Who funds the argument
Most money spent to change what Americans think never touches a campaign. It moves through charities, advocacy groups, unions, trade associations and super PACs, each with different rules about politics and different answers to one question: who gets to know the donors’ names?
The map
The trade is roughly this: the more openly a group may campaign for candidates, the more it must disclose. Charities get tax-deductible gifts and donor privacy but may not back candidates. Super PACs may spend without limit on candidates and must name every donor over $200.
| Kind of group | Gifts tax-deductible | May campaign for candidates | Donors reported to government | Donors public |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 501(c)(3) public charity | Yes | Flatly barred | Yes, to the IRS | No |
| 501(c)(3) private foundation | Yes | Barred, as for every 501(c)(3) | Yes | Yes |
| Donor-advised fund sponsor | Yes | Barred | Yes, at the sponsor level | No |
| 501(c)(4) social welfare organization | No | Allowed, as long as it is not the group's primary activity | To the IRS, amounts but not names | Generally no |
| 501(c)(5) labor union | No | Allowed, as long as it is not the union's primary activity | Union income is mostly member dues | Individual dues payers are not listed |
| 501(c)(6) trade association or business league | No | Allowed, as long as it is not the primary activity | To the IRS, amounts but not names | Generally no |
| 527 political organization (not registered with the FEC) | No | This is its purpose | Yes | Yes |
| Candidate committee (federal) | No | This is the campaign itself | Yes | Yes |
| Party committee (federal) | No | Core function | Yes | Yes, on fec.gov |
| Traditional PAC (corporate or union separate segregated fund, or nonconnected PAC) | No | Core function | Yes | Yes, on fec.gov |
| Super PAC (independent-expenditure-only committee) | No | Its whole purpose is election advocacy, but only independently | Yes | Yes, on fec.gov |
| Hybrid PAC (Carey committee) | No | Both kinds at once, kept in two bank accounts | Yes | Yes, on fec.gov, with the same one-layer-back gap as super PACs when the donor is an LLC or nonprofit |
| LLC or for-profit corporation as donor | No | A corporation may not give treasury money to a federal candidate, party or traditional PAC, but since 2010 it may spend unlimited sums independently | The company's owners are often not on file anywhere public | The super PAC's FEC report shows the company's name and address, not who owns or funded it |
Each cell is the short answer. Open a group below for the full rule and its source.
501(c)(3) public charity
Campaigning for candidates: Flatly barred. The statute says a 501(c)(3) may not take part in any political campaign for or against a candidate (the 'Johnson Amendment', added in the 1954 tax code; the words covering opposition to a candidate were added in 1987). Nonpartisan voter registration, voter guides and candidate forums are allowed; a violation risks loss of exemption and a 10% excise tax on the spending.
Independent spending on elections: Not allowed. An independent expenditure expressly urges a candidate's election or defeat, which is exactly the campaign activity the tax code bars for 501(c)(3)s.
Giving to candidates: No. The tax code bars it, and federal election law separately bars contributions from corporations, including nonprofit corporations.
Giving to super PACs: No. A gift to a super PAC would be campaign intervention under the tax code.
Lobbying: Allowed, within limits. By default lobbying may not be a 'substantial part' of what the charity does; or the charity can elect the 501(h) spending test, which allows 20% of its first $500,000 of program spending and smaller shares above that, capped at $1,000,000 a year (the cap is reached at $17 million of spending). Spending over the limit is taxed at 25%.
Issue advocacy: Unlimited. Research, reports, events and public education on policy questions do not count as lobbying unless they urge action on specific legislation, and do not count as campaigning unless they favor or oppose a candidate.
Donors reported to government: Yes, to the IRS. Schedule B of Form 990 lists the name and address of each contributor of $5,000 or more in the year (for charities that pass the public-support test, only those above the greater of $5,000 or 2% of total contributions). This is required by statute and was not changed by the 2020 rules that relieved other nonprofits.
Donors public: No. The IRS and the charity must withhold contributor names and addresses from public copies of the return; gift amounts stay visible unless they would identify the donor. Federal employees who willfully leak return information commit a felony (up to $5,000 fine and 5 years), and the taxpayer can sue for at least $1,000 per unauthorized disclosure.
What anyone can look up: The annual Form 990: revenue, spending, assets, officer and top-staff pay, lobbying spending (Schedule C) and grants of more than $5,000 to U.S. organizations (Schedule I). Returns are free on the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search and ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer.
Regulator: IRS
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) and 501(h); 4911 (lobbying limits); 4955 (tax on political spending); 6033(b)(5) (donor reporting); 6104(b) and (d)(3)(A) (donor names withheld from the public); 6103, 7213, 7431 (confidentiality and penalties).
Examples: Center for American Progress; American Civil Liberties Union Foundation; Heritage Foundation; American Enterprise Institute; Cato Institute (libertarian)
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 501 (text and amendment notes); IRS: restriction of political campaign intervention by 501(c)(3) organizations; IRS: lobbying; IRS: measuring lobbying activity, expenditure test; IRS: measuring lobbying, substantial part test; 26 U.S.C. 4911; 26 U.S.C. 4955; 26 U.S.C. 6033; 26 U.S.C. 6104; 26 U.S.C. 6103; 26 U.S.C. 7213; 26 U.S.C. 7431; IRS Schedule B (Form 990), Rev. December 2024; IRS: contributors' identities not subject to disclosure; IRS Instructions for Form 990; IRS Instructions for Schedule I (Form 990); CRS RL33377, Tax-Exempt Organizations Under IRC 501(c): Political Activity Restrictions (updated Jan. 3, 2025); National Religious Broadcasters v. Bessent, No. 6:24-cv-00311 (E.D. Tex. Mar. 31, 2026), opinion and order; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Heritage Foundation; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Center for American Progress; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Cato Institute; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: American Enterprise Institute; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: ACLU Foundation
501(c)(3) private foundation
Campaigning for candidates: Barred, as for every 501(c)(3). On top of that, any spending to influence a specific election or to run a voter registration drive is a 'taxable expenditure' hit with a 20% tax on the foundation and 5% on managers who knowingly approve it. The one exception lets foundations fund nonpartisan 501(c)(3) voter-registration groups that work in at least 5 states, are not confined to one election period, and get no more than 25% of support from any one exempt organization.
Independent spending on elections: Not allowed.
Giving to candidates: No.
Giving to super PACs: No.
Lobbying: Effectively barred. Money spent to influence legislation is a taxable expenditure (20% tax, rising to 100% if not corrected), and private foundations cannot elect the 501(h) spending test. Exceptions cover nonpartisan analysis, study and research, technical advice a legislative body requests in writing, and matters affecting the foundation's own existence or tax status.
Issue advocacy: Allowed. A foundation may fund and publish nonpartisan research and public education on policy. Grants to anything other than public charities require formal 'expenditure responsibility' oversight and must be for charitable purposes.
Donors reported to government: Yes. A foundation attaches Schedule B to Form 990-PF listing anyone who gave $5,000 or more in money or property during the year.
Donors public: Yes. The law that shields donor names for other nonprofits expressly excepts private foundations, so the names and addresses of a foundation's contributors are open to the public.
What anyone can look up: Form 990-PF shows contributors of $5,000 or more, grants paid during the year and grants approved for future payment (Part XIV), investments, and officer and trustee pay. For a foundation funded by one family or company, that means both ends of the money trail are public.
Regulator: IRS
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) and 509(a); 4941 (self-dealing); 4945 (taxable expenditures: lobbying, electioneering, voter drives), including 4945(f); 6104(b) and (d)(3)(A).
Examples: Foundation to Promote Open Society (the main grantmaking foundation in the Open Society Foundations network); Ford Foundation; Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation; Sarah Scaife Foundation; Charles Koch Foundation
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 4945; 26 U.S.C. 4941; 26 U.S.C. 6104; IRS: private foundation excise taxes; IRS Instructions for Form 990-PF; IRS: contributors' identities not subject to disclosure (exception for private foundations); IRS: measuring lobbying activity, expenditure test (not available to private foundations); ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Foundation to Promote Open Society; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Open Society Institute; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Ford Foundation; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Sarah Scaife Foundation; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Charles Koch Foundation
Donor-advised fund sponsor
Campaigning for candidates: Barred. The sponsor is a 501(c)(3) public charity, so the campaign ban applies to it and to every account it holds.
Independent spending on elections: Not allowed.
Giving to candidates: No.
Giving to super PACs: No.
Lobbying: The sponsor is under the same lobbying limits as any public charity. Grants out of a donor-advised account must be for charitable purposes; a grant to an individual, or to a non-charity without formal oversight, triggers a 20% tax on the sponsor and 5% on a manager who knowingly approves it.
Issue advocacy: Allowed through grants. Donors commonly recommend grants from their accounts to think tanks, legal groups and other 501(c)(3)s that do policy education.
Donors reported to government: Yes, at the sponsor level. The sponsor reports its $5,000-plus contributors to the IRS on Schedule B like any public charity. Once money is given, the sponsor legally owns it; the donor keeps only the right to advise on grants and investments.
Donors public: No. Donor names are withheld as for any public charity, and the sponsor's public filings do not tie any grant to the account or person who recommended it. A grant recipient's records show the sponsor as the giver.
What anyone can look up: The sponsor's Form 990: Schedule I lists each U.S. organization that received more than $5,000 and how much, and Schedule D gives only totals for all donor-advised accounts combined (number of funds, money in, grants out, year-end value).
Regulator: IRS
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 4966 (definitions and tax on improper distributions); 4967 (125% tax on a donor or advisor who gets more than an incidental benefit from a grant); 501(c)(3); 6104.
Examples: Tides Foundation; DonorsTrust
Sources: IRS: donor-advised funds; 26 U.S.C. 4966; 26 U.S.C. 4967; IRS Instructions for Schedule I (Form 990); IRS Instructions for Schedule D (Form 990), Part I; 26 U.S.C. 6104; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Tides Foundation; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: DonorsTrust; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: National Christian Charitable Foundation; DonorsTrust (self-description); Tides (self-description); Fidelity Charitable (self-description); National Christian Foundation (self-description)
501(c)(5) labor union
Campaigning for candidates: Allowed, as long as it is not the union's primary activity. Money given directly to federal candidates cannot come from dues or the union treasury; it must come from a separate PAC funded by voluntary contributions.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, from treasury funds since Citizens United (2010), with the same FEC reporting as any other spender (Form 5 above $250 a year).
Giving to candidates: Not from the treasury. Only the union's separate segregated fund (its PAC) may contribute, up to $5,000 per election if it qualifies as a multicandidate PAC.
Giving to super PACs: Yes, in unlimited amounts from treasury funds.
Lobbying: Unlimited. The tax code puts no lobbying cap on 501(c)(5) organizations.
Issue advocacy: Unlimited.
Donors reported to government: Union income is mostly member dues. On the IRS Schedule B, large payers are reported by amount without names since 2020. On Labor Department LM-2 reports, any single payer of $5,000 or more in categories such as 'other receipts' is itemized by name.
Donors public: Individual dues payers are not listed. But LM reports are public by law, so the itemized $5,000-plus receipts and every itemized payment out are open to anyone.
What anyone can look up: More than for any other nonprofit type. Besides Form 990, unions covered by federal labor law file annual LM reports showing pay for each officer and for employees paid over $10,000, and every payee that received $5,000 or more, sorted by purpose including political activities and lobbying. Reports are searchable in the Labor Department's Online Public Disclosure Room.
Regulator: IRS, Department of Labor (Office of Labor-Management Standards), and FEC for federal election activity
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(5); Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act of 1959, sections 201(b) and 205 (29 U.S.C. 431, 435); 29 CFR 403.4; 52 U.S.C. 30118 (no treasury contributions; PAC allowed); 26 U.S.C. 527(f) and 6033(e).
Examples: Service Employees International Union (SEIU); National Education Association (NEA); AFL-CIO; AFSCME; American Farm Bureau Federation (a 501(c)(5) agricultural organization, not a union; no right-leaning union example was confirmed today)
Sources: DOL OLMS: Form LM-2 and instructions (revised 06/2026); DOL final rule, Labor Organization Annual Financial Reports, 91 FR 32556 (June 1, 2026); DOL correction, 91 FR 35397 (June 11, 2026); 29 CFR 403.4 (eCFR, text before the July 1, 2026 amendment); 29 U.S.C. 431 (annual financial report; officer and employee pay); 29 U.S.C. 435 (reports are public information); DOL OLMS: text of the LMRDA; DOL OLMS Online Public Disclosure Room; IRS: labor organizations; CRS RL33377 (updated Jan. 3, 2025); 52 U.S.C. 30118; 11 CFR 114.10 (eCFR); T.D. 9898, 85 FR 31959 (May 28, 2020); IRS Publication 526 (union payments are not charitable contributions); FEC: SEIU COPE committee profile; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: SEIU; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: NEA; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: AFL-CIO; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: AFSCME; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: American Farm Bureau Federation
501(c)(6) trade association or business league
Campaigning for candidates: Allowed, as long as it is not the primary activity. The IRS says a business league is not disqualified merely because it engages in some political activity.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, since Citizens United (2010), with FEC reporting of the spending.
Giving to candidates: Not from its treasury if incorporated. It may sponsor a PAC funded by voluntary contributions, which can give up to $5,000 per election as a multicandidate PAC.
Giving to super PACs: Yes, in unlimited amounts.
Lobbying: Unlimited when germane to its purpose. Members may deduct dues as a business expense except for the share spent on lobbying and politics; the association must tell members that share or pay a 'proxy tax' on it at the top corporate rate.
Issue advocacy: Unlimited.
Donors reported to government: To the IRS, amounts but not names: since the 2020 rules, Schedule B for a 501(c)(6) lists each $5,000-plus payment without the payer's name or address, and the association must keep the names available to the IRS. FEC rules can require naming donors who gave for specific election ads.
Donors public: Generally no. Member companies and their dues are not public unless the association or the member chooses to disclose them.
What anyone can look up: Form 990 (revenue, spending, executive pay, grants, lobbying and political totals) and FEC reports of any federal election spending or super PAC gifts.
Regulator: both (IRS for tax status; FEC for federal election spending)
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(6); 162(e) (no deduction for lobbying and political spending); 6033(e) (dues notice or proxy tax); 527(f); 52 U.S.C. 30118 and 30104.
Examples: American Association for Justice (trial lawyers' association; the 'left' label is a conventional description, not verified today); U.S. Chamber of Commerce; National Federation of Independent Business; American Petroleum Institute
Sources: IRS: business leagues; IRS: proxy tax; IRS: nondeductible lobbying and political expenditures; 26 U.S.C. 6033 (subsection (e)); 26 U.S.C. 162 (subsection (e)); CRS RL33377 (updated Jan. 3, 2025); T.D. 9898, 85 FR 31959 (May 28, 2020); FEC: who can and can't contribute; 11 CFR 114.10 (eCFR); ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer API: PhRMA; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer search: American Association for Justice; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer search: National Federation of Independent Business; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer search: American Petroleum Institute; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer search: National Association of Realtors
527 political organization (not registered with the FEC)
Campaigning for candidates: This is its purpose. The tax code defines a 527 as a group organized primarily to raise and spend money to influence the selection or election of people to federal, state or local office. The best-known 527s outside the FEC, such as the governors associations, are organized around state races.
Independent spending on elections: In state races, as state law allows. A group that raises or spends more than $1,000 a year to influence federal elections generally must register with the FEC as a political committee instead.
Giving to candidates: To state and local candidates as state law allows. Not to federal candidates unless it registers a federal committee and uses money that meets federal limits and source rules.
Giving to super PACs: Generally yes; the super PAC reports the gift to the FEC under the 527's name.
Lobbying: Not what the form is for. A 527's tax exemption covers only money used for its electoral purpose.
Issue advocacy: Allowed, typically election-related messaging. Money spent outside the electoral purpose does not get the 527 tax treatment.
Donors reported to government: Yes. A 527 must notify the IRS electronically on Form 8871 within 24 hours of forming, then file periodic Form 8872 reports naming each contributor of $200 or more in a calendar year (with address, occupation and employer) and each recipient of $500 or more in spending.
Donors public: Yes. The law that shields donor names for other nonprofits expressly excepts 527s, and the IRS posts Forms 8871 and 8872 in a searchable public database.
What anyone can look up: Form 8871 (who runs it and its purpose), Form 8872 (donors of $200-plus and payees of $500-plus), and Form 990 for larger groups, all through the IRS Political Organization Filing and Disclosure site.
Regulator: IRS (plus state election agencies; the FEC only if it becomes a federal political committee)
Key law: 26 U.S.C. 527, especially 527(i) (notice) and 527(j) (donor and spending reports), both added by Pub. L. 106-230 (July 1, 2000) and amended by Pub. L. 107-276 (2002); 6104 (public disclosure); 52 U.S.C. 30101(4) ($1,000 federal political committee threshold).
Examples: Democratic Governors Association; Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee; Democratic Attorneys General Association; Republican Governors Association; Republican State Leadership Committee; Republican Attorneys General Association
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 527; 26 U.S.C. 6104; IRS: political organizations filing requirements; IRS: Political Organization Filing and Disclosure; IRS Political Organization Disclosure search (Form 8871 filers confirmed here); IRS: contributors' identities not subject to disclosure (exception for 527s); 52 U.S.C. 30101; FEC: types of nonconnected PACs (registration threshold)
Candidate committee (federal)
Campaigning for candidates: This is the campaign itself: the committee a candidate authorizes to raise and spend money for his or her own election. Anyone who raises or spends more than $5,000 running for federal office must register one with the FEC.
Independent spending on elections: Not applicable. It spends directly on the candidate's own race.
Giving to candidates: Yes, modestly: up to $2,000 per election to another federal candidate's committee, and unlimited transfers to party committees.
Giving to super PACs: Not covered by the sources checked today. The FEC limits chart shows a candidate committee may give up to $5,000 a year to a traditional PAC.
Lobbying: Not applicable.
Issue advocacy: Not applicable; its spending is campaign spending.
Donors reported to government: Yes. The committee reports every receipt to the FEC and must itemize each contributor whose gifts total more than $200 in the election cycle, with name, address, occupation, employer, date and amount.
Donors public: Yes. Itemized contributors are searchable by name on fec.gov. Donors who give $200 or less in total are counted in a lump sum, unless they gave through a conduit such as ActBlue or WinRed, which itemizes every contribution.
What anyone can look up: Regular FEC reports showing itemized donors, all PAC and party contributions, loans, debts and each payment to vendors.
Regulator: FEC
Key law: Federal Election Campaign Act, 52 U.S.C. 30101 et seq.; 30116 (limits); 30118 (no corporate or union treasury money); 30122 (no gifts in another's name); 30104(b) (itemize over $200). 2025-2026 limits: $3,500 per election from an individual or non-multicandidate PAC; $5,000 per election from a multicandidate PAC or a party committee.
Examples: Jeffries for Congress (Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y.); Mike Johnson for Louisiana (Rep. Mike Johnson, R-La.)
Sources: FEC: contribution limits for 2025-2026; FEC: registering as a candidate; FEC: who can and can't contribute; FEC: reporting individual contributions (itemization over $200); 52 U.S.C. 30104; 52 U.S.C. 30118; 52 U.S.C. 30122; 11 CFR 110.6 (earmarked contributions through conduits; eCFR); IRS Publication 526 (political contributions are not deductible); FEC committee profile: Jeffries for Congress; FEC committee profile: Mike Johnson for Louisiana; FEC: all commissioners (two seats filled as of Nov. 19, 2026)
Party committee (federal)
Campaigning for candidates: Core function: electing the party's candidates. National party committees may raise and spend only money that meets federal limits and source rules (the 'soft money' ban).
Independent spending on elections: Yes, unlimited. Separately, on June 30, 2026 the Supreme Court held in NRSC v. FEC that the federal caps on spending a party coordinates with its own candidates violate the First Amendment.
Giving to candidates: Yes: $5,000 per election to a candidate, and a national committee and its Senate campaign committee may give a Senate candidate up to $62,000 combined per campaign. Coordinated spending on top of that is no longer capped after NRSC v. FEC.
Giving to super PACs: Not covered by the sources checked today.
Lobbying: Not applicable.
Issue advocacy: Allowed, paid for with federally regulated money.
Donors reported to government: Yes. Party committees report to the FEC and itemize every contributor who gives more than $200 in a calendar year.
Donors public: Yes, on fec.gov.
What anyone can look up: Monthly or quarterly FEC reports: itemized donors, transfers among party committees, contributions to candidates, independent and coordinated spending, and payments to vendors.
Regulator: FEC (state parties also answer to state election agencies)
Key law: 52 U.S.C. 30116 (limits, including 30116(d) on coordinated party spending, held unconstitutional in 2026); 30125 (soft-money ban); 30104 (reporting). 2025-2026 limits on gifts to a national party committee: $44,300 a year from an individual, plus $132,900 a year to each of three special accounts (convention, recounts and legal, headquarters); $15,000 a year from a multicandidate PAC; $10,000 a year combined from an individual to state and local party committees.
Examples: Democratic National Committee (DNC); DSCC; DCCC; Republican National Committee (RNC); NRSC; NRCC
Sources: FEC: contribution limits for 2025-2026; 52 U.S.C. 30125; 52 U.S.C. 30116; FEC: NRSC et al. v. FEC et al. (No. 24-621); Supreme Court slip opinions, October Term 2025 (No. 24-621 decided June 30, 2026); FEC: coordinated party expenditures (page not yet revised); FEC: registering as a political party; 52 U.S.C. 30104; FEC committee profile: DNC; FEC committee profile: RNC; FEC committee profile: DSCC; FEC committee profile: NRSC; FEC committee profile: DCCC; FEC committee profile: NRCC
Traditional PAC (corporate or union separate segregated fund, or nonconnected PAC)
Campaigning for candidates: Core function: pooling limited contributions and giving them to candidates. A corporation, union or trade association may pay its PAC's overhead from its treasury, but the money the PAC gives away must come from voluntary contributions, never from dues or company funds.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, unlimited in amount, but paid only from the limited contributions it has raised.
