friendly super PAC spending vs $8M+ against) and LOST narrowly; the biggest-spending candidate committee (Conway, $7.1M) finished fifth. The winner had the smallest campaign account of the top four. source
New York 13th District (D primary, June 23, 2026)Partly confirmed
Darializa Avila Chevalier (DSA; Mamdani-backed) (D): Won; defeated a five-term incumbent. Campaign: Raised $1.60M / spent $1.45M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Adriano Espaillat (incumbent) (D): Lost renomination. Campaign: Raised $2.89M / spent $3.28M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: AP reports AIPAC gave heavily to him (amount not stated)
Espaillat, more than 2-to-1. Better-funded incumbent LOST. source
New York 7th District (D primary, June 23, 2026; open Velazquez seat)Partly confirmed
Claire Valdez (DSA; Mamdani-backed) (D): Won 56.2%; won general 83.3%. Campaign: Raised $1.92M / spent $1.81M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Antonio Reynoso (endorsed by Velazquez) (D): Lost, 35.6%. Campaign: Raised $1.02M / spent $1.01M through 9/30/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Valdez, nearly 2-to-1. Here the insurgent was the better-funded candidate and WON. source
New York 17th District (D primary, June 23, 2026) - self-funder Peter ChatzkyPartly confirmed
Peter Chatzky (self-funder) (D): Left the race in spring 2026 after lewd social-media posts resurfaced. Campaign: Loaned his campaign $11.29M (FEC weball26, through 6/30/2026); NOTUS: recouped $10.7M of $11.3M after quitting; NOTUS earlier put actual own-money spending near $6M Outside: n/a
Cait Conley (D): Won the nomination over four opponents. Reported to have unseated Rep. Mike Lawler in November (Latin Times says AIPAC's ~$960K for Lawler was unsuccessful; NY delegation went from 19D-7R to 20D-6R per Wikipedia). Campaign: Raised $10.71M / spent $9.76M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not itemized
Chatzky had by far the largest account on paper and never reached the ballot. In the general Conley and Lawler raised nearly identical sums ($10.7M vs $10.3M). source
New York 21st District (R primary, June 23, 2026) - self-funder Anthony ConstantinoPartly confirmed
Anthony Constantino (Sticker Mule CEO; Trump-endorsed) (R): Won the primary over Assemblyman Robert Smullen. General-election outcome NOT verified today. Campaign: $14.47M disbursed through 10/14/2026, funded by $14.4M of his own loans and essentially no individual donors (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Robert Smullen (R): Lost the primary; remained on the Conservative Party line. Campaign: $1.32M incl. $1.0M self-loan (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: Not found
Constantino, more than 10-to-1, all his own money. Self-funder WON the primary. source
Illinois 9th District (D primary, Mar 17, 2026; open Schakowsky seat)
Daniel Biss (Evanston mayor) (D): Won. Campaign: Raised $3.45M / spent $2.84M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: FOR: 314 Action Fund and Congressional Progressive Caucus PAC, $500K+ each (AP). AGAINST: Elect Chicago Women (AIPAC-linked) $1.4M+ (AP). Responsible Statecraft totals AIPAC-network spending against him at $6.31M.
Laura Fine (state senator) (D): Lost. Campaign: $2.78M (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: Elect Chicago Women $4.3M+ in support (AP; Sun-Times/IPM put the group's IL-9 total at $5.8M); Elect Democratic Women Action Fund $500K+.
Kat Abughazaleh (D): Lost. Campaign: $4.07M, virtually all from individuals (FEC weball26, through 10/14/2026) Outside: Only opposition spending: Chicago Progressive Partnership (AIPAC-linked) $266K against her.
Fine had the most money behind her once AIPAC-linked super PACs are counted (about $7M+ total) and LOST. Abughazaleh ran the best-funded campaign committee and also LOST. The winner, Biss, was the main target of the outside money. source
Illinois 7th District (D primary, Mar 17, 2026; open Danny Davis seat)
La Shawn Ford (D): Won. Campaign: Raised $819K / spent $726K through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Fairshake (crypto) spent $2.5M AGAINST him.
Melissa Conyears-Ervin (D): Lost. Campaign: $823K (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: United Democracy Project (AIPAC) about $5M, mostly in support.
Conyears-Ervin's side, by roughly $5M of AIPAC money, while crypto spent $2.5M against the eventual winner. Both big outside spenders LOST. source
Illinois 2nd District (D primary, Mar 17, 2026; open Robin Kelly seat)
Donna Miller (D): Won. Campaign: Raised $2.70M / spent $2.61M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Affordable Chicago Now (AIPAC-linked, donors undisclosed at the time) about $4.3-4.4M in support.
Jesse Jackson Jr. (D): Lost. Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Think Big (Democratic arm of AI-industry PAC Leading the Future) about $1.4M in support.
Robert Peters (D): Lost (third). Campaign: $1.32M (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: Fairshake about $817K AGAINST him.
Miller (largest outside backing plus the largest campaign among those checked). Better-funded WON - an AIPAC-linked win; an AI-industry PAC loss; a Fairshake "win" in that its target lost. source
Illinois 8th District (D primary, Mar 17, 2026; open Krishnamoorthi seat)
Melissa Bean (former U.S. Rep.) (D): Won. Campaign: Raised $2.46M / spent $2.16M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Elect Chicago Women (AIPAC-linked) $3.9M; Think Big (AI) about $1.1M - both in support.
