The holiday debt hangover
Most Decembers bring a new dollar record for holiday sales, and every January brings the credit card bills. Are we borrowing our way into oblivion to pay for things that don’t make us any richer? Here is what three decades of data say, and what actually raises a family’s income.
The numbers
Holiday sales, 2025
$972B
November–December retail, NRF definition. NRF forecasts $1.01T for 2026.
Household debt
$21.3T
All debt owed by U.S. households and nonprofits, Q2 2026. About $152,675 per household in 2025.
Debt ÷ median income
1.75×
Average debt per household as a multiple of the median household’s income in 2025 (peak: 2.43× in 2007). The average includes the roughly one in four households with no debt. The typical family with debt owes about 1.1× its income ($88,390 vs. $82,162, Survey of Consumer Finances 2025).
Credit card balances
$1.3T
12.9% of balances are 90+ days late.
The short answer
- Not on the whole. Measured against income, household debt is lower than before the 2008 crash: 1.75× the median income in 2025, down from 2.43× in 2007. Against total after-tax income it was 91% in 2025, down from 136% in 2007 and the lowest since 1995. Most debt is mortgages backed by homes; borrowing for goods and services was 4% of family debt in the 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances.
- Holiday spending hasn’t outrun incomes. Holiday sales were 5.2% of Americans’ after-tax income in 1992 and 4.2% in 2025. Per household, after inflation, they rose 18% while median household income rose 24%, though the two ran close in some recent years. The holidays are also a smaller share of the year’s shopping than in the 1990s.
- But the hangover is real for the families carrying it. Card balances rose $44B in the last quarter of 2025, then fell $35B by spring (net of new spending and write-offs). 12.9% of card balances are seriously delinquent, and 10.7% of families with debt fell 60 or more days behind on a payment in the 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances, the highest share since 2010. The personal saving rate is 4.1%, below its 2010–19 average of 6.1%.
- Borrowing moves spending forward; it doesn’t create income. What has raised American living standards is producing more: output per hour worked is about 5.3 times its 1948 level, and incomes rise when more people work. That’s the old idea behind Say’s Law: we pay for what we buy with what we produce. See the theory and the evidence →