Giving to candidates: Yes: $5,000 per election if it is a multicandidate PAC (registered at least 6 months, more than 50 contributors, and gifts to at least 5 federal candidates); otherwise $3,500 per election in 2025-2026. It may also give $15,000 a year to a national party committee.
Giving to super PACs: Yes; the FEC lists other PACs among the sources super PACs may accept money from.
Lobbying: Not applicable; the sponsoring company, union or association lobbies separately.
Issue advocacy: Allowed, though not the usual use.
Donors reported to government: Yes. An individual may give a PAC up to $5,000 a year, and the PAC must itemize to the FEC every contributor who gives more than $200 in a calendar year.
Donors public: Yes, on fec.gov.
What anyone can look up: FEC reports listing itemized donors (with employer and occupation), every contribution to a candidate or party, and the sponsoring organization's name.
Regulator: FEC
Key law: 52 U.S.C. 30101(4) (a group becomes a political committee above $1,000 a year); 30116(a) (limits); 30118(b) (separate segregated funds); 11 CFR 100.5(e)(3) (multicandidate definition); 30104 (reporting).
Examples: SEIU COPE (union PAC); American Federation of Teachers COPE (union PAC); EMILY's List; End Citizens United; NRA Political Victory Fund; KochPAC (Koch, Inc. corporate PAC); Club for Growth PAC
Sources: FEC: contribution limits for 2025-2026; FEC: political action committees (definitions); FEC: understanding the SSF and its connected organization; FEC: types of nonconnected PACs; FEC: limits on contributions made by nonconnected PACs; 11 CFR 100.5 (eCFR); 52 U.S.C. 30118; 52 U.S.C. 30116; 52 U.S.C. 30101; 52 U.S.C. 30104; FEC: making independent expenditures; FEC committee profile: SEIU COPE; FEC committee profile: AFT COPE; FEC committee profile: EMILY's List; FEC committee profile: End Citizens United; FEC committee profile: NRA Political Victory Fund; FEC committee profile: KochPAC; FEC committee profile: Club for Growth PAC; FEC committee profile: National Association of Realtors PAC; FEC committee profile: Planned Parenthood Action Fund PAC
Super PAC (independent-expenditure-only committee)
Campaigning for candidates: Its whole purpose is election advocacy, but only independently. It may not give money to candidates or parties and may not coordinate its spending with them.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, unlimited. That is what it exists to do, and each expenditure is reported to the FEC with the candidate supported or opposed.
Giving to candidates: No. A super PAC makes no contributions to federal candidates or party committees, in cash, in kind or through coordinated ads.
Giving to super PACs: Yes; super PACs may take unlimited sums from other political committees.
Lobbying: Not applicable.
Issue advocacy: Allowed.
Donors reported to government: Yes. It is a registered political committee and must itemize to the FEC every donor who gives more than $200 in a year. There is no limit on the size of a gift, and corporations and unions may give.
Donors public: Yes, on fec.gov. The gap is one layer back: when the donor is an LLC or a nonprofit such as a 501(c)(4), the report shows that entity's name, not the people who funded it.
What anyone can look up: FEC reports with every itemized donor and amount, and every independent expenditure with its date, payee, amount and target.
Regulator: FEC
Key law: Citizens United v. FEC (Supreme Court, Jan. 21, 2010); SpeechNow.org v. FEC (D.C. Circuit, en banc, Mar. 26, 2010); FEC Advisory Opinions 2010-09 (Club for Growth) and 2010-11 (Commonsense Ten), both issued July 22, 2010; 52 U.S.C. 30104 (reporting); 30122 (no gifts in another's name).
Examples: SMP (Senate Majority PAC); LCV Victory Fund; Women Vote!; Unite the Country; SLF PAC (Senate Leadership Fund); Make America Great Again Inc. (MAGA Inc.); Club for Growth Action
Sources: FEC: SpeechNow.org v. FEC; FEC: Citizens United v. FEC; FEC Advisory Opinion 2010-09 (Club for Growth); FEC Advisory Opinion 2010-11 (Commonsense Ten); FEC: registering as a super PAC; FEC: political action committees (definitions); 52 U.S.C. 30104; 52 U.S.C. 30122; FEC committee profile: SMP; FEC committee profile: SLF PAC; FEC committee profile: Make America Great Again Inc.; FEC committee profile: Club for Growth Action; FEC committee profile: LCV Victory Fund; FEC committee profile: Women Vote!; FEC committee profile: Unite the Country; FEC committee profile: Fairshake; FEC committee profile: FF PAC (registered as a hybrid PAC)
Hybrid PAC (Carey committee)
Campaigning for candidates: Both kinds at once, kept in two bank accounts. One account takes limited contributions and can give to candidates like a traditional PAC; the other (the 'non-contribution account') takes unlimited money, including from corporations and unions, for independent spending.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, unlimited, from the non-contribution account.
Giving to candidates: Yes, but only from the limited account, under the ordinary PAC limits ($5,000 per election if multicandidate). Money in the unlimited account can never be given to a candidate.
Giving to super PACs: Not specifically covered by the sources checked today; nothing in the FEC's description of hybrid PACs bars it.
Lobbying: Not applicable.
Issue advocacy: Allowed; the non-contribution account can also pay for other ads that mention federal candidates and for generic voter drives.
Donors reported to government: Yes. Both accounts are reported to the FEC, with every donor of more than $200 in a year itemized.
Donors public: Yes, on fec.gov, with the same one-layer-back gap as super PACs when the donor is an LLC or nonprofit.
What anyone can look up: FEC reports covering both accounts: itemized donors, contributions to candidates, and independent expenditures.
Regulator: FEC
Key law: Carey v. FEC (D.D.C. 2011): preliminary injunction June 14, 2011; stipulated order and consent judgment Aug. 19, 2011. FEC statement of Oct. 6, 2011 extending the same treatment to any nonconnected committee that keeps the accounts separate and splits overhead in proportion to activity.
Examples: FF PAC (Future Forward); HMP (House Majority PAC); MoveOn.org Political Action; Justice Democrats PAC; ActBlue (conduit); CLF (Congressional Leadership Fund); Senate Conservatives Fund; Great America PAC; AFP Action; WinRed (conduit)
Sources: FEC: Carey v. FEC; FEC statement on Carey v. FEC (Oct. 6, 2011); FEC: political action committees (definitions); FEC: limits on contributions made by nonconnected PACs; 11 CFR 110.6 (earmarked contributions through conduits; eCFR); FEC committee profile: FF PAC; FEC committee profile: HMP; FEC committee profile: MoveOn.org Political Action; FEC committee profile: Justice Democrats PAC; FEC committee profile: ActBlue; FEC committee profile: CLF; FEC committee profile: Senate Conservatives Fund; FEC committee profile: Great America PAC; FEC committee profile: AFP Action; FEC committee profile: WinRed; FEC committee profile: Priorities USA Action; FEC committee profile: AB PAC
LLC or for-profit corporation as donor
Campaigning for candidates: A corporation may not give treasury money to a federal candidate, party or traditional PAC, but since 2010 it may spend unlimited sums independently. An LLC is treated like whatever it is for tax purposes: one taxed as a corporation (or publicly traded) is barred like a corporation, while one taxed as a partnership or owned by a single person may give, with the gift counted against the individual owners' own limits.
Independent spending on elections: Yes, directly, with a Form 5 report to the FEC once they pass $250 in a year; or indirectly by funding a super PAC.
Giving to candidates: Corporation: no. LLC taxed as a partnership or single-member LLC: yes, up to the individual limit ($3,500 per election in 2025-2026), and the LLC must tell the campaign which owners to attribute it to. No share may be attributed to a corporate or foreign owner.
Giving to super PACs: Yes, in unlimited amounts.
Lobbying: Unlimited, but not tax-deductible: the tax code denies a business deduction for lobbying and campaign spending.
Issue advocacy: Unlimited.
Donors reported to government: The company's owners are often not on file anywhere public. State rules vary: Delaware's formation certificate asks only for the LLC's name and registered agent, while Arizona requires the names of members or managers. The federal ownership registry created by the Corporate Transparency Act no longer covers U.S.-formed companies: FinCEN exempted them by interim rule on March 26, 2025 and made that final on August 14, 2026.
Donors public: The super PAC's FEC report shows the company's name and address, not who owns or funded it. Routing a gift through a company to hide its true source can violate the ban on contributions in another's name.
What anyone can look up: The company's name, address, date and amount in the recipient committee's FEC report, plus whatever the state business registry shows.
Regulator: FEC for election spending; state secretaries of state for company records; FinCEN (Treasury) for the federal ownership registry
Key law: 52 U.S.C. 30118 (no corporate treasury contributions); 11 CFR 110.1(g) (LLC attribution); 11 CFR 114.10 (corporate independent spending and super PAC gifts); 52 U.S.C. 30122 (no contributions in the name of another); 26 U.S.C. 162(e); FinCEN rules at 90 FR 13688 and 91 FR 52508.
Examples: DE First Holdings (named with the super PAC Coalition for Progress in FEC matter MUR 7014, a contribution-in-the-name-of-another complaint; the Commission split 2-2 on the main allegations and closed the file. News coverage at the time described Coalition for Progress as backing a Democratic mayor; that alignment was NOT confirmed from a page fetched today); W Spann LLC (named with the super PAC Restore Our Future in FEC complaint MUR 6485 alleging a contribution in another's name; the Commission deadlocked 3-3); Government Integrity, LLC (named with the American Conservative Union and Now or Never PAC in FEC matter MUR 6920; the Commission accepted a settlement dated Oct. 23, 2017)
Sources: 52 U.S.C. 30118; 52 U.S.C. 30122; 11 CFR 110.1 (eCFR; paragraph (g)); 11 CFR 114.10 (eCFR); FEC: who can and can't contribute (LLCs and corporations); FEC: partnership and LLC contributions; FEC: making independent expenditures; 26 U.S.C. 162 (subsection (e)); FinCEN interim final rule, 90 FR 13688 (Mar. 26, 2025); FinCEN final rule, 91 FR 52508 (Aug. 14, 2026); Delaware Code, title 6, section 18-201; Arizona Revised Statutes 29-3201; FEC enforcement: MUR 6485 (W Spann LLC); FEC enforcement: MUR 6920 (American Conservative Union, Government Integrity, LLC); FEC enforcement: MUR 7690 (PacMar Technologies LLC and others); FEC enforcement: MUR 7904 (Wyss, Sixteen Thirty Fund and others); FEC MUR 7014 (DE First Holdings; Coalition for Progress)
What is knowable
Every one of these groups files a public tax return or FEC report showing what it raised and spent. What differs is whether the donors’ names are on it.
Charitable giving, 2025
$617.20B
Americans gave an estimated $617.20 billion to U.S. charities in 2025, the first year above $600 billion. givingusa.org
501(c)(3) charities
1,596,231
The IRS recognized 1,596,231 organizations under section 501(c)(3) in fiscal 2025. irs.gov
501(c)(4) groups
69,617
The IRS recognized 69,617 section 501(c)(4) social welfare organizations in fiscal 2025. irs.gov
From the top 100 donors
67.33%
The top 100 donors supplied 67% of all itemized money given to super PACs in the 2024 cycle. opensecrets.org
Dark money, 2024 (broad measure)
>$1.9B
Dark money in the 2024 federal elections reached a record of more than $1.9 billion, by the Brennan Center's broad measure. brennancenter.org
“Dark money” reported to the FEC, by the spender’s leaning
Election spending by groups that do not disclose donors. Conservative groups dominated through 2016; liberal groups have had the largest share in every cycle since 2018. This narrow measure counts only spending the groups themselves report to the FEC; broader estimates that include their gifts to super PACs are several times larger.
- Conservative
- Liberal
- Other or unclear
Source: OpenSecrets, outside spending by group (read from archived copies).
Large funders and networks on the left
| Sixteen Thirty Fund (501(c)(4)) $282.2 million revenue / $310.8 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| New Venture Fund (501(c)(3)) $662.4 million revenue / $723.0 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Hopewell Fund (501(c)(3)) $208.0 million revenue / $197.1 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Windward Fund (501(c)(3)) $308.2 million revenue / $251.3 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| North Fund (501(c)(4)) $45.0 million revenue / $53.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Five former Arabella-managed funds, combined $1.51 billion revenue / $1.54 billion expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Tides Foundation (501(c)(3)) $368.0 million revenue / $468.4 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Tides Center (501(c)(3)) $265.4 million revenue / $285.1 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Beyond Impact (formerly Tides Advocacy) (501(c)(4)) $92.6 million revenue / $93.2 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Foundation to Promote Open Society (Open Society Foundations, George Soros) (501(c)(3) private foundation (Form 990-PF)) $935.0 million revenue / $460.8 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Open Society Institute (501(c)(3) private foundation (Form 990-PF)) $396.5 million revenue / $295.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Open Society Policy Center (501(c)(4)) $157.2 million revenue / $178.7 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Berger Action Fund (Hansjörg Wyss) (501(c)(4)) $206.5 million revenue / $58.2 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
| Majority Forward (Senate Democratic-aligned) (501(c)(4)) $119.6 million revenue / $209.7 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
| Future Forward USA Action (501(c)(4)) $615.3 million revenue / $601.0 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| League of Conservation Voters (501(c)(4)) $159.3 million revenue / $146.6 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Ford Foundation (501(c)(3) private foundation (Form 990-PF)) $1.15 billion revenue / $1.04 billion expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
Large funders and networks on the right
| Americans for Prosperity (501(c)(4)) $223.7 million revenue / $201.4 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Americans for Prosperity Foundation (501(c)(3)) $4.4 million revenue / $6.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Stand Together Chamber of Commerce (formerly Freedom Partners) (501(c)(6)) $432.6 million revenue / $364.8 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Stand Together Trust (501(c)(3)) $172.6 million revenue / $158.7 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Stand Together Fellowships (501(c)(3)) $8.3 million revenue / $3.0 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Charles Koch Foundation (501(c)(3) private foundation (Form 990-PF)) $0.2 million revenue / $67.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| DonorsTrust (501(c)(3) donor-advised fund sponsor) $294.4 million revenue / $291.5 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Donors Capital Fund (501(c)(3)) $7.4 million revenue / $6.1 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Marble Freedom Trust, a 501(c)(4) chaired by Leonard Leo, $1,603,791,362 in contributions (FY ending April 2021) (2021) · projects.propublica.org |
| Marble Freedom Trust (501(c)(4) trust) $77.3 million revenue / $223.6 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
| The 85 Fund (Leonard Leo network) (501(c)(3)) $168.5 million revenue / $169.7 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| The Concord Fund (Leonard Leo network) (501(c)(4)) $26.5 million revenue / $27.6 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
| Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation (501(c)(3) private foundation (Form 990-PF)) $61.0 million revenue / $68.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Bradley Impact Fund (501(c)(3) donor-advised fund sponsor) $79.5 million revenue / $51.9 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| One Nation (Senate Republican-aligned) (501(c)(4)) $106.8 million revenue / $162.5 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| American Action Network (House Republican-aligned) (501(c)(4)) $57.0 million revenue / $74.2 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
| Heritage Foundation (501(c)(3)) $133.9 million revenue / $142.2 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Heritage Action for America (501(c)(4)) $15.5 million revenue / $14.8 million expenses (2024) · projects.propublica.org |
| Turning Point USA (501(c)(3)) $115.5 million revenue / $103.9 million expenses (2025) · projects.propublica.org |
Revenue and expenses as reported on each organization’s latest public tax return. These are whole budgets, most of which pay for research, grants, organizing and lobbying, not election ads. The lists are examples, not rankings, and the two columns are not totals to compare.
The fight over donor privacy
- Cuts toward privacy
- Cuts toward disclosure
- Background or mixed
1776–1841: unsigned pamphlets, and donors who signed their names
The case for independence and the case for the Constitution were both made under pen names. The Tappan brothers, New York merchants who bankrolled the abolition movement, are the other half of the story: they gave in the open, and what was done to them is the standing example of what known backers of an unpopular cause can face. Several famous details of their story, including the size of the bounties, rest on rumor; the entries say which.
- 1776Event
Common Sense appears in Philadelphia with no author's name
January 10, 1776
Thomas Paine's pamphlet arguing for independence was published in Philadelphia in January 1776 (reference works date it to January 10) by the printer Robert Bell. Paine's name was not on it: cataloged 1776 Bell title pages identify the author only as an Englishman. It became one of the most widely circulated tracts of the Revolution. The Supreme Court later pointed to this kind of unsigned Revolutionary-era pamphleteering when it struck down bans on anonymous leaflets.
The rule: Background: the leading pro-independence pamphlet circulated without its author's name.
Sources: Encyclopedia.com (Gale, Americans at War), 'Common Sense' - gives publication date January 10, 1776; ESTC-derived bibliographic record W32285 (Grub Street Project): Bell, Philadelphia, 1776 title page transcription; ESTC-derived bibliographic record W32284 (Bell, 1776); Talley v. California, 362 U.S. 60, 64-65 (1960) (opinion text, Cornell LII). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1787Event
The ratification debate is fought under pen names: Publius, Brutus, Cato, Federal Farmer, Centinel
Between October 1787 and May 1788, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay published 85 essays urging New Yorkers to ratify the Constitution, all signed Publius and printed mainly in two New York newspapers. Their opponents wrote under pen names too, including Cato, Centinel, the Federal Farmer and Brutus. According to the Library of Congress, an 1818 edition revised by Madison was the first to label each essay with its author's name. The Supreme Court relied on this history in Talley v. California (1960) and again in McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission (1995), where Justice Thomas's concurrence surveyed Founding-era anonymous writing at length.
The rule: Background: both sides of the ratification debate wrote pseudonymously; the Supreme Court has twice cited that practice as evidence that anonymous political writing is part of the American tradition.
Sources: Library of Congress research guide, Federalist Papers: Primary Documents in American History (full text page); Yale Avalon Project, Federalist No. 1 (headed for the Independent Journal; signed Publius); McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Comm'n, 514 U.S. 334 (1995), esp. n.6 and Thomas, J., concurring in judgment (opinion text, Cornell LII); Talley v. California, 362 U.S. 60, 64-65 (1960) (opinion text, Cornell LII). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1833Event
American Anti-Slavery Society founded in Philadelphia; Arthur Tappan chosen president
December 4, 1833
A national convention of abolitionists met in Philadelphia beginning December 4, 1833, and organized the American Anti-Slavery Society, with William Lloyd Garrison among its leading figures. Arthur Tappan, already the movement's best-known financial backer, was chosen its first president and held the office until 1840. His name therefore sat at the top of the organization whose pamphlets were about to flood the South.
The rule: Background: the principal donor was also the public face of the organization.
Sources: Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive; Oberlin College Library, Oberlin Sanctuary Project, 'The Lane Rebels' (Tappan president from founding until 1840); Temple University Libraries exhibit, 'American Anti-Slavery Society' (founded 1833 in Philadelphia). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1834Event
New York anti-abolition riots: mob sacks Lewis Tappan's house
July 9, 1834
Several days of rioting against abolitionists and Black New Yorkers began around July 7, 1834, stirred up in part by hostile newspaper editors. On the evening of Wednesday, July 9, a crowd broke into Lewis Tappan's house on Rose Street while the family was away, smashed windows and furnishings, threw the furniture into the street and lit a bonfire with the bedding. Over the next two days rioters stoned Arthur Tappan's Pearl Street store - which clerks defended with firearms on the mayor's advice - and attacked churches and the home of the Rev. Samuel Cox. The mayor swore in volunteer constables and called out militia; the riots were suppressed by about July 15.
The rule: Background: mob violence directed at the movement's known financial backers.
Sources: Museum of the City of New York, 'The Abolitionist Riots of 1834'; Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1835Event
The 1835 postal campaign and the Charleston post office raid
July 29, 1835
In the summer of 1835 the American Anti-Slavery Society, funded largely by the Tappans, began mailing antislavery papers and tracts unsolicited to ministers, officials and other prominent Southerners. The Society's own annual report counted 1,095,800 printed pieces for the year ending May 1836, on receipts of about $25,900. When a steamer brought sacks of the material to Charleston on July 29, 1835, postmaster Alfred Huger set them aside; that night a vigilante group calling itself the Lynch Men broke into the post office and carried them off. The next evening the mail was burned before a crowd of roughly two to three thousand, along with effigies of abolitionist leaders - Arthur Tappan, William Lloyd Garrison and the Rev. Samuel Cox, according to Lewis Tappan's later account.
The rule: Background: a lawful mailing by an identified organization was destroyed by a mob, and its named leaders were burned in effigy.
Sources: American Anti-Slavery Society, Third Annual Report (May 1836), publications table and treasurer's figures; Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive; Susanna Ashton, 'Ablaze', Southern Spaces (2022) - Tappan funding, Huger, the Lynch Men; PBS American Experience, The Abolitionists: burning abolitionist literature; J.D. Dickey, excerpt from The Republic of Violence, TIME (2022). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1835Event
Reported Southern 'rewards' for Arthur Tappan - real threats, shaky numbers
August 26, 1835
After the mailings, Northern and Southern newspapers carried reports that money had been put up for the seizure of Arthur Tappan. On August 26, 1835 William Leggett's New York Evening Post condemned a Charleston paper for approvingly repeating a statement that a $20,000 purse had been made up in New Orleans for anyone who would kidnap Tappan and deliver him on the levee there; an 1835 lithograph of the Charleston raid shows a placard advertising a $20,000 reward. Lewis Tappan later recorded that on September 21, 1835 a colleague noted a rumor of $100,000 for both brothers, delivered in a slave state. He also wrote that friends warned Arthur a vessel was waiting to carry him south, and that Arthur refused to stop his work.