Junaid Ahmed (D): Lost (Newsweek lists his defeat among AIPAC's successful interventions). Campaign: Raised $1.72M / spent $1.71M (FEC weball26, through 10/14/2026) Outside: Not found
Bean, by roughly $5M of outside support. Better-funded WON. source
New Jersey 11th District special (D primary, Feb 5, 2026; Sherrill vacancy)Partly confirmed
Analilia Mejia (D): Won the special primary; now serving in Congress (Newsweek). Campaign: Raised $2.23M / spent $2.11M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26; includes later elections) Outside: Not found
Tom Malinowski (former U.S. Rep.) (D): Lost. Campaign: $1.51M (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: United Democracy Project spent over $2M AGAINST him (FactCheck.org).
AIPAC's super PAC was the biggest spender and its target lost - but the beneficiary was Mejia, a progressive whom Newsweek groups with Israel-critical candidates. source
North Carolina 4th District (D primary, Mar 3, 2026)Partly confirmed
Valerie Foushee (incumbent) (D): Won renomination (Newsweek lists challenger's defeat among AIPAC successes). Campaign: Raised $1.05M ($574K from PACs) / spent $1.08M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Outside groups spent a record $4.2M in the primary, mainly supporting her (NPR).
Nida Allam (D): Lost. Campaign: Raised and spent $1.13M, mostly from individuals (FEC weball26, through 7/15/2026) Outside: Not found
Foushee's side, thanks to about $4.2M in outside spending; the two campaign committees were about even. Better-funded side WON. source
Maryland 6th District (D primary, June 23, 2026) - dueling self-funders
April McClain Delaney (incumbent) (D): Won by about 6-7 points (44%-37% at AP call). Campaign: Self-loaned about $7.4M before the primary (Roll Call/Legis1); $11.0M in self-loans and $12.43M spent through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Crypto-affiliated Protect Progress backed her (Roll Call, via search summary; amount not found).
David Trone (former U.S. Rep.; Total Wine co-founder) (D): Lost. Campaign: Self-loaned $25.0M; spent $25.0M through 9/30/2026; only $197K from individual donors (FEC weball26) Outside: None found
Trone, more than 3-to-1 in the primary. The bigger self-funder LOST (after also losing a $63M self-funded Senate primary in 2024, per NOTUS). source
Maryland 5th District (D primary, June 23, 2026; open Hoyer seat)Partly confirmed
Adrian Boafo (D): Won. Campaign: Raised $1.91M / spent $1.81M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: United Democracy Project (AIPAC) $5.73M in support (Responsible Statecraft).
Quincy Bareebe (self-funder) (D): Did not win the nomination (Boafo did). Campaign: $6.81M spent, incl. $6.61M in self-loans (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: None found
Boafo's side once AIPAC money is included (about $7.5M vs $6.8M). AIPAC-backed candidate WON; a $6.6M self-funder LOST. source
Michigan 13th District (D primary, Aug 4, 2026)Not confirmed
Shri Thanedar (incumbent; self-funder) (D): UNVERIFIED Campaign: Spent $4.16M through 9/30/2026; $2.97M self-loans this cycle; reported $5.94M cash on hand (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Donavan McKinney (Justice Democrats-backed) (D): UNVERIFIED Campaign: Raised $1.88M / spent $1.75M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Thanedar (about 2.4-to-1 in spending, largely his own money). source
California 14th District special (runoff Aug 18, 2026)Partly confirmed
Aisha Wahab (D): Won the special runoff and the November general (Latin Times). Campaign: Raised $1.21M / spent $752K through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: Opposed by United Democracy Project.
Melissa Hernandez (D): Lost both. Campaign: Raised $2.11M / spent $2.00M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: United Democracy Project $4.92M supporting her / opposing Wahab (Responsible Statecraft).
Hernandez, by a wide margin (about $7M combined vs under $1M). Better-funded, AIPAC-backed candidate LOST. source
California 11th District (top-two primary, June 2, 2026; open Pelosi seat)Partly confirmed
Scott Wiener (D): Advanced to the general against Connie Chan (D). Campaign: Raised $5.81M / spent $5.19M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: A dark-money affiliate of the Anthropic-aligned Public First network gave $3M to a super PAC supporting him (The Intercept).