The rule: Background: public identification as the movement's funder brought kidnapping threats; the specific bounty amounts rest on rumor and newspaper report.
Sources: William Leggett, 'Reward for Arthur Tappan', Evening Post, Aug. 26, 1835 (reprinted at Econlib / Liberty Fund); Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive; Susanna Ashton, 'Ablaze', Southern Spaces (2022) - describes the reward placard in the 1835 lithograph; J.D. Dickey, excerpt from The Republic of Violence, TIME (2022) - Norfolk meeting, $50,000
- 1841Event
Arthur and Lewis Tappan: New York silk merchants who bankrolled abolition - openly
Arthur Tappan built a large New York silk-importing house; his brother Lewis was his partner from 1828 until 1841. The two paid for much of the organized antislavery movement of the 1830s - a seminary, a college, a national society and its publications - and did so under their own names. In 1841 Lewis founded the Mercantile Agency, a credit-reporting firm that later became R.G. Dun & Co. and, after a 1933 merger with the Bradstreet Company, Dun & Bradstreet. Their story is one of retaliation against funders everyone could identify, not of anonymous giving.
The rule: Background: the leading abolitionist funders were publicly known, and that visibility is what made them targets.
Sources: Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive; Oberlin College, 'The Tappans' (175th anniversary history page); Encyclopedia.com (Gale, Company Profiles for Students), 'The Dun & Bradstreet Corporation'. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1841Court
Lewis Tappan's Amistad Committee funds a defense that wins at the Supreme Court
March 9, 1841 · 40 U.S. (15 Pet.) 518 (1841) · Vote: 7-1
In September 1839 New York abolitionists formed a committee - Lewis Tappan, Simeon Jocelyn and Joshua Leavitt - to raise money and hire lawyers for the Africans who had seized the slave schooner Amistad and were being held in Connecticut. The committee retained Roger Baldwin, Seth Staples and Theodore Sedgwick, and later persuaded former president John Quincy Adams to join the case. At the Supreme Court, Attorney General Gilpin argued for the United States and Baldwin and Adams for the Africans. On March 9, 1841 Justice Joseph Story's opinion held they had been unlawfully enslaved and were free; Justice Baldwin alone dissented, without opinion. The committee then raised the money to send the survivors home.
The rule: The Africans were free persons who had been kidnapped, not Spanish property, and were not to be handed to Spain or held by the President; the lower-court decree was affirmed except for the order to transport them to Africa at government expense.
Sources: United States v. The Amistad, 40 U.S. 518 (1841) (opinion text, Cornell LII); Cornell LII, Amistad background: Supreme Court stage (counsel; Baldwin dissent without opinion); National Park Service, 'The Amistad Committee'; National Archives, Prologue (Spring 2003), 'The Amistad Case'; Federal Judicial Center, biography of Justice Philip P. Barbour (died Feb. 25, 1841); Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (3)
- 1835Event
Commercial pressure on Arthur Tappan & Co.
According to Lewis Tappan's account, the campaign against his brother was economic as well as physical. A New York merchant with a Charleston store received a letter, issued in the name of a self-styled committee, threatening his Charleston business if he was seen entering Tappan's premises; Northern merchants with Southern trade urged Southern buyers to boycott the firm. Bank and insurance company presidents pressed Arthur to resign the presidency of the Anti-Slavery Society, warning that bank directors would refuse to discount his notes or those of any merchant who endorsed them. The firm insured part of its stock outside New York because of the mob danger, lost about $40,000 in the great fire of December 1835, and suspended payments in the commercial crash of 1837.
The rule: Background: a known donor faced boycott and credit threats aimed at making him stop funding the cause.
Sources: Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive
- 1835Event
Tappan money follows the 'Lane Rebels' to Oberlin, on condition Black students are admitted
February 10, 1835
Arthur Tappan had helped bring Lyman Beecher to Lane Seminary in Cincinnati and subscribed heavily to it. In 1834 Lane's trustees moved to shut down student antislavery discussion and societies, and a large group of students walked out; Tappan sent $1,000 to support those who left. Most of the 'Lane Rebels' moved to the struggling Oberlin Collegiate Institute in 1835 after the Tappans offered to fund it on conditions - that named faculty (including the revivalist Charles Finney) be hired, that the faculty control admissions, and that students be admitted regardless of color. Oberlin's trustees balked on January 1, 1835, then on February 10, 1835 handed admissions to the faculty and resolved that educating people of color should be encouraged.
The rule: Background: an identified donor used conditional gifts to open a college to Black students.
Sources: Oberlin College, 'The Tappans' (conditions attached to funding); Oberlin College Archives, Select Minutes of the Board of Trustees, Jan. 1 and Feb. 9-10, 1835; Oberlin College Library, Oberlin Sanctuary Project, 'The Lane Rebels'; College of Wooster digital exhibit 'A Cause for Freedom': The Lane Rebels Dismissions; Lewis Tappan, The Life of Arthur Tappan (1870), full text at Internet Archive. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1835Agency
Postmaster General Kendall declines to order delivery; President Jackson asks Congress to ban such mailings
December 8, 1835
Charleston's postmaster asked Washington what to do with the detained antislavery mail. Postmaster General Amos Kendall answered on August 4, 1835 that he had no legal power to exclude newspapers from the mail because of their content - but he would not direct that they be delivered, would neither approve nor condemn the postmaster's decision to hold them, and said officials owe a higher duty to their communities than to the laws. In his annual message of December 8, 1835, President Andrew Jackson asked Congress for a law barring, under severe penalties, the circulation of such publications through the mail in the Southern states. In the Senate John C. Calhoun resisted a federal ban on states'-rights grounds, arguing the states themselves should decide what was dangerous.
The rule: The executive branch tolerated local suppression of a disfavoured group's mail and asked Congress to make exclusion law.
Sources: Kendall to the Charleston postmaster, Aug. 4, 1835, as reprinted in the Western Carolinian (Salisbury, N.C.), Aug. 22, 1835, p. 3 (DigitalNC / State Archives of North Carolina); Andrew Jackson, Seventh Annual Message, Dec. 8, 1835 (American Presidency Project, UC Santa Barbara); Constitution Annotated, 'Power to Protect the Mails' (Cornell LII) - Jackson's proposal and Calhoun's objection. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
1928–1964: the membership list
The Supreme Court first upheld a membership-disclosure law in 1928, against the Ku Klux Klan. In the 1950s Southern states turned the same tool on the NAACP. The Court's unanimous answer in 1958 is the foundation of donor-privacy law. It is a balancing rule, not a ban on disclosure: the government must show a need that outweighs the harm to the members.
- 1928Court
New York ex rel. Bryant v. Zimmerman: the Court upholds forced filing of Klan membership rolls
November 19, 1928 · 278 U.S. 63 (1928) · Vote: 8-1
A 1923 New York statute, known as the Walker Law after its sponsor Jimmy Walker, required any oath-bound association of twenty or more members - labor unions and recognized benevolent orders excepted - to file its constitution, oath, officers and a roster of members with the secretary of state, and made it a misdemeanor to stay in a group known not to have filed. George Bryant, a member of the Buffalo Provisional Klan of the Ku Klux Klan, was arrested under it and sought release by habeas corpus. The Supreme Court upheld the law in an opinion by Justice Van Devanter. Justice McReynolds wrote separately only to say the Court lacked jurisdiction.
The rule: A state may require an oath-bound secret association to disclose its members and officers as a reasonable police regulation; exempting unions and fraternal orders did not deny equal protection because the legislature could find that the Klan class of societies used secrecy to cloak intimidation and lawlessness.
Sources: New York ex rel. Bryant v. Zimmerman, 278 U.S. 63 (1928) (opinion text, Cornell LII); NAACP v. Alabama, 357 U.S. 449, 465-466 (1958) (distinguishing Bryant) (opinion text, Cornell LII); Jewish Daily Bulletin (JTA archive), Nov. 21, 1928, report on the decision ('Walker law'; George C. Bryant)
- 1958Court
NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson: the state cannot force the NAACP to hand over its member list
June 30, 1958 · 357 U.S. 449 (1958) · Vote: 9-0
On June 1, 1956, Alabama Attorney General John Patterson sued to oust the NAACP from the state for not registering as an out-of-state corporation, citing among other things its support for the Montgomery bus boycott and for Black applicants to the state university. The same day Montgomery Circuit Judge Walter B. Jones, without hearing the NAACP, barred it from operating in Alabama and even from trying to register. The state then demanded its records, including the names and addresses of every Alabama member. The NAACP turned over nearly everything else but refused the membership lists, and was fined $10,000 for contempt, raised to $100,000 after five days. A unanimous Supreme Court, through Justice Harlan, threw out the contempt judgment and the fine.
The rule: Compelled disclosure of membership in an advocacy group can restrain freedom of association as effectively as direct regulation. Because the NAACP showed that exposure of rank-and-file members had brought reprisals, Alabama needed a compelling justification, and the lists had no substantial bearing on whether the NAACP was doing business in the state. The right is protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
Sources: NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson, 357 U.S. 449 (1958) (opinion text, Cornell LII); NAACP v. Gallion, 368 U.S. 16 (1961) (dating the restraining order to June 1, 1956) (opinion text, Cornell LII); Encyclopedia of Alabama, 'NAACP v. Alabama' (Judge Walter B. Jones; unanimous)
- 1960Court
Bates v. City of Little Rock: a license-tax ordinance cannot be used to get NAACP member and donor names
February 23, 1960 · 361 U.S. 516 (1960) · Vote: 9-0
In 1957 Little Rock and North Little Rock amended their business license-tax ordinances to require any organization, on request, to give the city clerk details including who had paid dues and contributions - information that would then be open to public inspection. Daisy Bates and a second branch official named Williams, who kept the records of the two local NAACP branches, supplied everything asked for except the names of members and contributors, citing the risk of harassment and reprisals. Each was convicted and fined. The Supreme Court reversed unanimously in an opinion by Justice Stewart, noting evidence that members had dropped out after the ordinances passed and that people identified as members had been harassed and threatened.
The rule: Where compelled disclosure of membership would significantly interfere with freedom of association, the government must show a compelling interest to which the disclosure is actually relevant. The cities showed no connection between the names and any license tax the branches could owe.
Sources: Bates v. City of Little Rock, 361 U.S. 516 (1960) (opinion text, Cornell LII). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1960Court
Talley v. California: a city cannot ban all handbills that do not name their authors
March 7, 1960 · 362 U.S. 60 (1960) · Vote: 6-3
A Los Angeles ordinance made it an offence to distribute any handbill anywhere that did not carry the names and addresses of the people who wrote, printed and distributed it. Manuel Talley was fined $10 for handing out leaflets, issued in the name of a group called National Consumers Mobilization, urging a boycott of merchants who sold goods from manufacturers accused of refusing to hire Black, Mexican and Asian workers. Justice Black's opinion for six justices struck the ordinance down on its face, pointing to the long history of anonymous pamphlets, including the Federalist Papers and pre-Revolutionary patriot writings. Justice Clark, joined by Frankfurter and Whittaker, dissented.
The rule: A blanket requirement that all handbills identify their authors and distributors restricts freedom of speech and press, because fear of identification and reprisal can deter peaceful discussion of public issues. The Court left open a law narrowly aimed at fraud, false advertising or libel.
Sources: Talley v. California, 362 U.S. 60 (1960) (opinion text, Cornell LII)
- 1960Court
Shelton v. Tucker: Arkansas cannot make teachers list every group they belong or give to
December 12, 1960 · 364 U.S. 479 (1960) · Vote: 5-4
Arkansas Act 10 of 1958 required every teacher in a state-supported school or college, as a condition of employment, to file an affidavit each year listing every organization he or she had belonged to or regularly contributed to in the previous five years. Arkansas teachers had no tenure and the affidavits were not confidential. B.T. Shelton, a Little Rock teacher of twenty-five years and an NAACP member, refused and was not rehired; a university professor and a Central High School teacher also refused. The Court struck the law down 5-4 in an opinion by Justice Stewart.
The rule: A state may inquire into the fitness of its teachers, but it may not pursue even a legitimate purpose by means that broadly stifle personal liberties when narrower means are available; demanding every associational tie, relevant or not, goes far beyond what fitness inquiries justify.
Sources: Shelton v. Tucker, 364 U.S. 479 (1960) (opinion text, Cornell LII)
- 1963Court
Gibson v. Florida Legislative Investigation Committee: no rummaging in NAACP rolls without a real link to subversion
March 25, 1963 · 372 U.S. 539 (1963) · Vote: 5-4
A Florida legislative committee - widely known as the Johns Committee after its leader, state senator Charley Johns - began investigating the NAACP in 1956. After Florida's own supreme court barred it from seizing the whole Miami membership list, the committee in November 1959 ordered the Miami branch president, Theodore Gibson, to bring the records and consult them to say whether fourteen named people, alleged to be Communists, were members. Gibson offered to answer from memory but refused to bring or use the lists; he was held in contempt, sentenced to six months in jail and fined $1,200. The Supreme Court reversed 5-4 in an opinion by Justice Goldberg.
The rule: Before a legislature may intrude on the membership records of a lawful organization it must show a substantial connection between that organization and the subversive activity under investigation, amounting to a compelling state interest. Thin, largely hearsay evidence that a few alleged Communists had attended meetings of a 1,000-member branch did not suffice.
Sources: Gibson v. Florida Legislative Investigation Committee, 372 U.S. 539 (1963) (opinion text, Cornell LII); First Amendment Encyclopedia (Free Speech Center, Middle Tennessee State University), entry on Gibson; University of Central Florida Libraries research guide, 'The Johns Committee' (official name, 1956-1965, Sen. Charley Johns). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1964Court
Eight years, four trips to the Supreme Court: Alabama keeps the NAACP out until 1964
June 1, 1964 · 360 U.S. 240 (1959); 368 U.S. 16 (1961); 377 U.S. 288 (1964) · Vote: 9-0
The 1958 ruling did not let the NAACP back into Alabama. On remand the Alabama Supreme Court reinstated the contempt fine, saying the justices had misread the record; the U.S. Supreme Court reversed again on June 8, 1959. When the state courts still gave the NAACP no hearing on the 1956 order, it sued in federal court, and on October 23, 1961 the Supreme Court set a deadline of January 2, 1962 for Alabama to hear the case. The state court then permanently banned the organization, and the Alabama Supreme Court affirmed on a briefing technicality. On June 1, 1964 - eight years to the day after the 'temporary' order - a unanimous Court, again through Justice Harlan, rejected the technicality, reached the merits itself, and held the NAACP could not be barred from the state.
The rule: A state may not use procedural devices to evade a federal ruling, and may not oust a lawful advocacy organization because of its constitutionally protected activities; the Court ordered prompt entry of a decree letting the NAACP operate in Alabama.
Sources: NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson, 360 U.S. 240 (1959) (per curiam) (opinion text, Cornell LII); NAACP v. Gallion, 368 U.S. 16 (1961) (per curiam) (opinion text, Cornell LII); NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Flowers, 377 U.S. 288 (1964) (opinion text, Cornell LII); Encyclopedia of Alabama, 'NAACP v. Alabama' (return to the state in 1964). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (4)
- 1907Law
First federal campaign-money laws: Tillman Act (1907), Publicity Act (1910, amended 1911), Federal Corrupt Practices Act (1925)
Tillman Act (1907); Publicity Act of 1910 and 1911 amendments; Federal Corrupt Practices Act of Feb. 28, 1925, c. 368, title III, 43 Stat. 1053, 1070
Congress's first major campaign finance law, the Tillman Act of 1907, barred corporations and nationally chartered banks from contributing to federal campaigns. Federal disclosure rules followed in 1910 and 1911. The Federal Corrupt Practices Act of 1925 pulled those rules together: multi-state political committees had to have a treasurer, keep exact accounts and file with the Clerk of the House the name and address of each contributor with the date and amount. The Congressional Research Service says the 1925 law had come to be seen as ineffective by the 1970s. When the Supreme Court reviewed the 1974 thresholds in Buckley, it noted Congress seemed simply to have carried over the dollar thresholds used in disclosure laws since 1910.
The rule: Corporate contribution ban (1907); first federal contributor-disclosure requirements (1910-11); consolidated disclosure statute (1925) that stayed on the books until FECA replaced it.
Sources: CRS Report R41542, The State of Campaign Finance Policy (mirror of CRS text); Burroughs v. United States, 290 U.S. 534 (1934) (describes the 1925 Act's terms and date); Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976), Part II-D (thresholds traced to 1910). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1934Court
Burroughs v. United States (1934) and United States v. Harriss (1954): the Court upholds campaign and lobbying disclosure
January 8, 1934 · Burroughs v. United States, 290 U.S. 534 (Jan. 8, 1934); United States v. Harriss, 347 U.S. 612 (June 7, 1954) · Vote: Burroughs: opinion by Sutherland; McReynolds dissented in part (on the sufficiency of the indictment). Harriss: 5-3, opinion by Chief Justice Warren; Douglas (joined by Black) and Jackson dissented; Clark took no part.
In Burroughs, officers of a political committee were indicted for failing to file the contributor reports the 1925 Corrupt Practices Act required in a presidential-elector campaign. The Court held Congress has power to require that publicity to protect presidential elections from the corrupt use of money, and let the conspiracy counts stand. Twenty years later, in Harriss, men charged with unreported spending to influence farm-price legislation challenged the 1946 Federal Regulation of Lobbying Act. The Court saved the statute by reading it narrowly, to cover only direct communication with members of Congress on pending or proposed legislation, and upheld disclosure as so limited. The dissenters thought the statute was too vague to be rescued by rewriting it.
The rule: Congress may require disclosure of contributors to committees in federal elections (Burroughs) and of paid lobbying aimed directly at Congress (Harriss, as narrowly construed).
Sources: Burroughs v. United States, 290 U.S. 534 (LII); United States v. Harriss, 347 U.S. 612 (LII)
- 1961Court
Louisiana ex rel. Gremillion v. NAACP: an old anti-Klan membership-list law turned on the NAACP
May 22, 1961 · 366 U.S. 293 (1961) · Vote: 9-0
Louisiana sued in 1956 to stop the NAACP from operating in the state, relying on two statutes. One, said to have been passed in 1924 to curb the Ku Klux Klan and never before enforced against anyone else, required organizations to file the names and addresses of all members each year. The other barred any group affiliated with an out-of-state body unless it swore that none of the national body's officers belonged to organizations listed as subversive. A federal court blocked both laws, noting claims that members of branches which had filed lists suffered economic reprisals. The Supreme Court unanimously affirmed in an opinion by Justice Douglas.
The rule: Where disclosure of membership lists is shown to result in reprisals and hostility toward members, it cannot be required; regulation touching association must be narrowly drawn. Requiring local members to swear to facts about national officers they could not know also violated due process.
Sources: Louisiana ex rel. Gremillion v. NAACP, 366 U.S. 293 (1961) (opinion text, Cornell LII)
1934–2007: tax files and politics
Administrations of both parties have tried to use the tax agency against political opponents, and the attempts are well documented. How much they achieved is a separate question, and the popular versions overstate it. Congress made tax returns confidential by statute in 1976 in direct response.
- 1954Law
The Johnson Amendment is added to the tax code on the Senate floor
July 2, 1954 · 100 Cong. Rec. 9604 (July 2, 1954); Internal Revenue Code of 1954, ch. 736, 68A Stat. 163 (Aug. 16, 1954); 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) · Vote: Agreed to in the Senate without a recorded vote and without debate
On July 2, 1954, while the Senate was amending the bill that became the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, Sen. Lyndon Johnson of Texas offered a floor amendment to section 501(c)(3). It denied the charitable exemption to any organization that participates or intervenes in a political campaign on behalf of a candidate for public office, including by publishing or distributing statements. Johnson explained it in a few sentences, said he had cleared it with the committee chairman and ranking member, Sen. Millikin of Colorado said he would take it to conference, and the chair announced it agreed to. The exchange takes up less than one column of the Congressional Record and nobody else spoke to its merits. The Code was signed into law on August 16, 1954.
The rule: A 501(c)(3) organization may not participate or intervene in any political campaign for a candidate. The text applies to every 501(c)(3) and contains no exception for churches.
Sources: Congressional Record, Senate, July 2, 1954, p. 9604 (govinfo); CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447 (July 2, 2026); 26 U.S.C. 501 with source credits (Cornell LII). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1961Agency
Kennedy-era IRS 'Ideological Organizations Project'
November 30, 1961 · S. Rep. No. 94-755, Book III, at 890-897 (1976) (Church Committee)
President Kennedy criticized right-wing extremists in speeches on November 16 and 18, 1961, and at a November 29 news conference said he was sure the IRS examined whether donations to such groups were being used properly. The next day an IRS assistant commissioner ordered a list of organizations to audit; on December 20, 1961 an aide to the commissioner supplied 18 names drawn partly from Time and Newsweek articles. A left-wing group was added, and in April 1962 a list of 19 left-of-center groups, to avoid the appearance of singling out one ideology. In July 1963 Kennedy phoned the commissioner urging an aggressive program on both sides; a plan for 10,000 exempt-organization examinations was drawn up but never carried out. A final list of 24 organizations, 19 of them right-wing, went through special review.
The rule: The Church Committee found that apparently none of the groups was chosen because of any information that it was violating the tax laws. An IRS task force recommended revoking 15 exemptions (14 right-wing); 4 were approved (3 right, 1 left). Later reports show seven organizations lost exemptions in 1966-67, six of them right-wing.
Sources: Church Committee Final Report, Book III (Senate Intelligence Committee). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1964Event
FBI obtains tax returns of Martin Luther King Jr. and the SCLC; field office proposes scaring donors
S. Rep. No. 94-755, Book III, at 855-856 (1976)
The Church Committee found that in 1964 the FBI obtained from the IRS all available information on Dr. King and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, including the tax returns of both and IRS investigative files. In April 1964 the FBI's Atlanta office proposed forging letters on SCLC stationery over King's signature to tell donors that the IRS was checking the group's tax records, in the expectation that this would alarm contributors and dry up donations. FBI headquarters set the idea aside as not desirable or feasible at that time, and the Committee found no evidence it was carried out. The Committee also found the FBI later requested the returns of at least 72 of 90 people in its 'Key Black Extremist' program.
The rule: Documented misuse of tax information for a non-tax purpose: disrupting a lawful civil rights organization by targeting its donors.
- 1969Agency
Nixon-era IRS 'Special Service Staff' keeps files on activists and dissident groups
S. Rep. No. 94-755, Book III, at 842-843, 876-890 (1976)
In July 1969, after criticism from a Senate subcommittee and expressions of White House interest, the IRS set up a secret national-office unit first called the Activist Organizations Committee and then the Special Service Staff. It collected names from the FBI, the Justice Department's Internal Security Division and others, opened files on people and groups because of their politics, and referred some for audit or collection. The FBI was its largest source, including a list of 2,300 organizations labeled Old Left, New Left and Right Wing. The Church Committee says its targets included about 8,000 individuals and 3,000 groups, among them the Ford Foundation, Head Start and 50 branches of the National Urban League. Commissioner Donald Alexander abolished it in 1973 when he learned of it.
The rule: The Church Committee concluded the unit reviewed taxpayers because they exercised First Amendment rights, without specific evidence of tax violations. Of 11,458 files, 225 cases were referred to the field; total assessments were about $622,000, of which $501,000 came from four cases.
Sources: Church Committee Final Report, Book III. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1971Event
The Nixon White House 'enemies list' and the IRS
August 16, 1971 · Memorandum, John Dean, 'Dealing with our Political Enemies' (Aug. 16, 1971), Senate Watergate Committee exhibit
On August 16, 1971 White House counsel John Dean wrote a memo on how the administration could use federal agencies against people active in opposing it, naming grants, contracts, litigation and prosecution as levers. White House aides compiled a list of twenty names and a longer list of about 200. Dean later compiled a second list of George McGovern staff and supporters and gave it to the IRS on September 11, 1972. The lists became public during the Senate Watergate hearings in June 1973 and in a second release in December 1973.
The rule: Documentary evidence of an attempt to direct tax enforcement at political opponents. It became the first charge in Article II of the impeachment articles.
Sources: Dean memo, Rufus Edmisten Papers, UNC Libraries; UNC Libraries exhibit: Nixon's Enemies List
- 1974Event
Impeachment Article II charges Nixon with trying to misuse the IRS
July 29, 1974 · H. Res. 803, Article II, para. (1), 93d Cong. (House Judiciary Committee, July 29, 1974); 3 Deschler's Precedents ch. 14, sec. 15 · Vote: 28-10 in the House Judiciary Committee
On July 29, 1974 the House Judiciary Committee adopted a second article of impeachment, on abuse of power, by 28 to 10. Its first numbered paragraph charged that Nixon, personally and through subordinates, tried to obtain confidential information from income tax returns for purposes not authorized by law and tried to have tax audits and investigations started or conducted in a discriminatory way. The other paragraphs dealt with the FBI, the Secret Service, the 'plumbers' unit and other matters. Nixon resigned on August 9, 1974 before the full House voted.
The rule: A committee-approved charge, never voted on by the full House or tried in the Senate.
Sources: Deschler's Precedents, vol. 3, ch. 14, sec. 15 (govinfo)
- 1976Law
Tax Reform Act of 1976 makes tax returns confidential by statute
October 4, 1976 · Pub. L. 94-455, sec. 1202 (Oct. 4, 1976); 26 U.S.C. 6103
After Watergate and the Church Committee disclosures, Congress rewrote section 6103 of the tax code in the Tax Reform Act of 1976. The general rule now is that returns and return information are confidential and may be disclosed only where the statute itself authorizes it, with detailed rules for Congress, the President, law enforcement and the states. Before the change, the Church Committee had found, the FBI and other federal investigators could obtain returns and even contributor lists from the IRS by simple request. Unauthorized disclosure is a felony under section 7213.
The rule: Returns and return information are confidential unless a specific statutory exception applies.
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 6103 (Cornell LII); Church Committee Final Report, Book III, at 855 (pre-1976 access by other agencies)
- 2004Event
IRS examines the NAACP after its chairman criticizes President Bush
October 8, 2004
In July 2004 NAACP chairman Julian Bond gave a convention speech in Philadelphia sharply critical of Bush administration policies. On October 8, 2004, about a month before the election, the IRS opened an examination of whether the speech was prohibited campaign intervention. The NAACP made the inquiry public and called it political. In a letter dated August 9, 2006, released August 31, the IRS said that after reviewing video of the speech and other information it had concluded political intervention did not occur. Documents the NAACP obtained during the fight showed that at least six Republican members of Congress had forwarded constituent complaints about the speech to the IRS.
The rule: No violation found; exemption unaffected, after an examination lasting nearly two years.
Sources: Associated Press via NBC News, Aug. 31, 2006; OMB Watch archive (reproducing NAACP statement), Aug. 31, 2006. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (9)
- 1934Event
Roosevelt-era tax cases against Andrew Mellon and other opponentsNot confirmed
Journalistic histories say the Roosevelt administration turned the tax agency on a series of rivals and critics, among them Sen. Huey Long, newspaper publishers and, most famously, former Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon. A federal grand jury declined to indict Mellon for tax fraud in 1934, after which the government pursued a civil claim for millions in back taxes before the Board of Tax Appeals. Historians have not found documents explaining why Mellon was pursued.
The rule: No official finding of political motive exists for these cases.
Sources: Christian Science Monitor, May 17, 2013. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1966Event
Sierra Club loses its tax-deductible status after Grand Canyon dam ads
In 1966 the Sierra Club ran full-page newspaper ads against two proposed dams near the Grand Canyon, urging readers to pressure Congress. The campaign flooded congressional offices with mail. In response the IRS stripped the club of its tax-deductible status on the ground that it was trying to influence legislation. Neither dam was built.
The rule: Loss of 501(c)(3) status for substantial lobbying, not for candidate campaigning.
Sources: Yale Energy History project, 'Sierra Club Grand Canyon dam advertisements, 1966'. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1968Event
IRS audit of Students for a Democratic Society yields a contributor list that goes to the FBI and the White House
S. Rep. No. 94-755, Book III, at 856-857 (1976)
In 1968 the IRS was auditing Students for a Democratic Society; an FBI letter of June 10, 1968 described the audit as being done at the Bureau's request, though IRS files showed FBI encouragement and no formal request. Because SDS had been denied an exemption, the IRS identified its contributors in the course of the audit. The FBI obtained the list the IRS developed, and the IRS later passed the list to the White House. The Committee noted that under the rules then in force, audit results including contributor lists were available to other federal agencies on request.
The rule: A contributor list compiled for tax purposes was shared with law enforcement and political officials.
- 1972Court
Christian Echoes National Ministry v. United States (Billy James Hargis's ministry loses exemption)Not confirmed
Christian Echoes National Ministry, Inc. v. United States, 470 F.2d 849 (10th Cir. 1972)
Billy James Hargis's Oklahoma-based anticommunist ministry is usually cited as the best-known group to lose its exemption in the wake of the 1960s audits of ideological organizations. The Tenth Circuit upheld the IRS's revocation, relying on the ministry's attempts to influence legislation and its intervention in campaigns. The case is the leading early appellate decision applying the lobbying and campaign limits to a religious organization.
The rule: Reported holding: revocation upheld; the limits on lobbying and campaign activity are valid conditions on a tax exemption.
Sources: Opinion page (CourtListener; would not load for automated fetch today); Church Committee Final Report, Book III (context on the audit project; does not name this group). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1972Event
IRS Commissioner Walters and Treasury Secretary Shultz sit on the listNot confirmed
According to obituaries of Johnnie Walters and congressional findings summarized in news reports, Dean handed Commissioner Walters a list of about 200 names in September 1972 and asked for investigations. Walters took it to Treasury Secretary George Shultz, recommended doing nothing, and was told to lock it in his safe. He later turned the list over to the staff chief of Congress's Joint Committee on Internal Revenue Taxation, which reported in December 1973 that it found no evidence the people on the list were audited as a result.
The rule: Reported outcome: the IRS did not act on the list.
Sources: Washington Post obituary of Johnnie Walters, June 26, 2014 (would not load for automated fetch); UNC Libraries exhibit (confirms Dean gave the second list to the IRS on Sept. 11, 1972). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1987Law
Congress adds '(or in opposition to)' to the campaign ban
December 22, 1987 · Pub. L. 100-203, sec. 10711 (Dec. 22, 1987); 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3)
The 1954 text banned campaign activity 'on behalf of' a candidate. In the budget reconciliation law enacted December 22, 1987, Congress inserted the words '(or in opposition to)' so that the statute expressly covers campaigning against a candidate as well as for one. The change applies to activities after that date. This is the wording still in the Code today.
The rule: The ban covers intervention for or against any candidate for public office.
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 501, amendment notes for 1987 (Cornell LII)
- 1998Law
Section 7217 bars the White House from asking the IRS to audit, or stop auditing, a particular taxpayer
July 22, 1998 · Pub. L. 105-206, sec. 1105(a) (July 22, 1998), 112 Stat. 711; 26 U.S.C. 7217
Added in the 1998 IRS reform law, section 7217 makes it unlawful for the President, the Vice President, employees of their executive offices, and Cabinet-level officers other than the Attorney General to request, directly or indirectly, that any IRS employee conduct or end an audit or investigation of a particular taxpayer. IRS employees who receive such a request must report it to the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration. A willful violation, or a failure to report, is punishable by a fine of up to $5,000, up to five years in prison, or both.
The rule: Executive-branch political officials may not direct taxpayer-specific audits or investigations.
Sources: 26 U.S.C. 7217 (Cornell LII)
- 2000Court
Branch Ministries v. Rossotti: a church loses its exemption over anti-Clinton newspaper ads
May 12, 2000 · Branch Ministries v. Rossotti, 211 F.3d 137 (D.C. Cir. 2000), No. 99-5097 · Vote: Unanimous panel; opinion by Senior Judge Buckley
On October 30, 1992, four days before the presidential election, the Church at Pierce Creek in Binghamton, New York, ran full-page ads in USA Today and the Washington Times headlined 'Christians Beware'. The ads urged Christians not to vote for Bill Clinton and said tax-deductible donations for the ad were welcome. The IRS opened a church tax examination on February 11, 1993 and revoked the church's 501(c)(3) status on January 19, 1995. The D.C. Circuit upheld the revocation on May 12, 2000.
The rule: The IRS acted within its statutory authority. Losing the exemption did not substantially burden the church's religious exercise, in part because it could set up a related 501(c)(4) with a political committee. The church did not show it was singled out for improper reasons, so its selective-prosecution claim failed.
Sources: D.C. Circuit opinion (govinfo)
- 2007Event
IRS examination of All Saints Episcopal Church, Pasadena, over an antiwar sermon
September 23, 2007
Shortly before the 2004 election, the retired rector of All Saints Church in Pasadena, George Regas, preached a guest sermon staged as a debate among George W. Bush, John Kerry and Jesus. It condemned the Iraq war and policies toward the poor, and Regas said he was not telling anyone how to vote. The IRS examined the liberal congregation for more than two years. In September 2007 the rector told parishioners the IRS had closed the case: the church kept its exemption, but the agency concluded the sermon was a prohibited campaign intervention without saying which words crossed the line. The church's lawyer, a former head of the IRS exempt organizations office, said records obtained under FOIA showed the IRS had consulted the Justice Department, and the church asked for an investigation of the IRS.
The rule: No penalty and no revocation. The IRS's reported conclusion that the sermon violated the ban was never tested in court.
Sources: NPR report republished by LAist, Sept. 26, 2007. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
1974–2014: disclosure in court
For election spending the Court has mostly sided with disclosure, eight to one in Citizens United, while keeping an exemption for groups that can prove a real risk of reprisal. For lone pamphleteers it has protected anonymity. California's Proposition 8 became the test case for what public donor lists make possible.
- 1976Court
Buckley v. Valeo: disclosure upheld, with an escape hatch for groups facing reprisals
January 30, 1976 · Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976) (per curiam), Part II · Vote: Per curiam. Disclosure provisions upheld; Chief Justice Burger dissented in part, objecting to the disclosure of small contributions.
A challenge by Senator James Buckley and others to the 1974 law produced the framework still used today. The Court said compelled disclosure can seriously burden association, so it must survive 'exacting scrutiny' and bear a substantial relation to an important interest. It then found three such interests: telling voters where campaign money comes from, deterring corruption by exposing large gifts, and gathering the data needed to detect violations of contribution limits. It refused a blanket exemption for minor parties but said a group need show only a reasonable probability that naming its contributors would bring threats, harassment or reprisals. To avoid vagueness, it read the disclosure rule for independent spenders to reach only contributions earmarked for political purposes and spending on communications that expressly advocate a clearly identified candidate's election or defeat.
The rule: Disclosure is reviewed under exacting scrutiny and is generally valid; as-applied exemptions are available on a showing of a reasonable probability of threats, harassment or reprisals; independent-spender disclosure is limited to express advocacy. The Court conceded the $10 recordkeeping and $100 reporting thresholds were low but left the line to Congress.
Sources: Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (LII full text); FEC litigation summary, Buckley v. Valeo
- 1995Court
McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission: a right to hand out unsigned leaflets
April 19, 1995 · McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission, 514 U.S. 334 (1995) · Vote: 7-2. Stevens for the Court (joined by O'Connor, Kennedy, Souter, Ginsburg, Breyer); Ginsburg concurred; Thomas concurred in the judgment; Scalia dissented, joined by Chief Justice Rehnquist.
On April 27, 1988, Margaret McIntyre stood outside a public meeting at Blendon Middle School in Westerville, Ohio, handing out leaflets she had written on her home computer opposing a proposed school tax levy. Some were signed only 'Concerned Parents and Tax Payers.' After the levy finally passed, a school official filed a complaint and the Ohio Elections Commission fined her $100 for distributing campaign literature without her name and address. She died while the case was pending, and the executor of her estate, Joseph McIntyre, carried it to the Supreme Court. The Court held that Ohio's ban on anonymous campaign literature violated the First Amendment.
The rule: A flat ban on anonymous campaign literature is a regulation of core political speech and fails exacting scrutiny; the state's interest in informing voters does not justify forcing a private citizen to put her name on a handbill. The Court distinguished Buckley's disclosure of campaign spending and said a more limited identification rule might be permissible.
Sources: McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission, 514 U.S. 334 (LII)
- 2008Event
California Proposition 8: donor lists, a map, and the backlash
November 4, 2008 · California Proposition 8 (Nov. 4, 2008); Political Reform Act, Cal. Gov. Code sec. 84211(f) · Vote: Passed 52.24% to 47.76% (7,001,084 to 6,401,482)
California law required committees for and against the same-sex marriage ban to report the name, street address, occupation and employer of every donor at the $100 level, and the Secretary of State posted the data online. By January 2009 an anonymous site called eightmaps had overlaid the Yes-on-8 donor file on a Google map showing names and streets. Scott Eckern, artistic director of Sacramento's California Musical Theatre, resigned on Nov. 12, 2008 after his $1,000 gift became known; Richard Raddon, director of the Los Angeles Film Festival, left after his $1,500 gift was reported, his resignation accepted on Nov. 25, 2008. A Los Angeles restaurant manager of 26 years who gave $100 stepped down after protesters repeatedly gathered outside; police came one night in riot gear. Donors' court filings also alleged death threats, vandalism and envelopes of white powder mailed to two religious organizations.
The rule: Not a ruling. The episode became the leading modern example cited for donor privacy, and the main test of whether the Buckley/Brown harassment exemption has any practical force for a large, well-funded campaign.
Sources: Ballotpedia, California Proposition 8 (2008) (certified totals); Citizens United v. FEC, opinion of Thomas, J. (disclosure rules, maps, three resignations, threats; cites WSJ Dec. 26, 2008 and L.A. Times Dec. 14, 2008); Poynter, Feb. 9, 2009 (eightmaps description; $100 threshold; lawsuit); ArtsJournal, Nov. 13, 2008 (Eckern resignation, relaying New York Times report); The Advocate, Nov. 26, 2008 (Raddon resignation). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2010Court
Citizens United v. FEC: corporate independent spending freed 5-4, disclosure upheld 8-1
January 21, 2010 · Citizens United v. FEC, 558 U.S. 310 (2010) · Vote: 5-4 striking the ban on corporate independent expenditures (Kennedy, with Roberts, Scalia, Alito, Thomas). 8-1 upholding BCRA's disclaimer and disclosure rules in Part IV (Stevens, Ginsburg, Breyer and Sotomayor joined that part; Thomas alone dissented from it).
A nonprofit corporation wanted to distribute and advertise 'Hillary: The Movie' during the 2008 primaries. The Court held that government may not ban independent political spending because the speaker is a corporation. In the same opinion, eight Justices upheld the requirements that the ads carry a disclaimer and that anyone spending more than $10,000 on electioneering communications report its donors. Justice Kennedy wrote that disclosure is a less restrictive alternative to banning speech, that it lets shareholders and citizens hold corporations and officials accountable, and that the group had shown no evidence its donors faced threats. He also refused to limit disclosure to express advocacy. Justice Thomas, alone, would have struck the disclosure rules, citing the treatment of Proposition 8 donors.
The rule: Corporations and unions may make unlimited independent expenditures from their treasuries; disclaimer and donor-disclosure requirements for those ads are constitutional, subject to as-applied exemptions on proof of likely harassment. The ruling did not affect the ban on corporate contributions to candidates.
Sources: Citizens United v. FEC, syllabus and lineup (LII); Citizens United, opinion of the Court, Part IV (LII); Citizens United, opinion of Thomas, J. (LII); FEC litigation summary, Citizens United v. FEC
- 2010Law
The DISCLOSE Act of 2010: passes the House, dies one vote short in the Senate
June 24, 2010 · H.R. 5175 and S. 3628, 111th Congress (Democracy is Strengthened by Casting Light on Spending in Elections Act) · Vote: House passage June 24, 2010: 219-206 (Democrats 217-36; Republicans 2-170). Senate cloture on the motion to proceed to S. 3628: 57-41 on July 27, 2010 and 59-39 on Sept. 23, 2010 (60 needed).
Congress's direct response to Citizens United would have required corporations, unions and advocacy groups that pay for election ads to report their funders and name top donors in the ads, among other things. It passed the House on a near party-line vote. In the Senate a majority supported taking it up both times, but it never reached the 60 votes needed to end debate, with Republicans united against it. Opposition was not only partisan: the ACLU wrote to senators on July 23, 2010 that the bill would do little for campaign integrity while significantly harming speech and associational rights, and warned that disclosure rules should not chill controversial political groups. The House version also drew fire from some of the bill's own supporters after a carve-out was added that would have exempted the National Rifle Association and a few other large, long-established membership groups.
The rule: Not enacted. Blocked by filibuster in the Senate.
Sources: House Clerk, Roll Call 391 (June 24, 2010); Senate roll call vote 220, 111th Cong. 2nd Sess. (July 27, 2010); Senate roll call vote 240, 111th Cong. 2nd Sess. (Sept. 23, 2010); ACLU letter to the Senate opposing S. 3628 (July 23, 2010). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2010Court
Doe v. Reed: referendum petition signatures are public records
June 24, 2010 · Doe v. Reed, 561 U.S. 186 (2010); on remand, 823 F. Supp. 2d 1195 (W.D. Wash. Oct. 17, 2011); appeal dismissed as moot, 697 F.3d 1235 (9th Cir. Oct. 23, 2012) · Vote: 8-1. Roberts for the Court (joined by Kennedy, Ginsburg, Breyer, Alito, Sotomayor); Stevens and Scalia concurred in the judgment; Thomas dissented.
In 2009 Washington expanded domestic-partner rights, and Protect Marriage Washington gathered more than 137,000 signatures to force a referendum (R-71); voters kept the law, 53% to 47%. When requests for the petitions were filed under the state public records act, signers sued to keep their names and addresses from being released. The Supreme Court held that disclosing referendum petitions in general does not violate the First Amendment, because it helps the state root out fraud and invalid signatures, and sent the signers' specific harassment claim back to the trial court. There, Judge Benjamin Settle found the evidence fell short: the witnesses' police complaints had been handled, and the names of 857 campaign donors had been public for years without serious incident. The Supreme Court refused a stay on Nov. 21, 2011, the petitions became public, and the appeal was dismissed as moot.
The rule: Public disclosure of referendum petitions is generally constitutional under exacting scrutiny; an as-applied exemption requires real evidence of a reasonable probability of threats, harassment or reprisals, and the R-71 signers did not produce it.