Connie Chan (D): Advanced to the general. Campaign: Raised $2.40M / spent $1.82M (FEC weball26, through 10/14/2026) Outside: Not found
Saikat Chakrabarti (self-funder; Justice Democrats co-founder) (D): Eliminated in the primary. Campaign: Nearly $9M of his own money, reported as the largest self-funded congressional primary effort in California history (Axios San Francisco, via search summary); NOTUS had him at nearly $5M by April. Not located in the weball26 file. Outside: n/a
Chakrabarti out-spent the field with his own money and LOST. source
California 4th District (top-two primary June 2 and all-Democratic general, 2026) - self-funder Eric JonesNot confirmed
Eric Jones (former venture capitalist) (D): Advanced to the November general against the incumbent (Wikipedia candidate table). Final result UNVERIFIED. Campaign: $16.52M spent through 10/14/2026; $14.86M of his own money ($10.06M contributions + $4.8M loans) (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Mike Thompson (incumbent) (D): Advanced; final result UNVERIFIED. Campaign: $5.29M spent through 10/14/2026; $2.44M from PACs (FEC weball26) Outside: Not found
Jones, about 3-to-1, almost entirely self-funded - the largest House self-funder still running in November per the FEC file. source
Florida 2nd District (R primary, Aug 2026) - self-funder Keith GrossPartly confirmed
Keith Gross (R): Lost the Republican primary (NOTUS). Campaign: $12.32M spent, $12.24M of it his own loans; $98K from individuals (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: None found
Gross (about $12M of his own money). Self-funder LOST. source
Missouri 1st District (D primary, Aug 2026) - rematchPartly confirmed
Wesley Bell (incumbent) (D): Won (Newsweek lists Cori Bush's defeat among AIPAC successes). Campaign: Raised $4.02M / spent $4.05M through 10/14/2026 (FEC weball26) Outside: AIPAC involvement reported; amount not retrieved
Cori Bush (former U.S. Rep.) (D): Lost. Campaign: Raised $1.52M / spent $1.53M (FEC weball26, through 9/30/2026) Outside: Not found
Bell, about 2.7-to-1 at the campaign level. Better-funded WON. source
California governor (top-two primary, June 2, 2026) - Tom Steyer
Tom Steyer (self-funder) (D): Finished third; did not advance. Campaign: At least $213-216M of his own money (Washington Examiner: $213M+; AP and MS NOW via AlterNet: $216M) - the costliest self-funded gubernatorial primary bid in state history Outside: n/a
Xavier Becerra (D): Advanced (about 28% in early count); won general 65.6%-34.4% (98% reporting, Wikipedia). Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Not retrieved
Steve Hilton (R): Advanced (about 25%); lost general. Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Not retrieved
Steyer by an enormous margin. Self-funder LOST. source
Georgia governor (R primary May 19 / runoff June 16, 2026; general) - Rick Jackson
Rick Jackson (billionaire health-care executive, self-funder) (R): Won the runoff over Trump-endorsed Lt. Gov. Burt Jones. LOST the general to Keisha Lance Bottoms (D). Campaign: $83.5M of his own money by the May primary (Al Jazeera); about $100M by the runoff (AP); over $100M by late October (Brennan Center) Outside: Georgians for Integrity, a dark-money group linked to him (he denies it), spent at least $13.5M attacking Burt Jones (Brennan Center).
Burt Jones (R): Lost the runoff. Campaign: $17M of his own money (MS NOW via AlterNet) Outside: Trump endorsement
Keisha Lance Bottoms (D): Won the general. Campaign: Out-spent about 5-to-1 by Jackson as of late October (Brennan Center) Outside: Democratic Governors Association $11.5M; Pritzker and Bloomberg $1M each to her leadership committee.
Jackson in both rounds. Self-funder WON the primary runoff (beating Trump's pick) and LOST the general despite a 5-to-1 edge. source
New York City mayor 2025 (D primary June 24; general Nov 4, 2025) - template for the 2026 "NYC-style insurgents"
Zohran Mamdani (D/WFP): Primary: won 56.39%-43.61% in final ranked-choice round. General: won 50.78%. Campaign: Publicly financed; 40,824 contributors over the cycle, average donation $90 (Citizens Union) Outside: Super PACs supporting him in the general: $4.47M (Citizens Union).
Andrew Cuomo (D primary; independent in general): Lost both: 43.61% (primary final round); 41.32% (general). Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Super PACs supporting him in the general: $28.43M (83% of outside money), incl. Fix the City $8.44M; more than $30M was spent on losing super PAC efforts in the primary. Michael Bloomberg gave $13.3M in all ($8.3M primary + $5M general).
Curtis Sliwa (R): 7.01%. Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: $789K
Cuomo's side by more than 6-to-1 in general-election super PAC money. Better-funded side LOST twice. source
2025 governor races: New Jersey and Virginia (Nov 4, 2025)Not confirmed
Mikie Sherrill (NJ) (D): Won 56.88%-42.52% over Jack Ciattarelli. Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Not retrieved
Abigail Spanberger (VA) (D): Won 57.58%-42.22% over Winsome Earle-Sears. Campaign: Not retrieved Outside: Not retrieved
NOT VERIFIED today (search budget exhausted before finance figures were retrieved). source
Abdul El-Sayed (Michigan): ran against corporate PAC and super PAC money, was outspent by outside groups in both elections, won both
Bridge Michigan and Latin Times report El-Sayed has vowed not to accept corporate PAC donations; NBC says he condemned money in politics and attacked Haley Stevens for taking corporate PAC money and for the AIPAC-affiliated ad campaign on her behalf. FEC summary file: $47.2M of his $53.8M came from individuals and $0.40M from PACs (labor and left-leaning groups, per Bridge); donors of under $200 gave about $11.2M (Bridge). In the primary, outside groups favored Stevens about 10 to 1 and he won by 0.9 points; in the general, outside groups favored Mike Rogers about 1.8 to 1 and he won by 7. Both statements cut two ways: his own campaign out-raised each opponent's (modestly in the primary, 2.3 to 1 in the general), and super PACs also spent roughly $95M on his side in the general despite his criticism of them (the Washington Examiner ran a piece on that point; headline seen only). source