Sources: Doe v. Reed, syllabus (LII); Doe v. Reed, opinion of the Court (signature count, vote result); Doe v. Reed, Scalia, J., concurring in the judgment; Doe v. Reed, Thomas, J., dissenting; Washington Attorney General release on the remand ruling; Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, Doe v. Reed (post-remand timeline). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2014Event
Brendan Eich resigns as Mozilla CEO over a $1,000 Prop 8 donation
April 3, 2014 · n/a
Brendan Eich, a Mozilla co-founder and the creator of JavaScript, gave $1,000 in 2008 to support Proposition 8. The gift was listed in California's public campaign-finance records, which the Los Angeles Times had turned into a searchable database, and it drew attention online in 2012. Mozilla named him CEO on March 24, 2014. Employees criticized the choice publicly and the dating site OkCupid urged Firefox users to switch browsers. Mozilla announced on April 3, 2014 that he had stepped down, ten days after his appointment.
The rule: Not a ruling. Frequently cited by donor-privacy advocates as showing that a small disclosed gift can end a career years later; cited by disclosure advocates as lawful private criticism and consumer pressure, not government reprisal.
Sources: Mozilla blog, Mar. 24, 2014 (appointment); Mozilla blog, Apr. 3, 2014 (resignation); TIME, Apr. 3, 2014; Reason, Apr. 4, 2014 (source of the donor record); TechCrunch, Apr. 3, 2014 (OkCupid, employee opposition). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (9)
- 1974Law
Taft-Hartley (1947), the Federal Election Campaign Act (1971) and the 1974 amendments that created the FEC
Labor Management Relations Act of 1947, sec. 304, 61 Stat. 159; Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 as amended in 1974 (now 52 U.S.C. 30101 et seq.) · Vote: n/a (Taft-Hartley was enacted over President Truman's veto)
A wartime law in 1943 temporarily extended the federal contribution ban to labor unions; Taft-Hartley made it permanent in 1947 and, for the first time, also barred corporate and union independent expenditures. Congress passed it over the veto of President Truman, who warned that the spending ban intruded on free speech. The Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 replaced the 1925 law and centered on reporting, including regular disclosure of receipts and spending. After the financial abuses of the 1972 presidential campaign, the 1974 amendments added contribution and spending limits and created the Federal Election Commission, which opened in 1975. As written in 1974, the law required committees to record anyone giving more than $10 and to report publicly anyone giving more than $100 in a year.
The rule: Union contribution/expenditure ban (1947); modern federal disclosure system and an independent enforcement agency (1971-1975).
Sources: FEC, Mission and history; CRS Report R41542 (mirror); Citizens United v. FEC, opinion of the Court (history of the 1947 expenditure ban and Truman veto); Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (the $10 / $100 thresholds). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 1978Court
First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti: corporations may spend on ballot questions
April 26, 1978 · First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti, 435 U.S. 765 (1978) · Vote: 5-4. Powell for the Court; Burger concurred; White (joined by Brennan and Marshall) and Rehnquist dissented.
Massachusetts made it a crime for banks and business corporations to spend money to influence referendum votes on issues that did not materially affect their business. Banks and companies that wanted to publicize their opposition to a proposed graduated income tax amendment sued. The Court struck the ban down, reasoning that the value of speech to the public does not depend on whether the speaker is a corporation. In a footnote the Court added that corporate advertising is highly visible and that identifying the source of advertising may be required so people can evaluate the arguments they are hearing.
The rule: A state may not ban corporate spending on ballot-question advocacy; source identification may be required as a means of disclosure (footnote 32).
Sources: First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti, 435 U.S. 765 (LII)
- 1999Court
Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation (1999) and Watchtower v. Village of Stratton (2002): anonymity at the moment of persuasion
January 12, 1999 · Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation, 525 U.S. 182 (Jan. 12, 1999); Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York v. Village of Stratton, 536 U.S. 150 (June 17, 2002) · Vote: ACLF: Ginsburg for the Court (joined by Stevens, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter); Thomas concurred in the judgment; O'Connor (joined by Breyer) concurred in part and dissented in part; Rehnquist dissented. Watchtower: 8-1, Stevens for the Court; Rehnquist dissented.
Colorado required people circulating initiative petitions to wear badges showing their names; the Court struck that down, along with other circulator rules, because it forced identification at the very moment a circulator is asking a stranger to sign. But the same opinion approved of Colorado requiring ballot-measure sponsors to disclose who pays petition circulators and how much. Three years later the Court threw out an Ohio village ordinance that required anyone going door to door for a cause to first register by name with the mayor. The challengers were Jehovah's Witnesses, and the Court noted the rule would also reach anonymous political canvassers and supporters of unpopular causes.
The rule: Government may not force face-to-face advocates to identify themselves as a condition of speaking, but may require after-the-fact financial disclosure by ballot-measure sponsors.
Sources: Buckley v. ACLF, syllabus (LII); Watchtower v. Stratton, syllabus (LII)
- 2000Law
Congress closes the 'stealth PAC' gap: disclosure for Section 527 groups
July 1, 2000 · Pub. L. 106-230, 114 Stat. 477 (H.R. 4762), approved July 1, 2000 · Vote: Passed the House June 27, 2000 and the Senate June 29, 2000 (per the law's legislative-history note); signed by President Clinton.
Before this law, political organizations organized under Section 527 of the tax code that were not registered with the FEC as political committees did not have to disclose their donors or spending. The law required them to notify the IRS of their existence and to file periodic public reports. The reports must list each expenditure once payments to a person reach $500 in a year and the name, address, occupation and employer of each contributor who gives $200 or more in a year.
The rule: 527 organizations must register with the IRS and publicly report contributors of $200+ and expenditures of $500+.
Sources: Public Law 106-230 (GovInfo). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2003Court
McCain-Feingold's 'electioneering communication' disclosure and McConnell v. FEC
December 10, 2003 · Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002, Pub. L. 107-155 (signed Mar. 27, 2002), secs. 201, 311; McConnell v. FEC, 540 U.S. 93 (Dec. 10, 2003) · Vote: On the core sec. 201 donor-disclosure rule: 8-1 (only Thomas would have struck it). Stevens and O'Connor wrote for the Court on Title II, joined by Souter, Ginsburg and Breyer; Kennedy, joined by Rehnquist and Scalia, agreed the disclosure was valid except for the advance-disclosure piece.
Before 2002, groups could run broadcast ads attacking or praising a candidate just before an election and avoid all disclosure by leaving out words like 'vote for.' McCain-Feingold created a bright-line category, the electioneering communication: a broadcast, cable or satellite ad that names a federal candidate, airs within 30 days of a primary or 60 days of a general election, and is aimed at that candidate's electorate. Anyone spending more than $10,000 a year on such ads must file a report identifying contributors of $1,000 or more. In McConnell the Court upheld that requirement against a facial challenge, relying on Buckley's three interests, while leaving room for a group to seek an exemption by showing a reasonable probability of reprisals.
The rule: Disclosure may constitutionally reach beyond 'magic words' express advocacy to candidate-naming broadcast ads run close to an election.
Sources: McConnell v. FEC, syllabus (LII); McConnell, opinion of Kennedy, J. (agreeing sec. 201 disclosure is valid 'with one exception'); McConnell, opinion of Thomas, J. (would hold sec. 201 disclosure unconstitutional); FEC litigation summary, McConnell v. FEC; FEC legislation page (BCRA signing date)
- 2007Court
FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life: issue ads escape the corporate spending ban (but not, later, disclosure)
June 25, 2007 · FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life, Inc., 551 U.S. 449 (2007) · Vote: 5-4. Roberts announced the judgment (controlling opinion joined in full only by Alito); Scalia, Kennedy and Thomas concurred in the judgment; Souter dissented, joined by Stevens, Ginsburg and Breyer.
A nonprofit corporation wanted to run issue ads, during the pre-election blackout window, asking viewers to contact Wisconsin's senators about a pending legislative fight. The Court held the corporate-treasury ban could not be applied to them. An ad counts as the functional equivalent of express advocacy, the controlling opinion said, only if it is susceptible of no reasonable interpretation other than as an appeal to vote for or against a specific candidate. The case was about the spending ban, not disclosure.
The rule: The ban on corporate-funded electioneering communications is unconstitutional as applied to genuine issue ads. Three years later, Citizens United expressly refused to carry this limit over to disclosure.
Sources: FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life, syllabus (LII); Citizens United v. FEC, syllabus (rejecting a WRTL limit on disclosure)
- 2010Court
SpeechNow.org v. FEC: unlimited contributions to independent-spending groups, with full disclosure
March 26, 2010 · SpeechNow.org v. FEC, 599 F.3d 686 (D.C. Cir. 2010) (en banc) · Vote: 9-0. Chief Judge Sentelle for the court, joined by Ginsburg, Henderson, Rogers, Tatel, Garland, Brown, Griffith and Kavanaugh.
David Keating formed an unincorporated group that would take money only from individuals and spend it only on independent ads for or against federal candidates. Federal law capped what any person could give it at $5,000 a year. Two months after Citizens United, the full D.C. Circuit held that because independent expenditures do not corrupt, limits on contributions to groups that make only independent expenditures cannot stand. The same unanimous court held that SpeechNow still had to organize, register and report as a political committee, because the burden was modest and the public has an interest in knowing who is speaking about a candidate and who is funding that speech.
The rule: Contribution limits are unconstitutional as applied to independent-expenditure-only groups; political-committee registration, recordkeeping and donor reporting requirements remain valid.
Sources: SpeechNow.org v. FEC, en banc opinion (FEC copy); FEC litigation summary, SpeechNow.org v. FEC. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2010Agency
The FEC opens the door: advisory opinions that created super PACs, and Carey v. FEC's hybrid PACs
July 22, 2010 · FEC Advisory Opinions 2010-09 (Club for Growth) and 2010-11 (Commonsense Ten), both issued July 22, 2010; Carey v. FEC (D.D.C.), preliminary injunction June 14, 2011, stipulated order and consent judgment Aug. 19, 2011
Applying Citizens United and SpeechNow, the FEC told the Club for Growth that it could set up a committee making only independent expenditures and solicit unlimited individual contributions for it. The same day it told Commonsense Ten that such a committee could also take unlimited money from corporations, unions and other political committees. Those independent-expenditure-only committees became known as super PACs; they register with the FEC and report their contributors. In 2011, a traditional PAC, the National Defense PAC, won the right to keep two bank accounts, one taking limited contributions for candidate donations and one taking unlimited contributions for independent spending. The FEC then issued guidance on Oct. 6, 2011 letting other nonconnected committees do the same, creating the hybrid PAC.
The rule: Independent-expenditure-only committees may accept unlimited contributions from individuals, corporations and unions and must report them; a traditional PAC may add a separate unlimited 'non-contribution account.'
Sources: FEC, AO 2010-09 (Club for Growth); FEC Record, AO 2010-11 (Commonsense Ten); FEC litigation summary, Carey v. FEC; CRS Report R41542 (super PAC reporting; Carey); FEC Statement on Carey v. FEC (Oct. 6, 2011)
- 2014Court
ProtectMarriage.com v. Bowen: Prop 8 donors seek the harassment exemption and do not get it
May 20, 2014 · ProtectMarriage.com-Yes on 8 v. Bowen, 830 F. Supp. 2d 914 (E.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2011); 752 F.3d 827 (9th Cir. May 20, 2014) · Vote: Ninth Circuit panel: Milan Smith for the court, joined by Ikuta; Wallace dissented in part.
In January 2009 the Yes-on-8 committees sued to stop California from publishing their later-filed donor reports and to have existing records purged, pointing to the boycotts and threats. The district court refused an emergency injunction, so the names stayed public, and in November 2011 Judge Morrison England granted summary judgment to the state on every claim. On appeal the Ninth Circuit upheld the $100 disclosure threshold and post-election reporting on their face under exacting scrutiny. It did not decide whether the donors qualified for an exemption: because the names had been public for about five years, the court said it could no longer give effective relief, and a request to be excused from future reporting was not ripe.
The rule: California's ballot-measure disclosure rules are facially valid; the as-applied request for anonymity was dismissed as moot/unripe and the district court's ruling on that part was ordered vacated.
Sources: Willamette Law Online summary of 9th Cir. opinion (No. 11-17884); CBS Los Angeles / AP, May 20, 2014; Campaign Legal Center release on the Ninth Circuit ruling; Leagle, district court opinion header (date, judge, citation). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
2010–2018: the IRS and the Tea Party
From 2010 to 2012 the IRS screened applications for tax-exempt status by name, starting with “Tea Party”, “Patriots” and “9/12”, held many open for years and asked 27 groups for the names of their donors. The inspector general called the criteria inappropriate in 2013. A 2017 follow-up found the IRS had also used terms such as “Progressive” and “Occupy” going back to 2004, with far fewer confirmed cases. The IRS apologized and settled in 2017. No one was charged, and the investigations did not establish direction from the White House.
- 2010Agency
IRS Cincinnati unit screens applications by name: 'Tea Party', 'Patriots', '9/12'
TIGTA Ref. No. 2013-10-053, at 5-8 and App. VI-VII
Starting in early 2010 the IRS Determinations Unit in Cincinnati searched applications for tax-exempt status for the words Tea Party, and later Patriots and 9/12, and sent them to a team of specialists. A 'Be On the Look Out' spreadsheet first distributed in August 2010 listed Tea Party organizations; by June 2011 the working criteria also covered applicants concerned with government spending, debt or taxes, or critical of how the country was run. When the director of Exempt Organizations was briefed in June 2011 she ordered the criteria changed, and in July 2011 they were rewritten around political and lobbying activity. The specialists changed them back toward policy positions in January 2012 without executive approval; they were rewritten again in May 2012.
The rule: TIGTA found that selecting applications by name or policy position rather than by activity was inappropriate, and that the improper criteria stayed in place for more than 18 months.
Sources: TIGTA report page; TIGTA report PDF (archived copy)
- 2013Event
Lois Lerner discloses and apologizes for the name-based screening
May 10, 2013
On May 10, 2013, four days before the inspector general's report was released, the IRS director of Exempt Organizations, Lois Lerner, told an American Bar Association tax meeting that the IRS had used organization names to select advocacy cases. TIGTA records her words that this was incorrect, insensitive and inappropriate. The disclosure came after the IRS had seen the draft audit findings.
The rule: First public admission by the IRS.
Sources: TIGTA Ref. No. 2017-10-054, at 1 (recounting the May 10, 2013 remarks); S. Rept. 114-119, at 11 (ABA meeting, May 10, 2013)
- 2013Agency
TIGTA audit: 'Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review'
May 14, 2013 · Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, Ref. No. 2013-10-053 (May 14, 2013)
The inspector general reviewed all 298 applications the IRS had flagged as potential political cases as of May 31, 2012. Ninety-six had Tea Party (72), 9/12 (11) or Patriots (13) in their names; 202 did not; and in samples of other 501(c)(4) files, every application with those words had been sent to the specialists. As of December 17, 2012, of 296 cases with complete files, 108 had been approved, 28 withdrawn, none denied, and 160 were still open after 206 to 1,138 days; flagged cases averaged 574 days open against 238 days for comparable cases. The IRS sent follow-up questions to 170 organizations, and for 98 of them (58 percent) some of what was asked was later judged unnecessary. That included requests to 27 organizations for the names of donors, 13 of which had Tea Party, Patriots or 9/12 in their names; the IRS said it later destroyed donor lists it should not have requested.
The rule: Ineffective management let inappropriate criteria develop and persist for more than 18 months, caused substantial delays, and allowed unnecessary information requests. Nine recommendations.
Sources: TIGTA report page; TIGTA report PDF (archived copy). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2015Agency
Senate Finance Committee report on the IRS's handling of political advocacy applications
August 5, 2015 · S. Rept. 114-119 (Aug. 5, 2015)
After a two-year inquiry with more than 32 interviews and about 1.5 million pages of documents, the committee's Republican and Democratic staffs issued joint findings. They agreed that from 2010 to 2013 IRS management failed to control or direct the processing of these applications, that Lerner learned of the Tea Party applications in early 2010 and did not tell her superiors, and that seven successive attempts to resolve the backlog failed, leaving applicants waiting for years and facing burdensome questions. The joint text also says that most of the applications set aside were Tea Party and conservative groups but that some left-leaning applicants were flagged, placed on the lookout lists, and delayed too.
The rule: Joint finding: serious mismanagement and delay. The staffs could not agree on three things: whether political bias by IRS employees including Lerner affected the processing; whether the IRS used improper methods to screen progressive groups; and whether Treasury or White House officials were involved.
Sources: S. Rept. 114-119, part 1 (govinfo); Senate Finance Committee release with both leaders' statements
- 2015Agency
Justice Department closes its criminal investigation with no charges
October 23, 2015
In a letter to Congress on October 23, 2015, Assistant Attorney General Peter Kadzik said the department was closing the investigation it opened in May 2013 without charging Lerner or anyone else. He wrote that investigators found substantial evidence of mismanagement, poor judgment and institutional inertia, but no evidence that any IRS official acted from political, discriminatory, corrupt or other improper motives that would support a prosecution, and that no employee interviewed reported actions taken to harm Tea Party-type applicants. Republicans called the decision a free pass; Democrats said it confirmed there was no crime.
The rule: No prosecution. Mismanagement found; criminal intent not shown.
Sources: Roll Call, Oct. 23, 2015 (quoting the letter). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2017Agency
TIGTA follow-up: 'Review of Selected Criteria Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review'
September 28, 2017 · Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, Ref. No. 2017-10-054 (Sept. 28, 2017)
This audit gave a historical account of 17 other screening criteria, out of 259 the IRS may have used between 2004 and 2013, chosen mainly from suggestions by Republican and Democratic congressional staff. They included Progressive, Occupy, ACORN Successors, Emerge, Green Energy, Medical Marijuana and Healthcare Legislation, and also Border Patrol, Rally Patriots and We the People. From more than 900 files, TIGTA identified 181 political cases and 146 that were processed under a criterion or while it was in use: 83 it could confirm were handled because of the criterion and 63 it could not. Confirmed counts were small: 13 for ACORN Successors, 5 for Occupy, 5 for Emerge, 10 for Medical Marijuana, 16 for Healthcare Legislation, 8 for We the People, and 4 for Progressive, all four from 2005-06. Some of these waited years; the five Emerge cases averaged 1,023 days.
The rule: The IRS used name- and issue-based screening terms that reached groups across the spectrum, going back to 2004. TIGTA made no recommendations because the lists had been abolished.
Sources: TIGTA Ref. No. 2017-10-054 (PDF). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2017Court
Government settles Linchpins of Liberty and NorCal Tea Party Patriots suits; IRS apologizes
October 26, 2017 · Linchpins of Liberty v. United States, No. 1:13-cv-00777 (D.D.C.); NorCal Tea Party Patriots v. IRS, No. 1:13-cv-341 (S.D. Ohio)
On October 26, 2017 Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced settlements of two long-running suits. In Linchpins of Liberty, brought by 41 groups in Washington, the proposed consent order had the IRS admit that it used heightened scrutiny and inordinate delays and demanded unnecessary information, and express its 'sincere apology'; there was no money and each side bore its own fees. In the NorCal class action in Cincinnati, covering NorCal Tea Party Patriots and 427 other groups, the government agreed to pay $3.5 million. The Ohio court approved that settlement on August 8, 2018 and on August 17 approved $1.75 million of it, half the fund, to reimburse the organization that financed the litigation, plus $10,000 awards to class representatives.
The rule: Consent resolutions, not adjudicated findings. The IRS admitted the screening was wrong and apologized.
Sources: NPR, Oct. 27, 2017; S.D. Ohio order on fees, Aug. 17, 2018 (govinfo); Justice Department release (URL; blocked for automated fetch). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (6)
- 2013Agency
Treasury proposes, then abandons, rules defining 'candidate-related political activity' for 501(c)(4)s
November 29, 2013 · REG-134417-13, 78 Fed. Reg. 71535 (Nov. 29, 2013)
Responding to the inspector general's recommendation for clearer rules, Treasury and the IRS proposed on November 29, 2013 to define a category of candidate-related political activity that would not count as promoting social welfare for 501(c)(4) groups. The proposal swept in a good deal of voter-education and issue communication near elections and drew objections from groups on the left and the right. The agencies received a very large number of public comments and never finalized the rule.
The rule: Never adopted. Congress has blocked any such rule every year since December 2015.
Sources: Federal Register, proposed rule; Pub. L. 114-113, div. E, sec. 127 (first rider). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2014Event
Lerner invokes the Fifth Amendment, retires, and is held in contempt by the House
May 7, 2014 · H. Res. 574, 113th Cong.; House Roll Call 203 (May 7, 2014) · Vote: 231-187 (225 Republicans and 6 Democrats in favor; 187 Democrats against)
Called before the House Oversight Committee on May 22, 2013, Lerner made a statement denying wrongdoing and then declined to answer questions, citing the Fifth Amendment. She was placed on administrative leave and retired on September 23, 2013; a senior House Democrat said an internal review board had been about to propose her removal for neglect of duties. On May 7, 2014 the House voted 231 to 187 to hold her in contempt of Congress for refusing to testify.
The rule: Contempt citation referred to the U.S. Attorney, who did not prosecute.
Sources: Clerk of the House, Roll Call 203; Government Executive, Sept. 23, 2013; S. Rept. 114-119 (citing the May 22, 2013 hearing). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2014Event
The lost Lerner emails and the inspector general's recovery effort
June 13, 2014 · S. Rept. 114-119, sec. II(C); TIGTA Report of Investigation (June 30, 2015)
On June 13, 2014 the IRS told the Senate Finance Committee that Lerner's hard drive had crashed in June 2011 and that some of her email could not be produced. The inspector general then interviewed 118 witnesses and searched backup media. It estimated that as many as 23,000 to 24,000 messages might not have reached Congress, recovered about 1,007 that had not been produced, and found that in March 2014 IRS staff in West Virginia had erased 422 backup tapes believed to hold responsive email. It could not determine why the hard drive failed.