AIPAC / United Democracy Project: 2026 spending and win-loss record
Post-election tally by Responsible Statecraft (Quincy Institute, Nov 4, 2026): AIPAC spent $84.1M through UDP and other PACs on races decided so far; $55.3M (nearly two-thirds) went to races where its preferred outcome lost. By the same yardstick 69% of UDP money was on the winning side in 2022 and 87% in 2024. Largest items: Michigan Senate $31.47M opposing Abdul El-Sayed across primary and general (he won both); IL-9 $6.31M against Daniel Biss (he won); MD-5 $5.73M for Adrian Boafo (won); IL-7 $5.03M for Melissa Conyears-Ervin (lost); CA-14 special $4.92M for Melissa Hernandez (lost). Other reported results: KY-4, $3M-4.2M against Thomas Massie (Massie lost - a win); NJ-11 special, $2M+ against Tom Malinowski (he lost, to progressive Analilia Mejia); IL-2 and IL-8 wins through AIPAC-linked pop-up PACs (Affordable Chicago Now ~$4.4M for Donna Miller; Elect Chicago Women $3.9M for Melissa Bean); Maine, $4.8M+ for Susan Collins (lost); Ohio, $840K+ for Jon Husted (lost); NY-17, ~$960K for Mike Lawler (lost) (Latin Times, Nov 14). Earlier snapshots: AIPAC PAC plus UDP had $104.3M in political spending by Aug 3 (Sludge, FEC review); UDP alone raised about $104M and spent $52.5M through June, with top donors including Paul Singer, Marc Rowan and Haim Saban (FactCheck.org); Politico found UDP routed more than 40% of its primary spending through pop-up/pass-through PACs. Latin Times puts the full-cycle total near $120M (up 26% on 2024) and reports AIPAC's own claim that 234+ candidates it supported won; it also says 30 incoming members won on platforms explicitly rejecting AIPAC ties and that AIPAC announced on Oct 21, 2026 it would stop endorsements and direct PAC contributions - both single-source claims that need confirmation before publication. source
Fairshake and affiliated crypto PACs (Protect Progress, Defend American Jobs): war chest and record
Fortune (Nov 4, 2026, citing Molly White's Tech Influence Watch): crypto PACs spent more than $170M of a roughly $260M war chest; the Fairshake network put about $75M behind Republicans, about $30M behind Democrats and about $36M into opposing Democrats (including in primaries). Big losses: Ohio Senate - $40M+ for Jon Husted and about $24M against Sherrod Brown, who won; WI-1 - about $2M for Rep. Bryan Steil, who lost; Texas Senate - about $1.4M for Paxton (lost); Michigan Senate - about $810K for Mike Rogers (lost); Iowa Senate - about $700K for Ashley Hinson via the Winklevoss-linked Digital Freedom Fund (lost); Illinois Senate primary - about $10M against Juliana Stratton (she won); IL-7 - $2.5M against La Shawn Ford (he won). Wins: Nebraska Senate - $13M+ against independent Dan Osborn (Ricketts held the seat); Kentucky Senate primary - about $8M for Andy Barr (won); IL-2 - $817K against Robert Peters (he lost). CoinGeek, citing the Citation Needed tracker, puts Fairshake-network spending at $154.5M, including $56.6M in Ohio (over $64M with other crypto groups). By count rather than dollars, Reuters (as relayed by Parameter) had Fairshake winning 29 of 34 called races as of Nov 4 - critics note many were safe seats. Fairshake reportedly keeps about $56M for 2028. Brennan Center: crypto interests supplied $304M, 13% of all giving by the top 40 donors, through mid-October. Fairshake had raised $193M by Jan 2026 (Axios headline; not fetched). source
Elon Musk / America PAC: 2026 spending and results
New York Times analysis (Theodore Schleifer, Nov 2, 2026; FEC, IRS and state records): about $474M in disclosed giving since Jan 1, 2025 - the most by any donor in one cycle other than self-funding candidates - and an undercount because federal data stopped at Oct 14 and dark money is excluded. Breakdown: America PAC (his own super PAC) about $216M; Senate Leadership Fund $168M, nearly all effectively for Ken Paxton in Texas; Congressional Leadership Fund $30M; other federal GOP groups/candidates about $44M; state efforts in Michigan, Texas and Wisconsin about $16M. About $212M went behind Paxton ($224M counting other Texas groups). Other tallies: AP, at least $445M with $158M effectively for Paxton and at least $5M for Gov. Greg Abbott; Brennan Center, about $483M through mid-October including his company United States of America Inc. He also gave $5M to the pro-Ramaswamy V-PAC in Ohio. Results: Paxton lost to James Talarico 55%-43%; Abbott lost to Gina Hinojosa; Ramaswamy lost; Republicans lost both chambers of Congress (Democrats at 54 Senate seats and 228+ House seats in early counts). Fortune named no Musk-backed winner. In 2025 his $25M-$47M Wisconsin Supreme Court effort also lost. For comparison he gave about $290M in 2024. source
AI-industry super PACs: Leading the Future vs. Anthropic-aligned Public First network