The rule: TIGTA found no evidence that any IRS employee was directed to destroy or hide information from Congress, the Justice Department or the inspector general. The Finance Committee nonetheless found that the IRS's failures impeded its inquiry and delayed it by more than a year.
Sources: S. Rept. 114-119, part 1 (govinfo); Senate Finance Committee release, Aug. 5, 2015
- 2014Court
IRS pays $50,000 after releasing the National Organization for Marriage's donor list
June 24, 2014 · National Organization for Marriage v. United States, No. 1:13-cv-1225 (E.D. Va.) (consent judgment June 2014)
An IRS clerk responding to a request for the National Organization for Marriage's public tax forms printed and sent an unredacted copy of its 2008 Schedule B, which lists donors and is confidential by law. The requester, a Boston activist, passed it to the Human Rights Campaign, NOM's main opponent on same-sex marriage, and donor names were published by the Huffington Post during the 2012 campaign. NOM sued in October 2013. On June 3, 2014 Judge James Cacheris ruled there was not enough evidence that the disclosure was willful; the government, which said the release was inadvertent, then agreed to pay $50,000.
The rule: The government conceded an unauthorized disclosure and paid actual damages. No finding that the leak was intentional or politically directed.
Sources: Government Executive, June 26, 2014. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2015Law
Appropriations rider freezes IRS rules on 501(c)(4) political activity, renewed through fiscal 2026
December 18, 2015 · Pub. L. 114-113, div. E, sec. 127 (Dec. 18, 2015); most recently Pub. L. 119-75, div. E, sec. 123 (Feb. 3, 2026), 140 Stat. 447-448
Beginning with the fiscal 2016 spending law, Congress has barred Treasury and the IRS from using any funds to issue, revise or finalize any regulation, revenue ruling or other general guidance on the standard for deciding whether an organization operates exclusively for social welfare under section 501(c)(4), naming the 2013 proposal. The rider also says the standard and definitions in effect on January 1, 2010 continue to apply. The same language is in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026, signed February 3, 2026, and applies during fiscal year 2026.
The rule: The IRS cannot write new general rules on how much political activity a 501(c)(4) may conduct. The pre-2010 facts-and-circumstances standard remains.
Sources: Pub. L. 119-75 (govinfo); Pub. L. 114-113 (govinfo). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2017Agency
Trump-era Justice Department declines to reopen the Lerner matter
September 8, 2017
On April 12, 2017 the Republican chairmen of the House Ways and Means Committee and its tax policy subcommittee asked Attorney General Jeff Sessions to take a fresh look at the committee's 2014 criminal referral of Lerner. On September 8, 2017 the department answered that it would not reopen the case. The chairmen called the decision a miscarriage of justice.
The rule: The earlier decision not to prosecute stood after review by a Republican-led Justice Department.
Sources: House Ways and Means Committee release, Sept. 8, 2017. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
2015–2026: Schedule B, leaks and new fights
The newest arguments are about whether government can be trusted to hold donor lists at all. California posted confidential donor schedules online by mistake; an IRS contractor took the tax data of more than 400,000 people. The Supreme Court tightened the test for demanding donor lists in 2021, Treasury stopped collecting most nonprofits' donor names in 2020, and states have moved in both directions at once.
- 2020Agency
T.D. 9898: final regulations end annual donor-name reporting for non-(c)(3) groups
May 28, 2020 · T.D. 9898, 85 Fed. Reg. 31959 (May 28, 2020); proposed at REG-102508-16, 84 Fed. Reg. 47447 (Sept. 10, 2019)
Treasury proposed the change by regulation on September 10, 2019, received 8,387 comments, and finalized it effective May 28, 2020. Exempt organizations other than 501(c)(3)s no longer report names and addresses of substantial contributors each year. Three things did not change: these groups still report the amount of each large contribution on Schedule B; they must keep donor names and addresses in their records and produce them if the IRS asks in an examination; and 501(c)(3) charities and section 527 political organizations still report names. Treasury said the IRS does not need the names each year to administer the tax law and that collecting them creates a risk of accidental release when returns are redacted for public inspection. Opponents, including attorneys general of 19 states and the District of Columbia, said the change would make it harder to detect foreign or other illegal money moving into elections through nonprofits and would cost states a source of information.
The rule: Annual reporting of donor names to the IRS is required only where the statute requires it: 501(c)(3)s, and 527 organizations.
Sources: Federal Register, final rule T.D. 9898; Federal Register, 2019 proposed rule
- 2021Event
ProPublica publishes 'The Secret IRS Files'
June 8, 2021
On June 8, 2021 ProPublica published the first of a long series of articles based on what it described as a vast trove of IRS data on thousands of the wealthiest Americans covering more than 15 years. The first story reported that several billionaires had paid no federal income tax in particular years and compared taxes paid with growth in wealth. The series eventually ran to more than 50 articles. ProPublica did not say how it obtained the data; the source was identified two years later.
The rule: The largest known unauthorized release of confidential IRS return information to the press.
Sources: ProPublica, June 8, 2021; Justice Department case page (50-plus articles)
- 2021Court
Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta: California cannot demand every charity's major-donor list
July 1, 2021 · Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta, 594 U.S. 595 (2021) (with Thomas More Law Center v. Bonta, No. 19-255); trial decision 182 F. Supp. 3d 1049 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 21, 2016) · Vote: 6-3. Roberts for the Court (Kavanaugh and Barrett in full; Alito and Gorsuch except Part II-B-1; Thomas except Parts II-B-1 and III-B). Sotomayor dissented, joined by Breyer and Kagan.
California required the roughly 60,000 charities renewing their state registration each year to file an unredacted copy of IRS Schedule B, which lists the names and addresses of their largest donors. The state promised to keep the forms confidential, and from 2010 began enforcing the rule with thousands of deficiency letters. At trial the Foundation showed that 1,778 confidential Schedule Bs had been posted on the Attorney General's public website, 38 of them found the day before trial, and its expert reached hundreds of thousands of confidential registry documents simply by changing a digit in a web address. The Supreme Court held the blanket demand unconstitutional for every charity. California, it said, rarely used the forms to start investigations and could get them by subpoena or audit letter when it needed them.
The rule: Compelled disclosure of affiliation must satisfy exacting scrutiny, which requires narrow tailoring to the government's interest even though not the least restrictive means. California's up-front collection failed that test and was facially invalid.
Sources: AFPF v. Bonta, all opinions (LII); AFPF v. Harris, trial court decision (C.D. Cal. 2016) (the 1,778 figure); ACLU release on its amicus brief with NAACP LDF, Knight Institute, Human Rights Campaign and PEN America (Mar. 2, 2021); Ninth Circuit, AFP v. Meyer (2026) (confirms the 594 U.S. 595 citation)
- 2022Law
Arizona Proposition 211, the Voters' Right to Know Act: tracing campaign money to its original source
November 8, 2022 · Arizona Proposition 211 (Nov. 8, 2022), A.R.S. secs. 16-971 to 16-979 · Vote: Approved 72.34% to 27.66% (1,736,496 to 664,111)
Arizona voters approved the country's most far-reaching state disclosure law by nearly three to one. Any person or group that spends more than $50,000 on campaign media in a statewide race, or more than $25,000 in other races, in an election cycle must publicly identify the original source of each contribution of more than $5,000 used for that spending, tracing the money back through any intermediaries to the people or businesses that earned it. The spender must keep records on donors of more than $2,500, and must give donors written notice and a 21-day chance to opt out of having their money used for campaign media. The Citizens Clean Elections Commission enforces it.
The rule: Original-source disclosure for donors over $5,000 to big campaign-media spenders; donors may opt out and keep their money (and names) out of campaign spending.
Sources: Ballotpedia, Arizona Proposition 211 (2022) (certified totals; 21-day opt-out); Ninth Circuit, Americans for Prosperity v. Meyer (Sept. 30, 2026) (statutory description and thresholds)
- 2024Court
IRS contractor Charles Littlejohn convicted and sentenced to five years for the leaks
January 29, 2024 · United States v. Littlejohn, No. 1:23-cr-343 (D.D.C.)
Charles Littlejohn, a contractor working at the IRS, took the tax returns of a high-ranking public official, widely reported to be Donald Trump, and gave them to one news organization between about August and October 2019; it published in September 2020. In July and August 2020 he took return information on thousands of the nation's wealthiest people and in November 2020 gave it to a second news organization. He evaded controls meant to detect large downloads and later destroyed evidence. He was charged on September 29, 2023 with one count of unauthorized disclosure of tax return information, pleaded guilty in October 2023, and on January 29, 2024 Judge Ana Reyes sentenced him to five years in prison, the statutory maximum.
The rule: Guilty plea to one felony count; maximum sentence imposed.
Sources: Justice Department case page, United States v. Charles Littlejohn; IRS statement to affected taxpayers
- 2025Law
State donor-privacy laws: the Personal Privacy Protection Act in 22 states
July 29, 2025 · Model 'Personal Privacy Protection Act' (PPPA); e.g., Nevada A.B. 197 (2025); North Carolina S.B. 416, Session Law 2025-79 · Vote: North Carolina: enacted July 29, 2025 by veto override (Senate 30-19, House 74-46). Nevada: passed with one dissenting vote, signed May 29, 2025.
Beginning with Arizona in 2018, states have passed laws that bar state and local agencies from demanding, collecting or releasing lists of a nonprofit's members, volunteers and donors, with exceptions for court orders and existing campaign-finance reporting. People United for Privacy Foundation, the laws' main promoter, counted 22 states as of September 2026; North Carolina was the most recent, becoming the 22nd when legislators overrode Governor Josh Stein's veto. Nevada's 2025 law was backed by groups as different as the state ACLU, Americans for Prosperity, Nevada Right to Life and Planned Parenthood Votes Nevada. No new state adopted the model in 2026, though three states passed laws redacting donors' home addresses from campaign reports and three raised reporting thresholds.
The rule: In PPPA states, government agencies generally may not require nonprofits to hand over supporter lists or publish them, and officials who do can be sued.
Sources: People United for Privacy Foundation, 2026 Post-Session Report (count as of Sept. 2026); People United for Privacy, North Carolina enactment (July 29, 2025); Reason, June 2, 2025 (Nevada as 21st state); Religion Unplugged, May 2024 (Georgia as 19th state); Ballotpedia News, donor privacy digest, June 2023. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2025Agency
NSPM-7 directs the IRS and Treasury to go after funders of 'domestic terrorism and organized political violence'
September 25, 2025 · National Security Presidential Memorandum 7 (Sept. 25, 2025)
Issued two weeks after the assassination of Charlie Kirk, this presidential memorandum orders a strategy to investigate not only people who commit political violence but the organizations and funding sources behind them, including institutional and individual funders. It tells the Treasury Secretary to trace and disrupt financial networks and tells the IRS commissioner to ensure that no tax-exempt entity is directly or indirectly financing political violence or domestic terrorism and to refer such organizations and their officers to the Justice Department. It describes the threat as coming from self-described anti-fascist movements and lists traits such as anti-Americanism, anti-capitalism and anti-Christianity. The Attorney General issued an implementing memo on December 4, 2025, and in March 2026 IRS Criminal Investigation confirmed it was working with the FBI under the directive.
The rule: An executive directive. It creates no new crime and does not change the standards for tax exemption.
Sources: White House, text of the memorandum; Fox News, March 20, 2026 (IRS-CI confirmation). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
Judge Barker refuses the Johnson Amendment consent judgment and dismisses the case
March 31, 2026 · National Religious Broadcasters v. Bessent, No. 6:24-cv-00311, Doc. 106 (opinion and order) and Doc. 107 (final judgment) (E.D. Tex. Mar. 31, 2026)
Americans United for Separation of Church and State asked to intervene to defend the law. Judge J. Campbell Barker heard argument on November 25, 2025 and on December 12, 2025 denied intervention but let the group file as a friend of the court. On March 31, 2026 he declined to enter the consent judgment and dismissed the whole case without prejudice for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. He held that the Tax Anti-Injunction Act and the tax exception in the Declaratory Judgment Act bar a court from enjoining or declaring rights about a condition of tax-exempt status before the IRS acts, and that the government's agreement to an injunction cannot create jurisdiction Congress withheld. He pointed to a refund suit or a declaratory action under 26 U.S.C. 7428 as the routes Congress provided.
The rule: No consent judgment. Dismissed without prejudice on jurisdictional grounds. The court did not decide whether the Johnson Amendment is constitutional and expressly did not decide standing.
Sources: Opinion and order, Doc. 106; District court docket (CourtListener); The NonProfit Times, April 1, 2026
- 2026Court
First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Davenport: nonprofits can fight a donor subpoena in federal court
April 29, 2026 · First Choice Women's Resource Centers, Inc. v. Davenport, No. 24-781 (U.S. Apr. 29, 2026) · Vote: 9-0. Gorsuch for a unanimous Court; reversed and remanded.
New Jersey's Attorney General, investigating a network of pro-life pregnancy centers for allegedly misleading fundraising, issued a subpoena that sought information identifying its donors. The nonprofit sued in federal court and the lower courts turned it away. The Supreme Court unanimously reversed, holding that the organization had shown a present injury to its First Amendment associational rights and could bring its challenge in federal court.
The rule: A state demand for a nonprofit's donor identities inflicts a First Amendment injury that can be challenged in federal court without first litigating in state court. The Court did not decide whether the subpoena is valid.
Sources: Supreme Court docket No. 24-781; People United for Privacy summary (advocacy source). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
More from these years (24)
- 2017Agency
Executive Order 13798, 'Promoting Free Speech and Religious Liberty'
May 4, 2017 · Exec. Order No. 13798, 82 Fed. Reg. 21675 (May 9, 2017)
President Trump signed this order on May 4, 2017. It told the Treasury Department, to the extent the law allows, not to take adverse action against individuals, houses of worship or other religious organizations for speaking about moral or political issues from a religious perspective, where similar speech has not ordinarily been treated as campaign intervention. It did not change the statute. When the order was challenged in court, the government said the Johnson Amendment still controlled and described the order as telling the government not to treat religious groups worse than others.
The rule: An instruction on enforcement discretion. The statute was untouched and remains in force.
Sources: Federal Register, EO 13798; CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447
- 2018Agency
Rev. Proc. 2018-38: IRS stops collecting donor names from most non-charity nonprofits
July 16, 2018 · Rev. Proc. 2018-38, 2018-31 I.R.B. 280
In July 2018 the IRS announced that tax-exempt organizations other than 501(c)(3)s, such as 501(c)(4) advocacy groups, 501(c)(5) unions and 501(c)(6) trade associations, would no longer have to list the names and addresses of contributors on Schedule B of their annual Form 990. They would still have to keep that information in their books and give it to the IRS on request. Because the statute itself requires 501(c)(3) charities to report substantial contributors, charities were not affected.
The rule: Names and addresses of donors no longer reported annually by non-(c)(3) groups; record-keeping duty retained.
Sources: Rev. Proc. 2018-38 (irs.gov); T.D. 9898 preamble (procedural history)
- 2018Court
CREW v. FEC (Crossroads GPS): a narrow FEC donor-disclosure rule is struck down
August 3, 2018 · CREW v. FEC, 316 F. Supp. 3d 349 (D.D.C. Aug. 3, 2018) (Howell, C.J.); stay denied sub nom. Crossroads GPS v. CREW, No. 18A274 (U.S. Sept. 18, 2018); affirmed (D.C. Cir. Aug. 21, 2020) · Vote: District court: single judge. Supreme Court: application denied by the full Court without recorded dissent, vacating a temporary stay Chief Justice Roberts had entered Sept. 15, 2018. D.C. Circuit: affirmed.
An FEC regulation had required groups that are not political committees to name only donors who gave for the purpose of furthering the specific independent expenditure being reported. A watchdog group's complaint against Crossroads GPS, a 501(c)(4), led Chief Judge Beryl Howell to hold that the rule was narrower than the statute and to vacate it. The statute, she held, requires such a spender to identify everyone who gave it more than $200 in a year in contributions, and separately to flag those who gave to further an independent expenditure. The Supreme Court declined to block the ruling seven weeks before the 2018 election, and the D.C. Circuit affirmed in 2020, saying the rule conflicted with the statute twice over.
The rule: 11 C.F.R. 109.10(e)(1)(vi) is invalid. Under FEC guidance of Oct. 4, 2018, a non-committee that makes independent expenditures of more than $250 in a year must report each donor of more than $200 whose contributions were earmarked for political purposes, and identify those who gave to further any independent expenditure. The rule applies to independent expenditures made on or after Sept. 18, 2018.
Sources: FEC litigation page, CREW v. FEC (16-0259); FEC guidance of Oct. 4, 2018; FEC summary of D.C. Circuit affirmance (Aug. 21, 2020); Supreme Court docket No. 18A274. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2019Court
Bullock v. IRS: court sets aside the Schedule B change for skipping notice and comment
July 30, 2019 · Bullock v. IRS, No. 4:18-cv-00103-BMM (D. Mont. July 30, 2019), reported at 401 F. Supp. 3d 1144
Montana Governor Steve Bullock and the State of New Jersey sued, saying the IRS had changed a regulation without the public notice-and-comment process the Administrative Procedure Act requires. Judge Brian Morris found the states had standing, in part because New Jersey had used the donor information it received from the IRS and had to spend resources to replace it. On July 30, 2019 he granted summary judgment to the states and set the revenue procedure aside.
The rule: The IRS must use notice-and-comment rulemaking to make this change. The court did not rule on whether the change was good policy or within the IRS's power.
Sources: Order, D. Mont., July 30, 2019 (govinfo). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2021Court
After Bonta: lower courts mostly keep upholding election-spending disclosure
September 14, 2021 · Gaspee Project v. Mederos, 13 F.4th 79 (1st Cir. Sept. 14, 2021), cert. denied Apr. 25, 2022; No on E v. Chiu, 85 F.4th 493 (9th Cir. Mar. 8, 2023, amended Oct. 26, 2023), cert. denied Oct. 7, 2024; Wyoming Gun Owners v. Gray, Nos. 22-8019 and 22-8021 (10th Cir. Oct. 11, 2023) · Vote: Gaspee: unanimous panel (Selya). No on E: panel affirmed; rehearing en banc denied over a dissent. Wyoming Gun Owners: opinion by Tymkovich.
Ten weeks after Bonta, the First Circuit upheld Rhode Island's law requiring groups that spend on independent expenditures and electioneering communications to report donors and carry on-ad disclaimers, holding that such rules get exacting rather than strict scrutiny. The Ninth Circuit then refused to block a San Francisco rule requiring ballot-measure ads to name not only a committee's top donors but those donors' own top donors. The Supreme Court declined to hear either case. The Tenth Circuit went the other way on narrower grounds: after Wyoming fined a gun-rights group $500 for refusing to name donors behind a 2020 primary radio ad, the court held the state's regime was not narrowly tailored as applied to the group and that part of the statute was unconstitutionally vague.
The rule: Bonta's narrow-tailoring requirement applies to election disclosure laws, but most such laws have survived it; poorly drafted ones that cannot tell a group which donors to report can fail as applied.
Sources: Supreme Court docket No. 21-890 (Gaspee Project v. Mederos); Supreme Court docket No. 23-926 (No on E v. Chiu); Colorado Bar summary, Wyoming Gun Owners v. Gray. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2022Law
DISCLOSE Act, later attempts: 2012, the For the People Act, 2022, and the 2026 reintroduction
September 22, 2022 · S. 3369 (112th Cong.); H.R. 1 (116th and 117th Cong.) and S. 2093 (117th); S. 4822 (117th); S. 3991, DISCLOSE Act of 2026 (119th) · Vote: S. 3369 cloture: 51-44 (July 16, 2012) and 53-45 (July 17, 2012). H.R. 1 passed the House 234-193 (Mar. 8, 2019) and 220-210 (Mar. 3, 2021). S. 2093 cloture: 50-50 (June 22, 2021). S. 4822 cloture: 49-49 (Sept. 22, 2022). All Senate votes needed 60.
A new version of the DISCLOSE Act failed twice in two days in July 2012. Democrats then folded its text into the For the People Act, which passed the House in 2019 and 2021 and was stopped in the Senate on a 50-50 vote. A stand-alone version failed again 49-49 in September 2022. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse and Representative Chris Pappas reintroduced it on March 4, 2026 as S. 3991; the sponsors' summary says groups spending more than $10,000 on elections or judicial nominations would have to disclose donors of more than $10,000, with rules to trace money passed between organizations. It has been referred to committee. No Republican senator voted to advance any version in 2012, 2021 or 2022.
The rule: Never enacted. Each Senate attempt had majority or tie support but fell short of the 60-vote cloture threshold.
Sources: Senate vote 179, 112th Cong. 2nd Sess. (July 16, 2012); Senate vote 180, 112th Cong. 2nd Sess. (July 17, 2012); House Clerk roll call 118 (Mar. 8, 2019); House Clerk roll call 62 (Mar. 3, 2021); Senate vote 246, 117th Cong. 1st Sess. (June 22, 2021); Senate vote 346, 117th Cong. 2nd Sess. (Sept. 22, 2022); Sen. Whitehouse release, Mar. 4, 2026 (reintroduction). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2023Event
D.C. Attorney General inquiries into Leonard Leo-linked nonprofits and Arabella AdvisorsNot confirmed
In 2023 the District of Columbia Attorney General, a Democrat, was reported to be investigating nonprofits associated with conservative activist Leonard Leo following a complaint by a liberal watchdog group. After criticism that he was ignoring comparable groups on the left, his office subpoenaed Arabella Advisors and nonprofits it manages. On April 9, 2024 the Washington Examiner reported, citing a lawyer for the Arabella-managed funds, that the Arabella investigation had ended.
The rule: No public enforcement action against either network was found.
Sources: Washington Examiner, April 9, 2024. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2024Law
2024 House bills on foreign money in tax-exempt groups (not enacted)
May 15, 2024
On May 15, 2024 the Ways and Means Committee marked up a package of bills on tax-exempt organizations. One would have required exempt organizations to report grants to foreign entities; one would have required groups receiving foreign donations to disclose aggregate data on amount, frequency and source country, while the chairman said it preserved donor privacy for Americans; one would have penalized exempt groups that take foreign contributions and then give to political committees; and one would have doubled the maximum prison term for unauthorized disclosure of tax information to ten years, in response to the Littlejohn case. The chairman cited a Swiss national's donations to groups in the Arabella Advisors network as the leading example of foreign money reaching political committees through nonprofits.
The rule: Committee action only. I found no evidence any of these became law.
Sources: Chairman Smith's opening statement, May 15, 2024. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2024Court
IRS publicly apologizes to Ken Griffin and other leak victims
June 25, 2024 · Griffin v. IRS, No. 22-cv-24023 (S.D. Fla.)
Hedge fund founder Ken Griffin, whose returns appeared in ProPublica's reporting, sued the IRS for failing to safeguard his data. On June 25, 2024 the case ended in a settlement whose public component was an IRS statement apologizing to Griffin and to the thousands of other Americans whose information was leaked, and acknowledging that the agency failed to prevent the contractor's conduct. Griffin received no money, according to reporting at the time.
The rule: Voluntary settlement with a public apology; no damages reported.
Sources: Bloomberg News via Accounting Today, June 25, 2024. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2024Law
Maine Question 1: voters cap contributions to super PACs, setting up a test of SpeechNow
November 5, 2024 · Maine Question 1 (Nov. 5, 2024); Dinner Table Action v. Schneider (D. Me. July 2025), appeal pending (1st Cir.) · Vote: Approved 74.91% to 25.09% (600,191 to 201,034)
Maine voters limited contributions to political action committees that make independent expenditures to $5,000 a year, a direct challenge to the reasoning of SpeechNow, and added donor-disclosure rules. Two Maine PACs sued in December 2024 and the state agreed not to enforce the law while the case was heard. In July 2025 a federal magistrate judge permanently enjoined it as unconstitutional on its face. Maine appealed, and the First Circuit heard argument on July 29, 2026. Supporters of the measure have said openly that they hope to get the question to the Supreme Court, which has never ruled on whether contributions to super PACs can be limited.
The rule: Enjoined; not in effect. No First Circuit decision was found as of November 19, 2026.
Sources: Ballotpedia, Maine Question 1 (2024); Brennan Center, Dinner Table Action v. Schneider. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2025Agency
IRS agrees to give immigration authorities taxpayer addresses; courts split
Centro de Trabajadores Unidos v. Bessent (D.C. Cir. Feb. 24, 2026); Center for Taxpayer Rights v. IRS (D.D.C. Nov. 21, 2025; aff'd D.C. Cir. Sept. 8, 2026); Community Economic Development Center v. Bessent (D. Mass.)
In 2025 the IRS and Immigration and Customs Enforcement signed a memorandum of understanding for sharing taxpayer information under the criminal-investigation exception in section 6103. ICE asked for last known addresses for about 1.28 million people, and the IRS returned roughly 47,000 matches. On February 24, 2026 the D.C. Circuit refused to block the agreement on its face, reading the statute to allow address disclosure on a proper request. But a district judge enjoined the way the exchange was actually run on November 21, 2025, and the D.C. Circuit affirmed that injunction on September 8, 2026, finding the procedure likely unlawful because ICE was not required to supply each taxpayer's address and the data was not limited to officers personally working the cases. A Massachusetts judge separately barred ICE and Homeland Security from using the data on February 5, 2026; the government's appeal was set for argument in the First Circuit on October 7, 2026.
The rule: The agreement survives on paper; the bulk exchange as implemented is enjoined. The IRS admitted in February 2026 that it had released addresses on incomplete matching information.
Sources: CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11413 (updated Sept. 17, 2026); Same, EveryCRSReport copy (fetched)
- 2025Event
IRS tells Congress the leak affected 405,427 taxpayers, not 70,000
The IRS first notified roughly 70,000 taxpayers that their information was in the stolen data. In February 2025 the acting IRS commissioner wrote to House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan that the disclosures affected 405,427 taxpayers, 89 percent of them business entities, and that notices had been mailed to all of them. The committee released the letter on February 25, 2025. The IRS has said it does not know the full scope of what was disclosed for each taxpayer and has seen no sign the data went beyond the two news organizations or was used for identity theft.
The rule: The scale was about six times what was first disclosed.
Sources: National Review, Feb. 25, 2025 (reporting the IRS letter); IRS statement to affected taxpayers. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2025Law
Free Speech Fairness Act reintroduced (not enacted)
March 31, 2025 · H.R. 2501, 119th Cong. (introduced Mar. 31, 2025)
Rep. Mark Harris of North Carolina and co-sponsors introduced this bill on March 31, 2025; it was referred to the House Ways and Means Committee. It would let charities make statements about campaigns if made in the ordinary course of carrying out their exempt purpose. CRS describes earlier versions as an exception for campaign activity of minimal cost in the organization's regular activities, and notes the bill has been introduced in every Congress since the 114th. A similar provision was in a 2017 House tax bill but was dropped before enactment.
The rule: Not law. No committee or floor action found as of November 2026.
Sources: H.R. 2501 as introduced (govinfo); CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2025Event
Threats to Harvard's tax exemption, and proposed IRS rules on discrimination by schools
April 16, 2025
After Harvard rejected a list of federal demands in April 2025, President Trump said the university should perhaps lose its exemption, and on April 16, 2025 CNN reported, citing two unnamed sources, that the IRS was preparing to revoke it. A year later Harvard's own magazine reported there was no evidence the IRS ever took steps to do so. On September 3, 2026 Treasury and the IRS proposed regulations that would treat all racial discrimination by private educational institutions as contrary to fundamental public policy, building on the Supreme Court's Bob Jones University decision, which could put exemptions at risk for schools found to discriminate in admissions or programs.
The rule: No revocation. The 2026 rules are proposed, not final, and by their terms would apply to thousands of institutions rather than to Harvard alone.
Sources: The Harvard Crimson, April 16, 2025; Harvard Magazine, April 10, 2026; The Harvard Crimson, Sept. 3, 2026
- 2025Court
National Religious Broadcasters v. Long: IRS joins plaintiffs in asking for a consent judgment
July 7, 2025 · National Religious Broadcasters v. Long (now v. Bessent), No. 6:24-cv-00311-JCB (E.D. Tex.), Doc. 35 (joint motion filed July 7, 2025)
National Religious Broadcasters, Intercessors for America, Sand Springs Church and First Baptist Church Waskom sued the IRS and its commissioner on August 28, 2024, asking a federal court in the Eastern District of Texas to declare the Johnson Amendment unconstitutional. The government first moved to dismiss. After the change of administration the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on February 21, 2025, and on July 7, 2025 the IRS joined them in a motion for a consent judgment. In that filing the IRS said that when a house of worship, in good faith, speaks to its own congregation through its customary channels on matters of faith in connection with religious services, including about candidates, it is not participating or intervening in a campaign, and compared it to a family discussion. The proposed order would have barred the IRS from enforcing the amendment against the two plaintiff churches for that kind of speech.
The rule: A litigating position and a proposed order, not a ruling. The court never entered it.
Sources: Joint motion for entry of consent judgment, Doc. 35; District court docket (CourtListener); CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447
- 2026Event
House Ways and Means Republicans refer nonprofits to the IRS for revocation
January 20, 2026
Since 2024 the Republican majority of the House Ways and Means Committee has sent the IRS letters naming specific organizations and asking it to investigate and consider revoking their exemptions, mostly groups it accuses of ties to designated terrorist organizations or foreign influence. A January 20, 2026 release said the committee's investigation had by then produced referrals of 11 nonprofits. On September 28, 2026 every Republican member joined a referral of the Middle East Children's Alliance, and the release said the chairman had subpoenaed three organizations linked to financier Neville Roy Singham in July 2026 over foreign-linked funding.
The rule: Congressional requests. The IRS decides independently and its examinations are confidential, so outcomes are generally not public.
Sources: Ways and Means release, Jan. 20, 2026; Ways and Means release, Sept. 28, 2026
- 2026Agency
Treasury and IRS announce plans for Johnson Amendment guidance for houses of worship
April 3, 2026 · Treasury press release sb0432 (Apr. 3, 2026)
Three days after the dismissal, Treasury and the IRS said they would develop additional guidance on how the Johnson Amendment applies to religious organizations, including communications made in the context of religious services. The release repeated the government's view that bona fide internal communications between a house of worship and its congregation, through customary channels on matters of faith, are not the campaign intervention the law prohibits. It said timing would be decided later in 2026 after talking with stakeholders. In searches on November 19, 2026 I found no notice, revenue ruling or proposed regulation actually issued.
The rule: An announcement of intent. A press release does not change the law or bind the IRS the way published guidance would.
Sources: Treasury press release; CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
President Trump's $10 billion suit against the IRS over the leak: dismissed, then condemned by the judge
May 18, 2026 · Trump v. Internal Revenue Service (S.D. Fla., filed Jan. 2026; Judge Kathleen Williams); appeal pending, 11th Cir.
In late January 2026 President Trump, his two eldest sons and the Trump Organization sued the IRS and Treasury in Miami for $10 billion over the Littlejohn leak. Judge Kathleen Williams asked whether a real dispute could exist when the plaintiff directs the defendant agencies. Two days before answers were due, on May 18, 2026, the plaintiffs dismissed the suit with prejudice in exchange for the Justice Department creating a $1.776 billion fund for people claiming to be victims of government 'weaponization'. After 35 former federal judges asked her to look into the deal, Judge Williams issued a 56-page ruling on July 13, 2026 finding the suit had been filed for an improper purpose and in bad faith, forbidding the parties from invoking the arrangement as a court-approved settlement, and sanctioning two of Trump's lawyers. On September 29, 2026 the Eleventh Circuit refused to pause the sanctions and called the appeal premature.
The rule: No adjudication that the IRS owed Trump anything. The district court found the parties were not genuinely adverse. Whether to formally reopen the case and what fees are owed remained undecided as of the latest reports.
Sources: CNBC, May 18, 2026; NPR, July 14, 2026; CNBC, Sept. 29, 2026; NBC News, April 2026 (suit and settlement talks). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
Young America's Foundation v. IRS: constitutional challenge to Schedule B for charities
July 13, 2026 · Young America's Foundation v. Internal Revenue Service, No. 1:26-cv-02449 (D.D.C., filed July 13, 2026)
Young America's Foundation, a conservative 501(c)(3), sued the IRS and Treasury on July 13, 2026, represented by the National Taxpayers Union Foundation. It asks the court to hold that the statute requiring charities to report substantial donors on Schedule B, 26 U.S.C. 6033(b)(5), violates the First Amendment, relying on the Supreme Court's 2021 decision in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta. The group says its returns were among those Littlejohn accessed and that the IRS makes little use of the donor names it collects.
The rule: Pending. No ruling as of the plaintiff's case page.
Sources: National Taxpayers Union Foundation case page; NTUF commentary on the Littlejohn appeal. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
D.C. Circuit upholds Littlejohn's five-year sentence
July 17, 2026 · United States v. Littlejohn, No. 24-3019 (D.C. Cir. July 17, 2026) · Vote: 3-0 (Walker, joined by Rao and Rogers)
Littlejohn appealed only his sentence, arguing that the judge had decided on the maximum before hearing from him, pointing to off-the-record conferences and an unfiled letter from 25 House members urging the maximum. On July 17, 2026 a unanimous panel rejected the challenge. Judge Justin Walker wrote that those communications should have been on the record but did not show a closed mind, and that the sentence reasonably reflected the number of victims and the aim of influencing an election and tax policy.
The rule: Sentence affirmed.
Sources: Courthouse News Service, July 17, 2026. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Event
Senators ask whether Treasury is planning to revoke exemptions of left-leaning groups before the midtermsNot confirmed
September 4, 2026
On September 4, 2026 Senators Raphael Warnock and Ron Wyden wrote to the Treasury Secretary and the IRS chief executive about a New York Post report of August 27, 2026. According to the letter, the report said Treasury officials were reviewing the tax-exempt status of organizations including the Open Society Foundations, the Southern Poverty Law Center and the Council on American-Islamic Relations, and drafting a blueprint for possible revocations with the aim of completing much of it before the November 2026 elections. The senators cited section 7217, asked for documents, and noted that the IRS chief had testified earlier in the year that presidential statements about opponents have no influence on the agency.
The rule: An inquiry by minority-party senators based on a press report. No revocation of any of the named groups has been confirmed.
Sources: Sen. Warnock release with letter text, Sept. 4, 2026. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
Proposition 211 in court: upheld on its face by Arizona's Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit, with one claim still alive
September 30, 2026 · Center for Arizona Policy v. Arizona Secretary of State, No. CV-24-0295-PR (Ariz. June 29, 2026); Americans for Prosperity v. Meyer, No. 24-2933 (9th Cir. Sept. 30, 2026), affirming D. Ariz. No. 2:23-cv-00470-ROS (Mar. 20, 2024); Montenegro (formerly Toma) v. Fontes, No. CV-24-0166-PR (Ariz. Sept. 2025) · Vote: Arizona Supreme Court (June 29, 2026): 4-3; Chief Justice Timmer, joined by Beene, Montgomery and retired Justice Berch (sitting for recused Justice Cruz); King, joined by Lopez and Bolick, concurred in part and dissented in part. Ninth Circuit: 2-1; Sanchez, joined by Rawlinson; Bumatay dissented.
Three sets of challengers have attacked the law. In state court, two conservative nonprofits and two anonymous donors argued it violates the Arizona Constitution's free-speech and private-affairs clauses; the Arizona Supreme Court rejected that broad attack, holding that donations used to fund campaign media are not 'private affairs,' but revived the plaintiffs' claim that disclosure would chill their own giving because of threats and harassment and sent it back for trial. In federal court, Americans for Prosperity lost at the Ninth Circuit, which found the burdens modest and the law narrowly tailored to voters' interest in knowing the true sources of campaign spending; the dissent grounded a right to anonymous political speech in founding-era practice. Separately, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled in September 2025 that Republican legislative leaders have standing to argue the law unlawfully hands lawmaking power to the Clean Elections Commission, and returned that case to the trial court.
The rule: As of November 19, 2026 the law is in force. Facial challenges have failed in both court systems; an as-applied chilled-speech claim (state court) and a separation-of-powers claim (state court) remain pending in Maricopa County Superior Court; further review of the Ninth Circuit ruling is possible.
Sources: Arizona Supreme Court news release, June 29, 2026; KJZZ, June 29, 2026; Ninth Circuit opinion, Americans for Prosperity v. Meyer; KJZZ, Sept. 29, 2025 (legislative leaders' standing); Campaign Legal Center release, June 29, 2026 (lower-court history); People United for Privacy on the Ninth Circuit ruling. Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Law
November 2026: Michigan and Montana voters approve new limits and disclosure on political spendingNot confirmed
November 3, 2026 · Michigan Proposal 2 (2026); Montana Initiative 194 (2026) · Vote: Michigan Proposal 2: approved, about 81% to 19% (3,531,044 to 812,419). Montana I-194: approved, about 66% to 34% (307,039 to 161,247).
Michigan's Proposal 2 bars regulated utilities and large state contractors, and people tied to them, from making certain campaign contributions, and extends campaign-finance reporting and disclaimer rules to public communications about candidates or ballot questions even when they do not expressly urge a vote. Montana's I-194 prohibits 'artificial persons,' as the measure defines them, from contributing to candidate campaigns, ballot-measure campaigns or political parties, an attempt to reach corporate political spending through state corporation law rather than campaign-finance law. Donor-privacy groups campaigned against both; People United for Privacy argued the Michigan measure would make a group that spends as little as $500 on covered communications a 'committee' required to publish its donors. Court challenges to both are widely expected.
The rule: Both measures passed. Their effect on nonprofit donor disclosure will depend on implementation and litigation.
Sources: Ballotpedia, Michigan 2026 ballot measures; Ballotpedia, Montana 2026 ballot measures; People United for Privacy analysis of Michigan Proposal 2 (opponent's characterization). Core facts confirmed; some secondary details were not.
- 2026Court
Status in November 2026: appeal fully briefed at the Fifth Circuit, no decision
November 6, 2026 · National Religious Broadcasters v. Bessent, No. 26-40237 (5th Cir.)
The plaintiffs filed a notice of appeal on April 22, 2026 and the Fifth Circuit docketed the case on April 28, 2026. The government, although the appellee, filed a brief on September 21, 2026 that sided with the churches and asked the court to reverse on the ground that the Anti-Injunction Act does not block the consent agreement. Americans United, Public Citizen with Campaign Legal Center, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation filed briefs defending the dismissal in late September; several religious-liberty and conservative groups filed on the other side. The appellants' reply brief was filed October 27, 2026. As of the docket's last update on November 6, 2026, no oral argument date and no decision appear.
The rule: Pending. The district court's dismissal stands unless and until the Fifth Circuit rules otherwise. The Johnson Amendment remains in force for every 501(c)(3), including the plaintiffs.
Sources: Fifth Circuit docket No. 26-40237 (CourtListener, updated Nov. 6, 2026); Shumaker client alert, Sept. 24, 2026; CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11447
The two cases
Both sides have serious arguments and serious evidence. These are the strongest points for each, drawn from court opinions and the public record.
The case for disclosure
- The Court has upheld compelled membership disclosure where the group itself was tied to intimidation and violence: in Bryant (1928) it said a state is entitled to know who composes an oath-bound secret society and that public filing deters wrongdoing. NAACP v. Alabama distinguished that case; it did not overrule it. law.cornell.edu
- Even the NAACP did not claim blanket secrecy: in 1958 it conceded the state could obtain its charter, purposes, officers, staff, total membership and dues, and the Court said it asserted no absolute immunity from state investigation. Only rank-and-file names were protected, and only because the state's stated reason had no real connection to them. law.cornell.edu
- Justice Clark's dissent in Talley: identification rules deter fraud, false advertising and libel; Talley showed no risk of reprisal; and Congress had long required disclosure from second-class mail publishers, lobbyists and campaign-literature sponsors. law.cornell.edu
- Buckley's three interests: disclosure tells voters where campaign money comes from and how it is spent, which helps them place candidates and predict whom they will answer to; it deters corruption and its appearance by exposing large gifts; and it supplies the records needed to detect violations of contribution limits. (424 U.S. at 66-68.) law.cornell.edu
- Kennedy for eight Justices in Citizens United: disclosure and disclaimers do not stop anyone from speaking, are a less restrictive alternative to banning speech, and let shareholders and citizens hold corporations and elected officials accountable and weigh messages by their source. (Part IV.) law.cornell.edu
- Scalia in Doe v. Reed: there are laws against threats and intimidation, harsh criticism short of unlawful action is a price of self-government, and requiring people to stand up publicly for their political acts builds the civic courage democracy depends on. law.cornell.edu
- Treasury's own rulemaking record shows that 19 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia said they use Schedule B information for charity oversight and that losing it would cost them time and money; commenters also warned that without annual donor names it is harder to detect foreign or government-contractor money reaching elections through 501(c)(4) and (c)(6) groups. federalregister.gov
- The House Ways and Means chairman, a Republican, argued in 2024 that current law lets foreign nationals route money through tax-exempt groups to political committees and that the public deserves to know whether advocacy is funded from abroad. waysandmeans.house.gov
- Courts have treated conditions on tax exemption as a choice by Congress not to subsidize certain activity rather than a ban on speech: the D.C. Circuit said a church that wants to campaign can do so through a separate, non-deductible affiliate. govinfo.gov
The case for privacy
- Disclosure can work as punishment by proxy: the NAACP made an uncontested showing that when members' identities had been revealed they faced economic reprisal, loss of employment and threats of physical coercion, and the Court held it does not matter that private citizens rather than officials carry out the retaliation. law.cornell.edu
- The chilling effect was measurable: in Bates there was evidence that members declined to renew once the ordinance passed and that people publicly identified as NAACP members were harassed and threatened. law.cornell.edu
- Disclosure demands were used as a litigation weapon: Alabama's member-list order kept the NAACP out of the state for eight years and required four Supreme Court decisions to undo. law.cornell.edu
- Buckley itself: compelled disclosure can seriously infringe privacy of association and belief, which is why it must survive exacting scrutiny; the Court added that small contributors are especially sensitive to exposure and that low thresholds may discourage participation. (424 U.S. at 64, 83.) law.cornell.edu
- Chief Justice Burger, dissenting in part in Buckley: no public right to know justifies forcing disclosure of $10 or $100 contributions that cannot plausibly corrupt anyone, at the cost of discouraging them. law.cornell.edu
- Stevens for seven Justices in McIntyre: anonymous pamphleteering is an honorable tradition of advocacy and dissent, and anonymity protects unpopular individuals from retaliation and their ideas from suppression. Thomas, concurring: the founding generation understood press freedom to include anonymous political writing. law.cornell.edu
- Government has used tax files to go after donors: the Church Committee documented that the FBI obtained the tax returns of Martin Luther King Jr. and the SCLC and that an FBI field office proposed forging letters to frighten the group's contributors. intelligence.senate.gov
- A contributor list the IRS compiled while auditing Students for a Democratic Society was passed to the FBI and then to the White House. intelligence.senate.gov
- Both parties' administrations have done it: the Kennedy-era IRS audited groups picked from magazine articles about the right wing, and the Nixon-era IRS kept files on roughly 11,000 people and groups chosen for their politics. intelligence.senate.gov
What each side gets wrong
“Dark money groups disclose nothing.”