The Intercept (Oct 29, 2026): the two AI networks spent $50.7M in primaries, and only 5% of their direct expenditures went to contested general-election races. Leading the Future (founded Aug 2025; arms Think Big for Democrats and American Mission for Republicans) was funded chiefly by OpenAI president Greg Brockman and his wife ($25M in 2025; a second $25M reported by the NYT) and by Andreessen Horowitz (Andreessen and Horowitz gave $115-116M to Republican-side groups overall, per Brennan/Fortune); it had $34M on hand late in the cycle and had spent $7.4M on general elections by Oct 26. Public First launched months later; Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei gave $1M and Anthropic gave an affiliated nonprofit millions on condition it not be used for elections; it had spent $1.1M on general elections by Oct 26. A secondary aggregator (not fetchable today) put totals through Oct 30 at $81.3M: Public First network $43.8M, Leading the Future network $37.5M. Outcomes: NY-12 - the networks spent $21.3M for or against Alex Bores (Think Big $8M+ against; Anthropic-linked PACs and a Chris Larsen-funded PAC about $18M for); Bores lost 35%-39% to Micah Lasher. IL-2 - Think Big $1.4M for Jesse Jackson Jr., lost. IL-8 - Think Big $1.1M for Melissa Bean, won. South Carolina Senate - American Mission about $2.7M for Sen. Darline Graham, its only competitive general-election bet, lost. CA-11 - a Public First dark-money affiliate gave $3M to a pro-Scott Wiener super PAC; Wiener advanced. Meta-backed Making Our Tomorrow went 1-for-4 in Illinois legislative primaries. A Campaign Legal Center complaint alleges Leading the Future routed $30M+ through new Delaware shell vendors. A Data for Progress poll for the rival Guardrails Alliance found about three-quarters of voters less likely to back a candidate with AI super PAC support. No complete post-election win-loss scorecard for either network was found. source
MAGA Inc., Trump-aligned and party-leadership super PACs: totals
MAGA Inc. cash on hand: $304M at end of 2025 (NBC), nearly $350M in April (NPR), nearly $416M at end of August (AP); it started heavy spending only in September, paying far higher ad rates than candidates (about $894 per airing vs about $290 for Talarico's campaign). MAGA Inc. and No Going Back Inc. spent $150M+ in a few weeks through early October (Brennan). Senate GOP leadership super PACs (SLF PAC plus Texas PAC) accounted for $280M in independent expenditures through September - more than SLF's whole 2022 total - and Texas PAC alone spent $83M+ on ads in one month. Leadership-tied super PACs of both parties: $494M through September; their dark-money affiliates had raised $198M by June. AP (Oct 8): Republicans had about $1B to spend across roughly six groups vs about $579M for comparable Democratic groups. 2025 fundraising: SLF $103M, CLF $72M, Senate Majority PAC $59M, House Majority PAC $69M (NBC). Independent expenditures by all outside groups reached about $2B through September, up 51% on 2022 in real terms; among the top 20 spending groups Republican money was more than double Democratic. Cycle-wide: AdImpact counted nearly $12B in ads, with the GOP side at $5.45B, about $430M more than Democrats; OpenSecrets' preliminary all-in tally was Democrats $5.5B vs Republicans $5.1B. Outcome: Republicans lost the House and Senate. Final full-cycle totals for each individual super PAC (MAGA Inc., SLF, CLF, SMP, HMP) were NOT found - year-end FEC reports are due in January 2027. source
Candidates who ran against big money / corporate PACs / billionaires, and how they fared
Won: Zohran Mamdani (NYC mayor 2025; out-spent 6-to-1 in super PAC money; average donation $90). Abdul El-Sayed (Michigan Senate; out-advertised 10-to-1 in the primary; $47.2M of his $53.8M came from individuals). James Talarico (Texas Senate; $139.8M of $146.3M from individuals, $0.47M from PACs; listed fighting corruption as a top priority per Brennan). Peggy Flanagan (Minnesota Senate; refused corporate PAC money per Newsweek; out-raised 2-to-1 in the primary). Troy Jackson (Maine Senate; $24.0M of $26.9M from individuals; beat Susan Collins). Brad Lander, Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier (Mamdani-backed NYC House insurgents; two beat better-funded incumbents). Graham Platner won the Maine primary with 72% and $16M raised but withdrew in July over a sexual-assault allegation he denies. Lost: Dan Osborn (independent, Nebraska Senate; $10.6M of $11.0M from individuals; faced $13M+ in crypto spending; lost to Pete Ricketts, who put $7.3M of his own money in). Kat Abughazaleh (IL-9; $4.07M small-donor campaign, third behind Biss). Saikat Chakrabarti (CA-11; nearly $9M self-funded, eliminated). Cori Bush (MO-1) and Nida Allam (NC-4) lost to better-funded, outside-backed incumbents. Context: 31% of all general-election TV ads mentioned ethics or campaign finance, the highest since 2012, and at least 40% of pro-Democratic ads did (Brennan/Wesleyan Media Project); 92% of voters called corruption a big problem (Brennan poll). CAVEAT: explicit "no corporate PAC" pledges were confirmed in a fetched source only for Flanagan (and McClain Delaney's campaign claim); pledge status for the others is inferred from FEC funding mix and should be checked. No End Citizens United count of 2026 no-corporate-PAC candidates was found. source
Dark money, megadonors and small donors in 2026
Dark money: about $1B had moved through groups that hide their donors by Aug 31, 2026 (New York Times, cited by Brennan); a Brennan piece of Oct 14 refers to about $1.3B. Dark-money groups among the top 40 donors gave $699M through mid-October - 29% of top-40 giving, about 13 times the 2014 level - more than half from four groups tied to congressional party leadership. Megadonors: the top 40 donors gave about $2.4B through mid-October, a midterm record, more than 50% above all of 2022 in real terms; the price of entry to the top 40 was $25M; Republican-only donors gave about $1.5B, over three times Democratic-only donors; no labor union made the top 40. Named: Musk ~$483M, Richard and Elizabeth Uihlein ~$147M, Andreessen and Horowitz ~$115M, Soros ~$102M, Miriam Adelson $67M, Bloomberg $61M. Twenty mostly-billionaire donors had spent about $1.2B by late August, 18 of them favoring Republicans (NYT via Brennan). Candidate money ran the other way: through September Democratic congressional candidates had raised about $2.36B to Republicans' $1.58B (AP, FEC data), and in 10 of the 13 costliest Senate races the Democrat's own committee out-spent the Republican's (Brennan). The FEC lacked a quorum for most of the cycle. ActBlue vs WinRed 2026 totals and an explicit small-donor share were NOT found today. source
Post-election analyses: did the bigger spender win in 2026?