501(c)(4), (c)(5) and (c)(6) groups file public Form 990s showing revenue, spending, pay and grants, and must report federal independent expenditures over $250 a year and electioneering communications over $10,000 a year to the FEC. What stays private is who gave them the money; since May 28, 2020 they no longer send donor names to the IRS either, though they must keep them. federalregister.gov
“Super PACs are dark money.”
Super PACs must disclose their donors to the FEC. The overlap is partial: of the $5.1B super PACs raised in 2024, about $1.3B (roughly a quarter, computed) came from nonprofits and shell companies that do not disclose their own donors. brennancenter.org
“Dark money is mostly a right-wing phenomenon.”
That was true from 2008 through 2016: conservative groups accounted for 88% of FEC-reported dark money in 2010, 86% in 2012, 70% in 2014 and 78% in 2016. Since 2018 liberal groups have led every cycle on that measure (55%, 71%, 47%, 58%), and on the broader measure Democratic-aligned dark money was more than $514M vs about $200M in 2020 and about $1.2B vs $664M in 2024. brennancenter.org
“Dark money is a left-wing invention, or the left has always dominated it.”
Conservative groups spent $269.2M of the record $312.5M in FEC-reported dark money in 2012, and Republican-aligned One Nation was the single largest dark money group in both 2020 (about $125M) and 2022 ($146.5M). The largest known single gift to a political nonprofit, $1.6B, went to the conservative Marble Freedom Trust. In 2022, counting unreported issue ads, the two sides were close. opensecrets.org
“Dark money is the majority of election spending.”
The broadest 2024 estimate, more than $1.9B, is roughly 13% of the about $14.8B total cost of the 2024 federal elections (computed). Dark money that groups reported spending directly to the FEC was about 1% or less ($170M on OpenSecrets' data page; about $43M by the Brennan Center's count of nonprofits). opensecrets.org
“The Tappan brothers are an example of anonymous donors being protected by privacy.”
They gave openly; Arthur Tappan was the named president of the American Anti-Slavery Society from its founding in December 1833. Their story shows retaliation against known funders, which is an argument about what exposure can cost - not evidence about anonymous giving. archive.org
“NAACP v. Alabama (1958) established that the government can never demand an organization's member or donor list.”
The Court said the NAACP claimed no absolute immunity from investigation, required the state to show a compelling interest with a real connection to the names, and distinguished - without overruling - Bryant, where disclosure was upheld against the Klan because of its record of violence and total non-compliance. law.cornell.edu
“Only conservative groups were targeted by the IRS.”
Most flagged applications were conservative, but not all. The 2013 audit found that 202 of the 298 flagged cases did not have Tea Party, Patriots or 9/12 in their names, and the Senate Finance Committee's joint findings say some left-leaning applicants were put on lookout lists and delayed. The 2017 audit confirmed small numbers of cases selected under terms like Occupy, ACORN Successors, Emerge and Progressive. What is true is that every Tea Party-named application in the samples was pulled, and the IRS's own 2012 tally found about three-quarters of the flagged 501(c)(4) cases looked conservative and fewer than ten looked liberal. tigta.gov
“The 2017 inspector general report showed the IRS treated left and right the same and debunked the scandal.”
The 2017 report says it did not judge whether any of the 17 criteria were appropriate, could not tell how many cases were actually selected under 16 of them because no tracking sheets existed, could confirm only 83 cases across all 17 criteria over nine years, and did not compare their treatment with the Tea Party cases. It left the 2013 findings standing. For 'Progressive', it confirmed four cases, all from 2005-06. tigta.gov
“The inspector general (or Congress) proved the targeting was ordered by the White House or driven by political bias.”
The 2013 audit reports that IRS officials said no one outside the IRS influenced the criteria and it did not assess political leanings or motive. The Justice Department found mismanagement but no evidence of political or corrupt motive that would support charges, and declined again in 2017 under a Republican attorney general. The Senate Finance staffs agreed on mismanagement but split along party lines on bias and on White House involvement. govinfo.gov
“Citizens United created 'dark money' or allowed secret political spending.”
The same opinion upheld donor-disclosure and disclaimer rules for the ads at issue by 8-1, with only Justice Thomas dissenting on that point. Undisclosed spending comes from other rules: 501(c) groups are not political committees and report to the FEC only when they make independent expenditures or electioneering communications, and the tax code keeps their donor lists (Schedule B) non-public. law.cornell.edu
“CREW v. FEC (2018) ended dark money in federal elections.”
It struck one narrow FEC rule. Non-committee groups that make more than $250 in independent expenditures must now list donors of more than $200 whose contributions were earmarked for political purposes. Donors who give for a group's general operations, and groups that stick to issue advocacy, are not covered. fec.gov
“AFPF v. Bonta struck down campaign-finance disclosure (or public disclosure of donors).”
Bonta involved charities' confidential filings of IRS Schedule B with California's Attorney General, not election spending and not public disclosure. Since Bonta, federal appeals courts have upheld election-disclosure laws in Rhode Island, San Francisco and Arizona; the Tenth Circuit struck Wyoming's as applied to one group. law.cornell.edu
“The IRS repealed the Johnson Amendment in 2025, so churches can now endorse candidates.”
The IRS joined a proposed consent judgment that would have protected two named churches for speech to their congregations in connection with services. The judge refused to enter it and dismissed the case on March 31, 2026. The statute is unchanged, an appeal was pending in November 2026, and promised Treasury guidance had not appeared. storage.courtlistener.com
“The 2020 rule ended donor reporting to the IRS.”
It ended annual reporting of donor names and addresses for groups other than 501(c)(3)s. Charities and 527 political organizations still report names; all groups still report contribution amounts; and the affected groups must keep the names and hand them over in an examination. federalregister.gov
More corrections (45)
“501(c)(3) charities can't lobby at all.”
Public charities may lobby as long as it is not a substantial part of their activity, or up to a sliding cap that tops out at $1,000,000 a year if they elect the 501(h) test. It is private foundations that are effectively barred, and it is candidate campaigning, not lobbying, that is flatly prohibited for all 501(c)(3)s. irs.gov
“Every big outside spending group is a super PAC, and ActBlue and WinRed are just payment processors.”
FEC records today list Future Forward (FF PAC), House Majority PAC (HMP), Congressional Leadership Fund (CLF), Priorities USA Action, American Bridge (AB PAC) and AFP Action as hybrid PACs with two accounts, not pure super PACs. ActBlue and WinRed are themselves FEC-registered committees of the same hybrid type and file their own reports. fec.gov
“Federal donors who give less than $200 are always anonymous.”
A campaign itemizes only donors whose gifts total more than $200, but a conduit that forwards earmarked contributions must report the name and address of every contributor regardless of amount. That is why small-dollar donors who give through ActBlue or WinRed appear in public FEC data. ecfr.gov
“Southern authorities posted a $20,000 (or $50,000, or $100,000) bounty on Arthur Tappan.”
The amounts trace to newspaper reports and rumor. The 1835 Evening Post piece relays a Charleston paper's mention of a report that a $20,000 purse had been made up in New Orleans; Lewis Tappan himself called the $100,000 figure a rumor and thought a printed fifty-dollar notice was satire. The often-cited $50,000 East Feliciana Parish offer could not be traced to any loadable source; one modern author attributes $50,000 to a Norfolk, Virginia rally instead. econlib.org
“A Klansman was convicted for refusing to disclose membership, and the Supreme Court upheld his conviction (Bryant v. Zimmerman).”
Bryant was arrested and held on a charge of remaining in a Klan chapter he knew had not filed; the case was a habeas corpus challenge to the statute, and the Court affirmed the refusal to release him. There was no trial or conviction in the record before the Court. The vote was 8-1, with McReynolds objecting only on jurisdiction. law.cornell.edu
“The NAACP won in 1958 and went back to work in Alabama.”
Alabama's courts kept the ban in place. It took further Supreme Court rulings in 1959, 1961 and 1964 - the last exactly eight years after the June 1, 1956 order - before the NAACP could operate there again. law.cornell.edu
“In Gibson the Florida committee demanded the NAACP's entire membership list.”
An earlier committee tried that and the Florida Supreme Court stopped it. The 1959 order at issue required Gibson to bring the list and consult it about fourteen named individuals; he offered to answer from memory instead. The Supreme Court ruled for him 5-4 because the committee had shown no substantial link between the branch and Communist activity. law.cornell.edu
“Talley's leaflets were completely anonymous.”
They carried the name, post office box and telephone number of the sponsoring organization. What they lacked was the names and addresses of the individuals who wrote, printed and distributed them, which the ordinance demanded. law.cornell.edu
“A mob burned down (or demolished) Lewis Tappan's house in 1834.”
By his own account the house was broken into and sacked on July 9, 1834: windows and furnishings smashed, furniture thrown into the street and bedding burned there. The building was damaged, not destroyed. archive.org
“Membership-disclosure laws were invented by segregationists to attack the NAACP.”
The technique was first aimed at the Ku Klux Klan: New York's 1923 law was upheld in Bryant, and the Louisiana list-filing statute used against the NAACP was described to the Court as a 1924 anti-Klan measure. The same legal tool served very different ends depending on who held it. law.cornell.edu
“We know exactly who 'Brutus', 'Cato', 'Federal Farmer' and 'Centinel' were.”
The Supreme Court's own footnote in McIntyre hedges every one of those attributions, presenting each as a belief, a probability or a possibility. Only the Publius authorship is settled, and per the Library of Congress no edition labelled each essay with its author until 1818. law.cornell.edu
“The 1835 campaign mailed exactly 175,000 pamphlets (or 'a million pamphlets') to the South.”
The Society's own report counts 1,095,800 printed pieces of all kinds for the year to May 1836, not all of them mailed south. The 175,000 figure for the summer 1835 mailing comes from secondary works and could not be traced to a primary source today. archive.org
“NAACP v. Button was decided in April 1963 and was about membership lists.”
It was decided January 14, 1963, 6-3, and concerned Virginia's attempt to treat NAACP-sponsored litigation as illegal solicitation of legal business. It belongs to the same campaign but is not a disclosure ruling. law.cornell.edu
“Citizens United let corporations give money directly to candidates.”
It did not. The FEC's summary states the ruling did not affect the ban on corporate contributions; the Court noted Citizens United had made no direct contributions and had not asked it to revisit contribution limits. The decision concerned independent spending only. fec.gov
“Citizens United created super PACs, and super PACs are dark money.”
Super PACs came from the D.C. Circuit's SpeechNow decision (March 26, 2010) and two FEC advisory opinions of July 22, 2010. SpeechNow unanimously upheld registration and donor reporting, so super PAC donors are public. Anonymity can arise when a donor to a super PAC is itself a nonprofit or company that does not reveal its own funders. fec.gov
“California leaked exactly 1,778 donor lists and a hacker could download every Schedule B.”
The trial court found 1,778 confidential Schedule Bs had been posted on the registry's public site (38 discovered the day before trial). The Supreme Court's opinion rounds that to nearly 2,000 and says an expert could reach several hundred thousand confidential registry documents by changing a digit in the URL. Use the trial court's number with attribution. pacificlegal.org
“The courts examined the Proposition 8 harassment evidence and found it insufficient (disclosure-side telling); or, the Prop 8 donors' experience proves the harassment exemption protects people (privacy-side telling).”
The district court ruled for the state in 2011, but the Ninth Circuit in 2014 did not reach the merits of the exemption claim: it held the request moot because the names had already been public for years and ordered that part of the lower ruling vacated. No court ever granted Prop 8 donors an exemption, and none finally adjudicated their evidence on appeal. wlo.willamette.edu
“Justice Thomas's Citizens United dissent catalogued only attacks on conservatives.”
His examples were mostly about Proposition 8 supporters, but he also cited a report that a Yes-on-8 committee threatened to publish the company name of a donor to the No side unless he also gave to Yes on 8, and a business community afraid to fund a challenger to a sitting state attorney general. law.cornell.edu
“Brendan Eich's Proposition 8 donation was exposed by an IRS leak.”
It was in California's public campaign-finance records from the start, searchable through a Los Angeles Times database. The IRS episode involved a different document, the National Organization for Marriage's donor schedule. reason.com
“McIntyre established a general constitutional right to anonymous political spending.”
McIntyre protected an individual's unsigned leaflets and expressly distinguished Buckley's disclosure of campaign money. The Court later upheld donor disclosure in McConnell (2003) and Citizens United (2010) and petition disclosure in Doe v. Reed (2010), each time with only Justice Thomas dissenting on anonymity grounds. law.cornell.edu
“Buckley's 'magic words' footnote was written to limit disclosure.”
Footnote 52 is attached to the Court's narrowing of an expenditure LIMIT (sec. 608(e)(1)). The Court then borrowed the same express-advocacy construction for the independent-spender disclosure provision (sec. 434(e)). McConnell and Citizens United later held disclosure may reach beyond magic words. law.cornell.edu
“The DISCLOSE Act failed because a majority of the Senate opposed it.”
It never lost a majority vote. Cloture votes were 57-41 and 59-39 in 2010, 51-44 and 53-45 in 2012, and 49-49 in 2022; each needed 60. It also was not opposed only by Republicans: the ACLU opposed the 2010 bill. senate.gov
“Twenty-three (or some other number of) states have 'banned donor disclosure.'.”
The promoter of the model Personal Privacy Protection Act counts 22 enacting states as of September 2026 (its '23' figure is a broader category). These laws stop state agencies from demanding or releasing nonprofit supporter lists; they do not repeal campaign-finance reporting. unitedforprivacy.com
“The Arizona Supreme Court fully upheld Proposition 211 (or, alternatively, opened the door to striking it down).”
On June 29, 2026 the court rejected the facial challenge 4-3 and held campaign-media donations are not 'private affairs' under the state constitution, but it reinstated the plaintiffs' as-applied claim that disclosure would chill their giving and sent it back for trial. The law remains in force. azcourts.gov
“Brown v. Socialist Workers shows the harassment exemption is routinely available.”
It is the only Supreme Court case in which a political group won the exemption, on a record of firings, gunfire, and decades of FBI surveillance and disruption of a sixty-member party. Later claimants with thinner records have lost. law.cornell.edu
“160 Tea Party applications sat for more than 1,000 days.”
The 2013 audit says 160 of the flagged cases were still open as of December 17, 2012, for periods ranging from 206 to 1,138 days. The average flagged case had been open 574 days. The 160 were not all Tea Party groups and were not all open 1,000 days. web.archive.org
“The judge upheld the Johnson Amendment as constitutional.”
The court ruled only that it lacked jurisdiction under the Anti-Injunction Act and the Declaratory Judgment Act. It did not reach the First Amendment questions and said it was not deciding standing. storage.courtlistener.com
“The Johnson Amendment was debated and aimed at silencing churches.”
It was adopted on the Senate floor in a few sentences with no debate and no recorded vote. Johnson's stated purpose was to extend the existing limit on lobbying to campaign intervention; churches were not mentioned. The usual story about his motive, tax-exempt groups backing his primary opponent, is not in the record. govinfo.gov
“The IRS regularly strips churches of their exemptions for politics.”
The D.C. Circuit said in 2000 that the Branch Ministries revocation was the first of a bona fide church for political involvement in IRS history, and it remains the only known one. The IRS does open inquiries, as with All Saints Pasadena, but they have ended without revocation. govinfo.gov
“The Kennedy audit project was launched by the Reuther Memorandum.”
The Church Committee traces it to an IRS memo written November 30, 1961, the day after President Kennedy's news conference remark, and to a list sent December 20, 1961. The Reuther memo is usually dated December 19, 1961, after the IRS had already begun, and the Committee's IRS chapter does not mention it. The memo may have reinforced the effort; the documented trigger was the President's own words. intelligence.senate.gov
“Nixon's enemies list led to IRS audits of the people on it.”
The impeachment article charged that Nixon 'endeavored' to misuse the IRS. Accounts of the period say the IRS commissioner and Treasury secretary locked the list away, and a congressional staff review found no audits resulted from it. The documented IRS abuse of the era was the separate Special Service Staff. (The Walters-Shultz details were not fetched from a primary source today.) govinfo.gov
“The Special Service Staff was an effective tool of political punishment through taxes.”
It was intrusive but produced little: 225 referrals from 11,458 files and about $622,000 in assessments, most of it from four cases. The harm the Church Committee identified was the surveillance and selection by politics itself. intelligence.senate.gov
“A federal court ruled that hiding donor names from the IRS was illegal.”
Bullock v. IRS set aside the 2018 change only because the IRS skipped notice and comment. The judge said he was not assessing the merits. The IRS then made the same change through rulemaking. govinfo.gov
“The IRS deliberately leaked the National Organization for Marriage's donors to its opponents.”
The government conceded an unauthorized release by a clerk and paid $50,000, but the court found insufficient evidence that it was willful, and the man who received the document refused to testify. Intent was never established either way. govexec.com
“The ProPublica leak was just a few billionaires' tax returns.”
The IRS later told Congress that 405,427 taxpayers were affected, 89 percent of them businesses. Nonprofits were in the data as well, though no publication of nonprofit donor lists from the leak has been shown. nationalreview.com
“Harvard lost its tax-exempt status.”
It did not. A year after the 2025 reports, Harvard's magazine found no evidence the IRS had taken steps to revoke. Separate proposed rules on discrimination by schools were issued in September 2026 and are not final. harvardmagazine.com
“The courts struck down IRS data sharing with ICE (or, alternatively, approved it).”
Both are half right. The D.C. Circuit let the agreement stand on its face in February 2026 and in September 2026 upheld an injunction against the way the exchange was actually carried out. everycrsreport.com
“Tax returns have always been confidential.”
Strict statutory confidentiality dates from 1976. Before that, the Church Committee found, other federal agencies could get returns and contributor lists from the IRS on request. intelligence.senate.gov
“The 2024 election cost $15.9 billion and was the most expensive ever.”
$15.9B was OpenSecrets' pre-election projection. Its cost-of-election table now shows about $14.8B for 2024, which is below 2020 in both nominal ($15.1B) and inflation-adjusted ($18.3B) terms. opensecrets.org
“Big political money all comes from one side's billionaires.”
Disclosed megadonor money leaned right in 2024 (the six largest individual donors, led by Elon Musk at $291.5M, gave almost entirely to Republicans, and conservative super PACs made 65% of super PAC independent expenditures), while undisclosed money leaned left (about $1.2B vs $664M). In 2020 liberal outside groups outspent conservative ones ($1.58B vs $1.29B). opensecrets.org
“Sixteen Thirty Fund still raises about $390 million a year.”
$389.7M was its 2020 peak. It reported $190.7M in 2021, $191.5M in 2022, $181.4M in 2023 and $282.2M in 2024. projects.propublica.org
“The 'Arabella network' is a $1.5 billion political machine.”
The five funds' 2024 Form 990s do sum to about $1.5B in revenue, but roughly 78% of that went to three 501(c)(3) charities that cannot fund campaigns, and inter-fund grants are double-counted. The firm Arabella Advisors itself is closing; its administrative business was sold to Sunflower Services in November 2025. philanthropy.com
“Unions are the biggest money in politics / business always outspends labor.”
Both are oversimplified. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce alone spent more on federal lobbying in 2024 ($76.4M) than the whole labor sector ($54.7M), but labor put about $288M into the 2024 federal elections, including $212.8M to outside groups, and labor PACs raised slightly more than corporate PACs ($402.4M vs $390.5M). opensecrets.org
“Charitable giving is mostly foundations and corporations, and it was $592.5 billion in 2024 and $617.2 billion in 2025.”
Individuals gave 64% of the 2025 total and bequests another 10%; foundations 19%, corporations 7%. The two headline totals are not a clean series: Giving USA revised 2024, and the 5.7% growth it reports implies a 2024 base near $584B. givingusa.org
“The National Philanthropic Trust DAF Report says...”
NPT stopped publishing the report after its 2024 edition. The current source is the DAF Research Collaborative's Annual DAF Report, whose FY2024 figures were revised in spring 2026 to $327.87B in assets, $90.57B in contributions, $64.60B in grants and 3.59M accounts. dafresearchcollaborative.org
How this page was checked
Five research passes run on 2026-11-19 (entity rules; history to 1963; courts and legislation since 1907; IRS and government custody of data; numbers). Each fact was checked against a page fetched that day with WebFetch or curl: U.S. Code and CFR (law.cornell.edu, ecfr.gov), irs.gov, fec.gov, Federal Register, govinfo.gov, Supreme Court opinions at Cornell LII and the Court's own docket pages, CourtListener/RECAP court filings, TIGTA, the Church Committee report (S. Rep. 94-755, Book III), Senate and House roll-call pages, CRS reports, IRS Data Book spreadsheets, ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (Form 990 extracts), Giving USA, the DAF Research Collaborative, the Brennan Center, and news outlets for events. url_checks records what each URL returned. Records marked 'verified' may still carry specific sub-claims that could not be confirmed; those are spelled out in each record's notes and should be read before publishing. The lead compiler then re-fetched a sample of the highest-risk and most recent claims (see lead_spot_check fields and meta.lead_spot_checks) and corrected one date (the FEC's Carey statement is October 6, 2011, not October 5). Entries marked “not confirmed” could not be checked against a source read directly. For campaign money, see the rules.