Brennan Center, "In Top Senate Races, Parties Spend to a Tie" (Ian Vandewalker, Nov 13, 2026): across the 13 most expensive Senate contests Democrats (plus Nebraska's Democratic-backed independent) had 49% of spending; Democrats out-spent Republicans in 5 of the 13 and were within 10 points in 9; their lowest share anywhere was 40%; the Democrat's own campaign committee out-spent the Republican's in 10 of 13; Democrats won all of these races except Florida and Nebraska, with Alaska uncalled. Race figures given: Texas - Talarico campaign $136M vs Paxton $18M; pro-Paxton super PACs $324M (over $200M from Musk) vs pro-Talarico $145M; $624M in total ads; Talarico won. Ohio - Brown campaign $64M vs Husted $16M; pro-Husted outside $264M vs pro-Brown $159M; $538M in ads; Brown won. Michigan - $405M in ads. Democratic campaigns out-spent Republican campaigns more than 3-to-1 in Georgia, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Ohio and Texas. Outside the 13: Louisiana - 41% of spending favored the Democrat, who narrowly lost; Mississippi - 73% favored the Democrat, who won by several thousand votes. The piece stresses that candidate dollars buy more airtime than super PAC dollars because of candidate ad rates; it gives no full 13-row table. AP (Nov 4): Republicans and allies out-spent Democrats on ads $5.45B to roughly $5.0B and still suffered a wipeout; a UMass political scientist said money matters mainly at the margins. Fortune (Nov 4) quotes a forecaster calling it "the biggest defeat for big money in politics in American history." Pre-election: a Roll Call column (Sep 2) tallied four marquee primaries (MI-Sen D, MN-Sen D, FL-Sen D, TX-Sen R) where winners spent about $16.8M on ads and losers about $126.8M; Axios (Aug 14) reported that in the three most competitive GOP Senate primaries the losers had the bigger ad budgets (headline and summary seen in search results only). Counter-examples where more money won: Talarico (TX-D primary), Barr (KY), Gallrein side (KY-4), Ossoff, Cooper, Letlow (LA general), Ricketts (NE), Foushee, Bell, Miller, Bean, Boafo. The Portside piece "Knowledge Beat Money in the 2026 Midterms" was not found on portside.org today. source
Most expensive House races of 2026 and whether the bigger spender won
Primaries (verified): KY-4 was the costliest House primary on record - over $32M in ads by May 17 (AdImpact) - and the side with more total money (Gallrein plus Trump-aligned and pro-Israel groups, about $19M) beat Rep. Thomas Massie. MD-6: about $32M of two candidates' own money; David Trone ($25M) lost to April McClain Delaney. NY-12: at least $21.3M from AI networks alone; the most-supported candidate (Bores) lost. Chicago-area open seats: more than $62M across four Democratic House primaries (Capitol News Illinois), with outside groups out-spending all candidates combined in four of five (AP). NC-4: record $4.2M outside. Largest House self-funders in the FEC file: Trone $25.0M (lost primary), Eric Jones CA-4 $14.9M (general result unverified), Constantino NY-21 $14.4M (won primary; general unverified), Gross FL-2 $12.2M (lost primary), Chatzky NY-17 $11.3M loaned (quit), McClain Delaney MD-6 $11.0M (won). General election: a ranked list of the most expensive House general-election races and their outcomes was NOT found today. Partial indicators: House ad spending in September ran $172.5M Republican to $156.8M Democratic (AdImpact via Washington Monthly), yet Democrats gained at least 19 seats and held 228+ in early counts; crypto-backed Rep. Bryan Steil (WI-1, about $2M in crypto support, $6.4M campaign) lost. source
Self-funders: the 2026 record
NOTUS (Sep 8, 2026): a record 69 candidates put more than $1M of their own money into 2026 federal races, lending their campaigns $160M collectively; about two-thirds failed to reach the November ballot. (In 2024, 65 people lent $1M+ and 10 were elected.) Named losers: David Trone (~$25M, MD-6), Keith Gross (~$12M, FL-2), John Fleming (~$12M, Louisiana Senate), Thomas Chalifoux (~$2M+, FL-9, third), Daniel Keenan ($1.6M, Arizona, lost with about 42%); Peter Chatzky quit NY-17 and took back $10.7M of $11.3M. Also: Nate Morris ($6.3-6.75M, Kentucky Senate) quit; Mark Lynch ($5.05M, South Carolina Senate) lost twice; Quincy Bareebe ($6.6M, MD-5) lost; Saikat Chakrabarti (~$9M, CA-11) lost; Buddy Carter ($3.5M loans, Georgia Senate) third; Ralph Norman ($2.1M, SC special) lost runoff; Don Tracy ($4.25M, Illinois Senate general) lost 36%-62%. Governors: Tom Steyer ($213-216M, California) third in primary; Vivek Ramaswamy (at least $36M, Ohio) lost the general to Amy Acton; Rick Jackson ($100M+, Georgia) won the GOP runoff but lost the general. Self-funders who won: April McClain Delaney ($7.4M-11M, MD-6), Anthony Constantino ($14.4M, NY-21 primary), Pete Ricketts ($7.3M, Nebraska Senate), Dan Goldman is a counter-case (put in $2.45M and lost NY-10). source
These are figures as reported by the sources named, gathered in November 2026. They can differ from the FEC totals in the race explorer, which run through mid-October and count only general-election outside spending.
States and ballot measures
- California Proposition 22 (2020): gig companies' record spending - the big-money side WON: Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, Instacart and Postmates put in over $205 million; opponents (mostly labor) about $19 million. Passed 58.63% to 41.37%. Described as the most expensive ballot measure in California history. Struck down by a trial court in 2021, reinstated on appeal in 2023, upheld unanimously by the California Supreme Court in 2024. Wikipedia 2020 California Proposition 22 page (cites Ballotpedia, CNN, CNET)
- California Propositions 26 and 27 (2022, sports betting): both LOST badly: Prop 27 (online betting): 17.72% yes, 82.28% no. Prop 26 (tribal in-person betting): 33% yes, 67% no. Spending totals (widely described as a record for ballot measures) were NOT confirmed in a fetched source today. Wikipedia 2022 California Proposition 27 and Proposition 26 pages (results from California Secretary of State)
- Ohio Issue 1, November 2023 (abortion-rights amendment): the better-funded side WON: Passed 56.78% to 43.22%. Yes committee (Ohioans United for Reproductive Rights): $42.5 million raised, $42.4 million spent. No committee (Protect Women Ohio): $30.4 million raised, $30.8 million spent. Wikipedia November 2023 Ohio Issue 1 page (committee finance table)
- Maine Question 1 (2024): voters capped contributions to super PACs; a court has blocked it: Set a $5,000 limit on contributions to independent-expenditure PACs. Passed 74.91% to 25.09% (600,191 to 201,034). Sponsoring committee raised about $1.52 million. A federal district judge blocked enforcement on July 15, 2025, relying on SpeechNow v. FEC; appeal to the First Circuit was pending as of January 2026. Wikipedia 2024 Maine Question 1 page
- Wisconsin Supreme Court election, April 2025: most expensive judicial race in U.S. history; the Musk-backed candidate LOST: Susan Crawford 55.02% (1,301,137) vs Brad Schimel 44.92% (1,062,330). Total spending topped $100 million (Brennan Center). Elon Musk and groups tied to him spent more than $25 million supporting Schimel. Candidate committees through June 30, 2025: Crawford raised $33,725,335; Schimel raised $15,736,903 (Wisconsin Ethics Commission). Wikipedia 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court election page (cites Brennan Center, WISN-TV, WisPolitics, Wisconsin Ethics Commission)
- State public financing: Arizona and Maine have run full 'clean elections' programs since 2000; Connecticut also fully funds participating candidates: Arizona and Maine systems in effect since 2000; about three-quarters of Maine legislators have run with public funds. Connecticut's program survived a 2009-2010 court challenge with its core intact. In 2011 the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Arizona's matching-funds trigger (Arizona Free Enterprise Club's Freedom Club PAC v. Bennett). Wikipedia Publicly funded elections page
- Virginia governor 2025: the candidate with the early money lead WON: Abigail Spanberger won by 15.36 percentage points. Through March 31, 2025 she had raised $16,301,998 vs $5,677,456 for Winsome Earle-Sears (Virginia Public Access Project). Full-cycle totals not found. Wikipedia 2025 Virginia gubernatorial election page (cites VPAP)
- Ballot-measure money, 2024 (context): OpenSecrets projected ballot measure committees would raise about $1.4 billion in the 2023-2024 cycle; state candidates, parties and ballot committees together raised about $4.6 billion. OpenSecrets staff article republished by InDepthNH (Nov 7, 2024)
- California governor 2026: record self-funder Tom Steyer failed to advance: Steyer spent at least $213-216M of his own money and finished third in the June 2 top-two primary; Xavier Becerra (D) and Steve Hilton (R) advanced; Becerra won in November 65.6%-34.4% (98% reporting as of Nov 17). AP via PBS (Oct 8, 2026); Washington Examiner (June 9-10, 2026); Wikipedia infobox
- California Prop 40 (one-time 5% tax on billionaires' wealth), Nov 3, 2026: bigger spender won: Failed, about 52-53% No. Opponents gave $378.4M (Sergey Brin $102M; Eric Schmidt $40.2M; John Doerr $40M via Building a Better California) versus $33.5M raised by supporters - more than 10-to-1. The companion counter-measure Prop 42 passed narrowly (led 51.6%-48.4%); Prop 41 failed. CalMatters (Kristen Hwang, Nov 9, 2026); Ballotpedia News (Oct 26, 2026); Stateside results list; SF Standard (Nov 9, 2026)
- California 2026 was the state's most expensive ballot-measure cycle: $798.9M in contributions across 14 November measures as of Oct 26 (previous record $763.7M in 2020); nationally, campaigns around 164 statewide measures had raised more than $1.2B. Props 40-42 together exceeded $360M. Ballotpedia News (Oct 26, 2026)
- California Prop 39 (voter ID), 2026: slightly better-funded side lost: Supporters raised $39.5M vs $33.3M for opponents (as of Oct 26); the measure failed. Ballotpedia News (Oct 26, 2026); Stateside results list
- California Props 3 and 38 (2026): lopsided funding, outcomes not confirmed: Prop 3 (extend income-tax increase for education): $74.8M+ in support (California Teachers Assn. $53.8M) vs $5,500 against. Prop 38 (research bonds): $71.3M in support from Gary Michelson vs about $9,900 against. Results were not retrieved today. Ballotpedia News (Oct 26, 2026)
- California Prop 50 (Nov 4, 2025 redistricting measure): bigger spender won: Passed 64.42%-35.58%. Supporters raised $124.9M (House Majority PAC $16.5M; Fund for Policy Reform $10M) vs $47.7M for opponents (Charles Munger Jr. $36M; Congressional Leadership Fund $5M) - about $172.7M in all, 94% of all 2025 ballot-measure money nationwide. Ballotpedia News (Feb 11, 2026); Wikipedia results
- Campaign-finance measures on 2026 ballots: Alaska Ballot Measure 1 (Aug 18, 2026), restoring contribution limits, passed with over 70%. Michigan Proposal 2 (Nov 3, 2026), barring campaign contributions from regulated utilities and large state contractors and widening disclosure, passed. California had a measure allowing public financing of campaigns on the Nov 3 ballot (result not listed in sources fetched). Brennan also mentions a related Montana measure; its fate was not confirmed. Stateside 2026 ballot-measure results list; Brennan Center (Oct 13, 2026)
- Ohio governor 2026: self-funder and megadonor-backed candidate lost: Vivek Ramaswamy (R) lent his campaign at least $36M; the allied V-PAC took at least $30M from Jeff Yass plus $5M from Elon Musk; Ramaswamy and allies spent over $120M on ads, more than triple Amy Acton's side. Acton (D) won. Brennan Center (Oct 27, 2026); Fortune (Nov 4, 2026)
- Georgia governor 2026: $100M self-funder won the primary, lost the general: Rick Jackson (R) self-funded over $100M and out-spent Keisha Lance Bottoms (D) about 5-to-1; he beat Trump-endorsed Burt Jones in the June 16 runoff but lost to Bottoms in November. Brennan Center (Oct 27, 2026); AP via PBS (June 17, 2026); Fortune (Nov 4, 2026)
- Texas governor 2026: incumbent with nine-figure war chest lost: Gov. Greg Abbott (R) entered 2026 with $105.7M on hand and received at least $5M from Elon Musk; he lost to Gina Hinojosa (D). Opponent's spending not retrieved. Fortune (Nov 4, 2026); AP via KY3 (Nov 5, 2026)
- Wisconsin governor 2026: megadonor money routed through the state party: Diane Hendricks and Richard and Liz Uihlein gave nearly $60M to the Wisconsin GOP, which passed nearly $35M to Tom Tiffany (R) - 92% of his recent fundraising; David Crowley (D) raised about $12M. Outcome not retrieved today. Brennan Center (Oct 27, 2026)
- Nevada governor 2026: outside money favoring the incumbent: Gov. Joe Lombardo's Better Nevada PAC raised nearly $30M (about a third from the Republican Governors Association); the DGA gave $7M to a PAC for Aaron Ford (D). Outcome not retrieved today. Brennan Center (Oct 27, 2026)
- Wisconsin Supreme Court (April 2025): record outside spender lost: Elon Musk's America PAC spent about $47M (NYT count; AP cites $25M from Musk personally) for the conservative candidate, who lost. New York Times analysis via Philadelphia Inquirer (Nov 2, 2026); AP via PBS (Oct 8, 2026)
- New York City 2025: record super PAC spending failed: Super PACs spent $82.95M across the 2025 city cycle (a record); $28.4M backed Andrew Cuomo in the general vs $4.5M for Zohran Mamdani, who won by 9.4 points. Citizens Union (Dec 2025)
How this page was checked
Four research passes on 2026-11-19 (academic literature; historical benchmarks; 2026 primaries and themes; OpenSecrets, Michigan and 2026 Senate generals). Each item was checked that day against a fetched source: Crossref/OpenAlex/publisher or RePEc records for papers; FEC press releases and PDF tables; OpenSecrets elections-hub pages read in a browser; Brookings Vital Statistics CSVs; Brennan Center analyses; news reports (AP via local outlets, NBC, Bridge Michigan, Roll Call, NOTUS, Fortune, Newsweek and others); Wikipedia as a pointer for results and FEC tables; and the pipeline's own local copies of FEC bulk files (weball26 candidate summary; independent_expenditure_2026) for 2026 candidate and outside-spending figures. Nothing was taken from memory. Subagent passes were spot-checked (Crossref records for Levitt 1994 and Kalla-Broockman 2018; Wikipedia for the Maine and Michigan primaries; UDP, MD-5, IL-7 and Ohio totals re-derived from the FEC file). All text is paraphrased.